Showing posts with label appellant. Show all posts
Showing posts with label appellant. Show all posts

Monday, 29 June 2020

Whether appellate court can allow the appeal even if one of the appellants have applied for withdrawal of appeal?

J.K. Bhatia Vs. A.K. Bhatia MANU/DE/8638/2007 : 144 (2007) DLT 28 holding that since Order XXIII Rule 1 (5) mandates that consent of co-plaintiffs for seeking withdrawal of suit or part thereof is mandatory, unless there is consent of other plaintiffs, withdrawal of suit on behalf of one plaintiff cannot take place.

 Applying the aforesaid law, in the present case, the First Appellate Court did not allow the application for withdrawal of the First Appeal by plaintiff no. 1 Ram Chander but transposed the plaintiff no. 1 Ram Chander as respondent in the First Appeal. The reliance by the senior counsel for the respondents no. 4(i) and 4(ii)/plaintiffs on J.K. Bhatia supra, in turn referring to Order XXIII Rule 1(5) CPC is apposite. The suit from which the First Appeal arose as well as this Second Appeal arises, was filed not by plaintiff no. 1 Ram Chander alone but by four plaintiffs including plaintiff no. 1 Ram Chander. Order XXIII Rule 1(5) provides that nothing in Order XXIII Rule 1 shall be deemed to authorize the Court to permit one of the several plaintiffs to abandon a suit or part of a claim under Order XXIII Rule 1(1) or to withdraw under Order XXIII Rule 1(3), the suit or part of the claim, without the consent of the other plaintiff. The First Appellate Court, though without referring to the said provision but perhaps owing thereto, did not allow the application of plaintiff no. 1 Ram Chander for withdrawal of the First Appeal. Once there was such a bar of law, the argument of the counsel for the appellants/defendants that the First Appellate Court was incompetent to pass a decree for ejectment with respect to plots no. 3 to 6 and 8 to 10, in favour of plaintiff no. 1 Ram Chander, falls to the ground. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

RSA No. 242/2005.

Decided On: 05.05.2020

Baldev Singh  Vs.  Ram Chander and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.

Print Page

Friday, 20 April 2018

Whether application for re-admission of arbitration appeal can be made if it was dismissed due to absence of counsel of both parties?

In such situation, provisions of Order 41 Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 got attracted and, therefore, the High Court should have taken recourse to the powers under Order 41 Rule 17 for passing appropriate orders as contemplated in Rule 17. Indeed the explanation appended to Rule 17 in clear terms provides that nothing in this sub-rule shall be construed as empowering the Court to dismiss the appeal on merits.
18) In any event, the dismissal of appeal being essentially under Order 41 Rule 17, the appellant herein should have taken recourse to the remedy available under Order 41 Rule 19 by filing application to the High Court praying therein for readmission of their appeal by making out the sufficient cause for their non-appearance on the date when the appeal was listed for hearing instead of filing this appeal against the impugned order before this Court.
Reportable
Supreme Court - Daily Orders
Navniraman Development ... vs Divisional Commissioner And ... on 5 July, 2017
Citation:2018(2) MHLJ 17

Print Page

Friday, 2 May 2014

Whether Appeal can be dismissed on merit if appellant remains absent?

 It is clear from the above that whereas appeal can be heard on merits if the respondent does not appear, in case the appellant fails to appear it is to be dismissed in default. Explanation makes it clear that the court is not empowered to dismiss the appeal on the merits of the case. As different consequences are provided, in case the appellant does not appear, in contradistinction to a situation where the respondent fails to appear, as a fortiori, Rule 19 and Rule 21 are also differently worded. Rule 19 deals with re-admission of appeal "dismissed for default", where the appellant does not appear at the time of hearing, Rule 21 talks of "re- hearing of the appeal" when the matter is heard in the absence of the respondent and ex-parte decree made.
In Abdur Rahman case (supra), this Court made it clear that because of non-appearance of the appellants before the High Court, High Court could not have gone into the merits of the case in view of specific course of action that could be chartered (viz. dismissal of the appeal in default above) continued in the explanation to Order XLI Rule 17, CPC and by deciding the appeal of the appellants on merits, in his absence. It was held that the High Court had transgressed its limits in taking into account all the relevant aspects of the matter and dismissing the said appeal on merits, holding that there was no ground to interfere with the decision of the trial court.

Supreme Court of India
Harbans Pershad Jaiswal (D) by LRS. Vs. Urmila Devi Jaiswal (D) by LRS.
[Civil Appeal No.4656/2014 arising out of S.L.P. (Civil) No.5875/2007]

   Decided On, 21 April 2014


Print Page