Showing posts with label admission of documents. Show all posts
Showing posts with label admission of documents. Show all posts

Friday, 5 August 2016

Whether admission of documents may amount to admission of its truth?

Thus, the question that arises for consideration is whether in absence of any oral evidence having been tendered by the appellants, and especially in absence of putting their own defence to the respondent during his cross examination in the Court, what is the effect of documents filed by appellants and marked as Exhibits.
21.Despite our persistent requests made to the learned counsel appearing for the appellants they have not been able to show compliance of Order XII Rule 1 and 2 of the CPC, meaning thereby that there has not been any compliance thereof.
22.Order XII, Rules 1 and 2 appearing in the Code of Civil Procedure reads as thus:
"ORDER XII ADMISSIONS
1. Notice of admission of case. - Any party to a suit may give notice, by his pleading, or othewise in writing, that he admits the truth of the whole or any part of the case of any other party.
2. Notice to admit documents. - Either party may call upon the other party to admit, within seven days from the date of service of the notice any document, saving all just exceptions; and in case of refusal or neglect to admit, after such notice, the costs of proving any such document shall be paid by the party so neglecting or refusing, what- ever the result of the suit may be, unless the Court otherwise directs; and no costs of proving any document shall be allowed unless such notice is given, except where the omission to give the notice is, in the opinion of the Court, a saving of expense."
23.It is also necessary to mention here that Rule 2A of Order XII of the CPC deals with the situation where notice of admission as contemplated in Order XII Rule 2 of the CPC has been served but is not denied then the same shall be deemed to have been admitted. Similarly, Rule 3A of the aforesaid Order grants power to the Court to admit any document in evidence, even if no notice has been served. The aforesaid provisions of law have been brought in the Code vide Amendment by Act No. 104 of 1976, w.e.f. 1.2.1977.
24.Records do not reveal that any such procedure was adopted either by the appellants or by the Trial Court to prove the documents filed by the appellants and mark them as Exhibits. Thus, no advantage thereof could be accrued to the appellants, even if it is assumed that said documents have been admitted by respondent and were then exhibited and marked.
We are of the firm opinion that mere admission of document in evidence does not amount to its proof. In other words, mere marking of exhibit on a document does not dispense with its proof, which is required to be done in accordance with law. As has been mentioned herein above, despite perusal of the record, we have not been able to come to know as to under what circumstances respondent plaintiff had admitted those documents. Even otherwise, his admission of those documents cannot carry the case of the appellants any further and much to the prejudice of the respondent.
Under the Law of Evidence also, it is necessary that contents of documents are required to be proved either by primary or by secondary evidence. At the most, admission of documents may amount to admission of contents but not its truth. Documents having not been produced and marked as required under the Evidence Act cannot be relied upon by the Court. Contents of the document cannot be proved by merely filing in a court.
 REPORTABLE
Supreme Court of India
L.I.C. Of India & Anr vs Ram Pal Singh Bisen on 16 March, 2010

Bench: B. Sudershan Reddy, Deepak Verma
           C.A. No.893 of 2007                          

Citation:2010(2) ALLMR970
Print Page

Friday, 15 April 2016

When document shall be deemed to be admitted if not denied specifically?

 I have considered the rival circumstances and the
submissions made. One of the objects of Order 12 Rule 2A of
C.P.C. is to curtail the time taken for recording of evidence and
exhibiting the documents and thereby expediting the trial. Order
12 Rule 2A of C.P.C. in turn provides that every document which a
party is called upon to admit, if not denied specifically or by
necessary implication, or stated to be not admitted in the pleading
of that party or in his reply to the notice to admit documents, shall
be deemed to be admitted except as against a person under a
disability. The proviso to Order 12 Rule 2A(1) of C.P.C. states that
the Court in its discretion and for reasons to be recorded require
any document so admitted to be proved, otherwise than by such
admission.
It can thus be seen that once, in pursuance of a notice
to admit the documents, the party concerned does not deny the
documents specifically or by necessary implication, the same shall
be deemed to be admitted. In fact, there was no dispute denying
the arguments at the Bar that the documents will have to be
treated to be admitted in evidence. The only question is about
marking of exhibits. Normally, mere marking of documents as
exhibits does not amount to proof and it is always open to the
Court to decide the same in accordance with law. The format of
notice as provided in Form No. 9 of Appendix C in the C.P.C. would
also show that the admission as envisaged under Order 12 Rule 3
of C.P.C. is subject to all just exceptions to the admissibility of
such documents as evidence in such suits. Both the cased cited on
behalf of the respondents arose out of a situation where the
parties had led oral evidence. In other words, in none of the cases
cited above, there was a notice to admit documents given. Be that
as it may, having regard to the provisions of Order 12 Rule 2A of
C.P.C. and the fact that the documents are not specifically denied,
the documents will have to be treated as admitted, subject to all
just exceptions as to the admissibility of the documents as
evidence. Thus, the petition will have to succeed. Accordingly, the
impugned order is hereby set aside. The application filed by the
petitioner is allowed. The documents produced alongwith notice to
admit the documents shall be treated to be admitted, subject to all
just exceptions to their admissibility as evidence.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA
WRIT PETITION NO. 653 OF 2015
M/s Sociedade de Fomento
Industrial Limited,

 Versus
Smt. Sita Shripad Narvekar,


CORAM:- C. V. BHADANG, J.
 DATE:- 19thOCTOBER, 2015.
Citation;2016(2) MHLJ 958,2016(2) ALLMR107
Print Page

Saturday, 10 October 2015

Whether referring to charge sheet for purpose of seeking discharge can be treated as admission of fact or documents by accused?

Clearly, such an approach of the Special Judge is not only erroneous but it too resulted in grave and serious prejudice to the accused. It is clear, that because of this approach, the Special Judge did not give any reasons for rejecting the applications for discharge and held that prosecution has prima facie made out a case against the accused. Relying on, or referring to charge sheet for the purpose of seeking discharge, cannot, by any stretch of imagination be treated as admission of fact or documents by the accused'. Hence, these observations in para 10 and directions in para 11 are required to be disregarded and neglected. The present Special Judge shall not take them into consideration for any purpose whatsoever.

Bombay High Court

Nirmal Kumar Pal & Others vs The Central Bureau Of ... on 25 June, 1999
Equivalent citations: 1999 (5) BomCR 898, 1999 (3) MhLj 390

Bench: D Deshpande
Print Page

Saturday, 3 January 2015

Admission of documents may amount to admission of contents but not its truth

 As has been held by the Apex Court in LICI Vs. Rampal Singh Bisen reported in (2010) 4 SCC 491, admission of documents in evidence does not amount to its proof, in other words, merely making of exhibit or a document does not dispense with its proof, which is required to be done in accordance with law. The documentary evidence adduced by the petitioner was also required to be proved in accordance with the provisions of the Evidence act which he failed to do. Under the Law of Evidence it is necessary that contents of documents are required to be proved either by primary or by secondary evidence. At the most, admission of documents may also to admission of contents but not its truth. Apart from the aforesaid position of the case, the documents were also not produced and marked as required under the Evidence Act. Needless to say that the contents of the documents cannot be proved by merely filing in a Court.

IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(THE HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
WP(C) NO.22/2014

 Rezia Khatun, V The Union of India,

BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE B.K. SHARMA

Date of Judgment : .03.2014

Read original judgment here; click here
Print Page