Showing posts with label antecedent title. Show all posts
Showing posts with label antecedent title. Show all posts

Friday, 31 July 2020

Whether it is mandatory to register a memorandum of family settlement if a family member not having title to the property previously was allocated a particular property?

The settled legal position is
that when by virtue of a family settlement or arrangement,
members of a family descending from a common ancestor or a
near relation seek to sink their differences and disputes, settle
and resolve their conflicting claims or disputed titles once and for all in order to buy peace of mind and bring about complete
harmony and goodwill in the family, such arrangement ought to be governed by a special equity peculiar to them and would be enforced if honestly made. The object of such arrangement is to protect the family from long drawn litigation or perpetual strives which mar the unity and solidarity of the family and create hatred and bad blood between the various members of the family, as observed in Kale (supra). In the said reported decision, a threeJudge  Bench of this Court had observed thus: “
9.….. A family arrangement by which the property is
equitably divided between the various contenders so as to
achieve an equal distribution of wealth instead of
concentrating the same in the hands of a few is
undoubtedly a milestone in the administration of social
justice. That is why the term “family” has to be
understood in a wider sense so as to include within its
fold not only close relations or legal heirs but even those
persons who may have some sort of antecedent title, a
semblance of a claim or even if they have a spes
successionis so that future disputes are sealed for ever
and the family instead of fighting claims inter se and
wasting time, money and energy on such fruitless or futile
litigation is able to devote its attention to more
constructive work in the larger interest of the country.
The courts have, therefore, leaned in favour of
upholding a family arrangement instead of disturbing
the same on technical or trivial grounds. Where the
courts find that the family arrangement suffers from a
legal lacuna or a formal defect the rule of estoppel is
pressed into service and is applied to shut out plea of
the person who being a party to family arrangement
seeks to unsettle a settled dispute and claims to
revoke the family arrangement under which he has
himself enjoyed some material benefits. …..”
(emphasis supplied)
In paragraph 10 of the said decision, the Court has delineated
the contours of essentials of a family settlement as follows: “
10. In other words to put the binding effect and the
essentials of a family settlement in a concretised form,

the matter may be reduced into the form of the following
propositions:
“(1) The family settlement must be a bona fide one
so as to resolve family disputes and rival claims by a
fair and equitable division or allotment of properties
between the various members of the family;
(2) The said settlement must be voluntary and
should not be induced by fraud, coercion or undue
influence;
(3) The family arrangement may be even oral in
which case no registration is necessary;
(4) It is well settled
that registration would be
necessary only if the terms of the family arrangement
are reduced into writing. Here also, a distinction
should be made between a document containing
the terms and recitals of a family arrangement
made under the document and a mere
memorandum prepared after the family
arrangement had already been made either for the
purpose of the record or for information of the
court for making necessary mutation. In such a
case the memorandum itself does not create or
extinguish any rights in immovable properties and
therefore does not fall within the mischief of Section
17(2) of the Registration Act and is, therefore, not
compulsorily registrable;
(5) The members who may be parties to the family
arrangement must have some antecedent title, claim
or interest even a possible claim in the property which
is acknowledged by the parties to the settlement. Even
if one of the parties to the settlement has no title
but under the arrangement the other party
relinquishes all its claims or titles in favour of such
a person and acknowledges him to be the sole
owner, then the antecedent title must be assumed
and the family arrangement will be upheld and the
courts will find no difficulty in giving assent to the
same;
(6) Even if bona fide disputes, present or possible,
which may not involve legal claims are settled by a
bona fide family arrangement which is fair and
equitable the family arrangement is final and binding
on the parties to the settlement.”
(emphasis supplied)

Again, in paragraph 24, this Court restated that a family
arrangement being binding on the parties, clearly operates as an
estoppel, so as to preclude any of the parties who have taken
advantage under the agreement from revoking or challenging the
same. In paragraph 35, the Court noted as follows: “
35. … We have already pointed out that this Court
has widened the concept of an antecedent title by holding
that an antecedent title would be assumed in a person
who may not have any title but who has been allotted a
particular property by other party to the family
arrangement by relinquishing his claim in favour of such
a donee. In such a case the party in whose favour the
relinquishment is made would be assumed to have an
antecedent title. …..”
And again, in paragraph 36, the Court noted as follows: “
36. … Yet having regard to the near relationship
which the brother and the soninlaw
bore to the widow
the Privy Council held that the family settlement by which
the properties were divided between these three parties
was a valid one. In the instant case also putting the case
of Respondents Nos. 4 and 5 at the highest, the position
is that Lachman died leaving a grandson and two
daughters. Assuming that the grandson had no legal title,
so long as the daughters were there, still as the
settlement was made to end the disputes and to benefit
all the near relations of the family, it would be sustained
as a valid and binding family settlement. …”
While rejecting the argument regarding inapplicability of principle
of estoppel, the Court observed as follows: “
38. … Assuming, however, that the said
document was compulsorily registrable the courts
have generally held that a family arrangement being
binding on the parties to it would operate as an

estoppel by preventing the parties after having taken
advantage under the arrangement to resile from the
same or try to revoke it. …..”
(emphasis supplied)
And in paragraph 42, the Court observed as follows: 42.
..… In these circumstances there can be no doubt
that even if the family settlement was not registered
it would operate as a complete estoppel against
Respondents Nos. 4 and 5. Respondent No. 1 as also the
High Court, therefore, committed substantial error of law
in not giving effect to the doctrine of estoppel as spelt out
by this Court in so many cases. …”
(emphasis supplied)
 A priori, we have
no hesitation in affirming the conclusion reached by the first
appellate Court that the document Exhibit P6
was nothing but a
memorandum of a family settlement. The established facts and
circumstances clearly establish that a family settlement was
arrived at in 1970 and also acted upon by the concerned parties.
That finding of fact recorded by the first appellate Court being
unexceptionable, it must follow that the document Exhibit P6
was merely a memorandum of a family settlement so arrived at.
Resultantly, it was not required to be registered and in any case,
keeping in mind the settled legal position, the contesting
defendants were estopped from resiling from the stated
arrangement in the subject memorandum, which had recorded
the settlement terms arrived at in the past and even acted upon
relating to all the existing or future disputes qua the subject
property amongst the (signatories) family members despite
absence of antecedent title to the concerned property.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 7764 OF 2014
Ravinder Kaur Grewal Vs  Manjit Kaur 

A.M. Khanwilkar, J.
Dated: July 31, 2020.
Print Page

Tuesday, 9 May 2017

What is definition of family for purpose of family arrangement?

Reliance was also placed upon judgment in the case of Kale v. Deputy Director of ConsolidationMANU/SC/0529/1976 : (1976) 3 SCC 119 to highlight the nature, effect and value of family arrangement under the Hindu Law. All the three Judges deciding this case were agreed on the relevant proposition that the object of family arrangement is to sink their differences and disputes and resolve their conflicting claims to buy peace of mind and bring about complete harmony and goodwill in the family. Paragraph 9 of the judgment deserves full respect and is extracted hereinafter:
9. Before dealing with the respective contentions put forward by the parties, we would like to discuss in general the effect and value of family arrangements entered into between the parties with a view to resolving disputes once for all. By virtue of a family settlement or arrangement members of a family descending from a common ancestor or a near relation seek to sink their differences and disputes, settle and resolve their conflicting claims or disputed titles once for all in order to buy peace of mind and bring about complete harmony and goodwill in the family. The family arrangements are governed by a special equity peculiar to themselves and would be enforced if honestly made. In this connection,Kerr in his valuable treatise Kerr on Fraud at p.364 makes the following pertinent observations regarding the nature of the family arrangement which may be extracted thus:
The principles which apply to the case of ordinary compromise between strangers do not equally apply to the case of compromises in the nature of family arrangements. Family arrangements are governed by a special equity peculiar to themselves, and will be enforced if honestly made, although they have not been meant as a compromise, but have proceeded from an error of all parties originating in mistake or ignorance of fact as to what their rights actually are, or of the points on which their rights actually depend.
The object of the arrangement is to protect the family from long-drawn litigation or perpetual strifes which mar the unity and solidarity of the family and create hatred and bad blood between the various members of the family. Today when we are striving to build up an egalitarian society and are trying for a complete reconstruction of the society, to maintain and uphold the unity and homogeneity of the family which ultimately results in the unification of the society and, therefore, of the entire country, is the prime need of the hour. A family arrangement by which the property is equitably divided between the various contenders so as to achieve as equal distribution of wealth instead of concentrating the same in the hands of a few is undoubtedly a milestone in the administration of social justice. That is why the term 'family' has to be understood in a wider sense so as to include within its fold not only close relations or legal heirs but even those persons who may have some sort of antecedent title, a semblance of a claim or even if they have a spes successionis so that future disputes are sealed for ever and the family instead of fighting claims inter se and wasting time, money and energy on such fruitless or futile litigation is able to devote its attention to more constructive work in the larger interest of the country. The courts have, therefore, leaned in favour of upholding a family arrangement instead of disturbing the same on technical or trivial grounds. Where the courts find that the family arrangement suffers from a legal lacuna or a formal defect the rule of estoppel is pressed into service and is applied to shut out plea of the person who being a party to family arrangement seeks to unsettle a settled dispute and claims to revoke the family arrangement under which he has himself enjoyed some material benefits. The law in England on this point is almost the same. In Halsbury's Laws of England, Vol. 17, Third Edition, at pp. 215-216, the following apt observations regarding the essentials of the family settlement and the principles governing the existence of the same are made:
A family arrangement is an agreement between members of the same family, intended to be generally or reasonably for the benefit of the family either by compromising doubtful or disputed rights or by preserving the family property or the peace and security of the family by avoiding litigation or by saving its honour.
The agreement may be implied from a long course of dealing, but it is more usual to embody or to effectuate the agreement in a deed to which the term 'family arrangement' is applied.
Family arrangements are governed by principles which are not applicable to dealings between strangers. The court, when deciding the rights of parties under family arrangements or claims to upset such arrangements, considers what in the broadest view of the matter is most for the interest of families, and has regard to considerations which, in dealing with transactions between persons not members of the same family, would not be taken into account. Matters which would be fatal to the validity of similar transactions between strangers are not objections to the binding effect of family arrangements.
The legal principles enunciated above have not been disputed.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Civil Appeal Nos. 3687 of 2006, 503 of 2001 and 2763 of 2002
Decided On: 01.12.2015
Rajni Sanghi Vs. Western Indian State Motors Ltd. and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vikramajit Sen and Shiva Kirti Singh, JJ.

Citation:(2015) 16 SCC 631
Print Page