Showing posts with label Successive cause of action. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Successive cause of action. Show all posts

Saturday, 29 August 2020

How order 2 R 2 of CPC applies to arbitration proceeding?

Supreme Court, in Dolphin Drilling Ltd. Vs. Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. MANU/SC/0120/2010 : (2010) 3 SCC 267 held that the words "all disputes" in arbitration clause can only mean "all disputes that may be in existence when the arbitration clause is invoked and one of the parties to the agreement gives the arbitration notice to the other"; it cannot be held that once the arbitration clause is invoked, the remedy of arbitration is no longer available in regard to other disputes that might arise in future. We may add, that depending on nature of the agreement or obligations to be performed thereunder, it is not necessary that all disputes between parties arise at one point of time. This Court in National Highways Authority of India Vs. ITD Cementation India Ltd. MANU/DE/6011/2012 : 197 (2013) DLT 650 held that in large scale projects, it is not unheard that different facets of the project constitute subject matter of separate references and in the context of large scale works contracts, there cannot be any rigid application of the principles of Order II Rule 2 of the CPC unless it is demonstrated that prejudice has been caused to either party as a result of such non-adherence. We may further add that even if commencement of arbitration with respect to disputes which have arisen, can await culmination of full performance of the agreement, to commence arbitration at one time only, also with respect to other dispute which may arise, the claim earliest arising may by then become barred by time. Order II Rule 2 of the CPC also envisages successive causes of action.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

FAO (OS) (COMM) 60/2020 and CM No. 10461/2020

Decided On: 07.07.2020

 Hero Wind Energy Private Ltd. Vs.   Inox Renewables Limited and Ors.
Print Page

Whether petition for interim measures U/S 9(3) of Arbitration Act is maintainable before the court if Arbitration tribunal is in existence from the same agreement?

 In our opinion, the words 'Arbitral Tribunal' in Section 9(3) of the Act have to take colour from all the said provisions and thus have to be interpreted as Arbitral Tribunal constituted to adjudicate the disputes which have arisen and been referred to arbitration and with respect whereto Arbitrators have been appointed and notified of their appointment. Much prior to the incorporation of Sub-Section (3) in Section 9, Supreme Court in Firm Ashok Traders Vs. Gurumukh Das Saluja MANU/SC/0026/2004 : (2004) 3 SCC 155 held, that under the 1996 Arbitration Act, unlike the predecessor Act of 1940, the Arbitral Tribunal is empowered by Section 17 of the Act to make orders amounting to interim measures; the need for Section 9 of the Act, inspite of Section 17 having been enacted, is that Section 17 of the Act would operate only during the existence of the Arbitral Tribunal and its being functional; during that period, the power conferred on the Arbitral Tribunal under Section 17 of the Act and the power conferred on the Court under Section 9 of the Court may overlap to some extent but so far as the period pre and post the arbitral proceedings is concerned, the party requiring an interim measure shall have to approach only the Court. Seen in this light, the Arbitral Tribunal constituted with reference to the disputes which had earlier arisen, even though from the same agreement, cannot be the Arbitral Tribunal within the meaning of Section 9(3) of the Act even if were to be of the same composition. Section 9(3) of the Act does away with the jurisdiction of the Court with respect to interim measures also, once the Arbitral Tribunal is constituted. However, if a separate Arbitral Tribunal even if of same composition is to be constituted for disputes arising out of successive causes of action, Arbitral Tribunal constituted for adjudication of disputes arisen from a earlier cause of action cannot be the Arbitral Tribunal constituted for the disputes arising from a subsequent cause of action and qua which interim measures are sought.
32. We are thus unable to agree with the view taken by the learned Single Judge, of the petition of Hero being barred by Section 9(3) of the Act.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

FAO (OS) (COMM) 60/2020 and CM No. 10461/2020

Decided On: 07.07.2020

 Hero Wind Energy Private Ltd. Vs.   Inox Renewables Limited and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Rajiv Sahai Endlaw and Asha Menon, JJ.

Author:  Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.
Citation: MANU/DE/1349/2020
Print Page