The High Court, in the impugned judgment erred in holding that the appellant had not examined the author of the documents. Such reasoning is absolutely erroneous as in the written statement, the respondents had not denied their signatures on the documents referred to by the appellant but pleaded duress in executing of these large number of documents. The witness examined by respondent no.1 in his cross examination admitted his signature or that of the representative of company on invoices, debit notes and on ST-1 Form. The respondent had led no evidence in respect of fraud or duress apart from self-serving statement. The consignment of goods was sent from the month of November 1985 to January 1986. The respondent had signed large number of documents during this period. However, no complaint was made to any person or authority or even to the plaintiff. It is a denial of receipt of goods without any basis raised only in the written statement filed. Such stand is wholly bereft of any truth and is thus rejected. {Para 20}
Supreme Court
JUSTICE HEMANT GUPTA JUSTICE V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN
M/S STAR PAPER MILLS LIMITED Vs. M/S BEHARILAL MADANLAL JAIPURIA LTD. & ORS.
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4102 OF 2013
16th December 2021
Author: HEMANT GUPTA, J.
Citation: 2021 ALL SCR (ONLINE) 788