Showing posts with label adverse finding. Show all posts
Showing posts with label adverse finding. Show all posts

Saturday, 3 August 2024

Supreme court: Respondent in appeal can without filling cross-objections attack adverse finding upon which decree has been passed against him

We hold that the respondent-defendant in an appeal can, without filing cross-objections attack an adverse finding upon which a decree in part has been passed against the respondent, for the purpose sustaining the decree to the extent the lower court had dismissed the suit against the defendants-respondents. The filing of cross-objection, after the 1976 Amendment is purely optional and not mandatory. In other words, the law as stated in Venkata Rao's case by the Madras Full Bench and Chandre Prabhuji's case by this Court is merely clarified by the 1976 Amendment and there is no change in the law after the Amendment.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 6036 of 1990

Decided On: 14.09.1999

Ravinder Kumar Sharma Vs. The State of Assam and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

M. Jagannadha Rao and M. Srinivasan, JJ.

Author: M. Jagannadha Rao, J.

Citation: AIR 1999 SC 3571, MANU/SC/0561/1999.

Print Page

Sunday, 18 February 2018

Whether landlord can agitate grounds of eviction negatived by trial court in appeal preferred by tenant?

'Any aggrieved party', the expression employed in Section 20(1), means a person feeling aggrieved by the ultimate decision, that is, the operative part of the order. A party to the proceedings, who has succeeded in securing the relief prayed for is not a party aggrieved though the order contains a finding or two adverse to him. The Respondent can support the order and pray for the ultimate decision being sustained, without filing a revision of his own, and for achieving such end he may seek reversal of any findings recorded against him. However, if the non-petitioning party feels entitled to a more beneficial or larger order in his favour but was allowed a lesser or smaller relief then to the extent of claiming the more beneficial or larger relief he should have filed a revision petition of his own as he was 'an aggrieved party' to that extent.

16. There is, therefore, no doubt in the present case that in a revision preferred under Section 20 of the Act by the tenant laying challenge to the propriety of the decision of the Appellate Authority under Section 11(8) of the Act, the landlord could have urged that the order of eviction could be sustained under Section 11(3) of the Act also. The High Court has not erred in permitting the landlord to urge such a plea in the revision filed by the tenant though the landlord did not file any revision of his own. A landlord who has succeeded in securing an order of eviction on one of the several grounds urged by him cannot be said to be a person aggrieved by such order. He can not file a revision rather he can feel satisfied with the order. The person aggrieved is the tenant and in a revision preferred by the tenant it is only just and equitable that the landlord should be permitted to support the order of eviction by disputing correctness of the finding recorded in the impugned order whereby the availability of additional ground for eviction was negatived. Such a right has to be necessarily spelled out in favour of the landlord who has succeeded from the Court below else there would be grave injustice.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

SLP No. 1599 and 8694 of 2001

Decided On: 08.07.2002

Nalakath Sainuddin Vs. Koorikadan Sulaiman

Hon'ble Judges/Coram: 
R.C. Lahoti and B.N. Agrawal, JJ.
Citation: AIR 2002 SC 2562
Print Page

Sunday, 17 September 2017

Whether a party can challenge adverse finding given against him without filing cross objection?

In terms of Order 41, Rule 22 of the Civil Procedure Code, it is open to the respondents to challenge any finding which is adverse to him without filing a Cross Appeal provided he supports the decree passed in his favour.

14. The Apex Court in the Judgment reported in MANU/SC/0147/2003 : 2003(9) SCC 606 in the case of Banarsi and ors. v. Ram Phal, has observed at Para 10 thus :

"10. The Civil Procedure Code amendment of 1976 has not materially or substantially altered the law except for a marginal difference. Even under the amended Order 41, Rule 22 sub-rule (1) a party in whose favour the decree stands in its entirety is neither entitled nor obliged to prefer any cross-objection. However, the insertion made in the text of sub-rule (1) makes it permissible to file a cross-objection against a finding. The difference which has resulted we will shortly state. A respondent may defend himself without filing any cross-objection to the extent to which decree is in his favour; however, if he proposes to attack any part of the decree he must take cross-objection. The amendment inserted by the 1976 amendment is clarificatory and also enabling and this may be made precise by analysing the provision. There may be three situations :

(i) The impugned decree is partly in favour of the appellant and partly in favour of the respondent.

(ii) The decree is entirely in favour of the respondent though an issue has been decided against the respondent.

(iii) The decree is entirely in favour of the respondent and all the issues have also been answered in favour of the respondent but there is a finding in the judgment which goes against the respondent."

Taking note of the said observation in the present case, the appellant has supported the Decree passed by the learned Trial Judge and, as such, was entitled to question the findings of the learned trial Court adverse to him even without filing cross objections.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA

S.A. No. 23 of 2003

Decided On: 31.03.2017

 Sharad Prabhudas Vs. Sapana Real Estates and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
F.M. Reis, J.

Citation:2017(4) MHLJ 227
Print Page

Sunday, 12 February 2017

Whether critical direction which is unfavourable to respondent can be assailed without filing cross objection?

The settled position in law as is evident from a proper perusal of Nalakath is that even though several points pressed by the victor of a litigation may have been viewed with favour, and the Respondent may have succeeded only one or some, if the matter is taken by the vanquished party to the portals of a superior forum, the victor may still press all the points argued by it earlier. The Judgments of the High Courts which have been analysed by this Court in Nalakath do not go to the extent, as they clearly cannot, that a critical direction which is unfavourable to the Respondent can be assailed even in the absence of filing a cross or a separate appeal. A holistic reading of the impugned judgment discloses that this direction was not given en passant or casually in that in the penultimate paragraph of the impugned judgment the Division Bench emphasised that although they were allowing two writ appeals, they were at pains to reiterate that the success of the Respondents was subject to compliance with the aforementioned directions which we entirely affirm.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Civil Appeal No. 6905 of 2005
Decided On: 29.12.2015
S.K.L. Co.
Vs.
Chief Commercial Officer and Ors.
Coram:Vikramajit Sen and Shiva Kirti Singh, JJ.
Citation:(2015) 16 SCC509
Print Page

Monday, 15 August 2016

Whether mere adverse finding in dismissed suit will act as res judicata in future litigation?

Thus, an appeal does not lie against mere "findings"
recorded by a court unless the findings amount to a "decree"
or "order". Where a suit, is dismissed, the defendant against
whom an adverse finding might have come to be recorded on
some issue, has no right of appeal and he cannot question
those findings before the appellate court. (See Ganga Bai v.
Vinay Kumar (1974) 3 S.C.R.882 : (AIR 1974 SSC 1126).”
30. In case of Smt.Ganga Bai Vs. Vijay Kumar and others,
reported in 1974 SC 1126 it was observed as under:
“17. These provisions show that under the Code of Civil
Procedure, an appeal lies only as against a decree or as
ag1ainst an order passed under rules from which an appeal is
expressly allowed by Order 43, Rule 1. No appeal can lie
against a mere finding for the simple reason that the Code
does not provide for any such appeal. It must follow that First
Appeal No.72 of 1959 filed by defendants 2 and 3 was not
maintainable as it was directed against a mere finding
recorded by the trial Court.”
31. As noted, the plaintiffs did try to appeal against the said
judgment in Civil Suit No.113 of 1973. However, said appeal the
District Court dismissed on the ground of limitation. When he filed
revision, the High Court observed that since the suit is dismissed
any adverse finding would not form res judicata against the
defendants.For all these reasons we do not find any error in the view of
the learned Single Judge. The Letters Patent Appeal is dismissed.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL NO. 333 of 1991
In FIRST APPEAL NO. 771 of 1982

MAHABALLI BOGRA SHETTY THR'LEGAL HEIRS & 
V
SMT.MOHINI THADHARAM CHAWLA SINCE DECSD. THRU LEGAL HEIRS

CORAM: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE AKIL KURESHI
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MOHINDER PAL
Date : 08/09/2015
Citation:AIR 2016(NOC)533 Guj
Print Page

Sunday, 3 July 2016

What is distinction between cross objection in respect of adverse finding and in respect of adverse portion of decree?

 Under R. 22 of Order XLI of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short, "the Code") a party who is aggrieved by a finding can challenge that finding in the appeal preferred by the opposite party even without a Cross Objection. Cross Objection challenging the finding therefore need only be treated as the information given to the appellant about the cross objectors challenging the finding which is adverse to them.
True that under R. 22 of Order XLI of the Code, Cross Objection, has to conform to the requirements of R. 1 of Order XLI of the Code but that is only in the matter of form and contend. If the Cross Objection is against any part of the decree, cross objectors may have to pay court fee as required by law. But, when a Cross Objection is against a finding, I am persuaded to think that it is not necessary for the cross objectors to pay ad valorem court fee; they need only pay petition fee (` 10/-) under Schedule II, Art. 11(t) of the Court Fees and Suits Valuation Act.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA
C.O. No. 16 of 2012 in R.S.A. No. 1233 of 2011
Decided On: 01.03.2012

Peethambara Panicker Vs. Pratheepkumar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:Thomas P. Joseph, J.
Citation:2013 KHC 3685 = 2013 (4) KLT 716

Print Page

When person filing cross objection is not liable to pay court fees?

 Under R. 22 of Order XLI of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short, "the Code") a party who is aggrieved by a finding can challenge that finding in the appeal preferred by the opposite party even without a Cross Objection. Cross Objection challenging the finding therefore need only be treated as the information given to the appellant about the cross objectors challenging the finding which is adverse to them.
True that under R. 22 of Order XLI of the Code, Cross Objection, has to conform to the requirements of R. 1 of Order XLI of the Code but that is only in the matter of form and contend. If the Cross Objection is against any part of the decree, cross objectors may have to pay court fee as required by law. But, when a Cross Objection is against a finding, I am persuaded to think that it is not necessary for the cross objectors to pay ad valorem court fee; they need only pay petition fee (` 10/-) under Schedule II, Art. 11(t) of the Court Fees and Suits Valuation Act.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA
C.O. No. 16 of 2012 in R.S.A. No. 1233 of 2011
Decided On: 01.03.2012

Peethambara Panicker Vs. Pratheepkumar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:Thomas P. Joseph, J.
Citation:2013 KHC 3685 = 2013 (4) KLT 716

Print Page