In Commissioner of Police, Bombay v.
Gordhandas Bhanji, AIR 1952 SC 16, the Apex Court held as
follows :
“Public orders publicly made, in exercise of a
statutory authority cannot be construed in the light
of explanations subsequently given by the officer
making the order of what he meant, or of what was
in his mind, or what he intended to do. Public orders
made by public authorities are meant to have public
effect and are intended to affect the acting and
conduct of those to whom they are addressed and
must be construed objectively with reference to the
language used in the order itself. Orders are not like
old wine becoming better as they grow older.”
Similar view has also been taken in Bhikhubhai Vithlabhai Patel and
others v. State of Gujarat and another, (2008)4 SCC 144.
9. In view of the law laid down by the Apex Court
mentioned supra and looking at the impugned order in Annexure-
4, a conclusion can be drawn that by a cryptic order the
cancellation of tender has been made, which has been explained by
filing subsequent affidavit, the same is not permissible under law.
10. Relying on Air India Ltd. (supra), learned counsel
for the State has urged that in exercise of judicial review, the Court
cannot interfere with the decision, but it can interfere with the
decision-making process on grounds of mala fides,
unreasonableness or arbitrariness and Court should exercise its
discretionary power with great caution and only in furtherance of
overwhelming public interest.
11. In Maa Binda Express Carrier(supra), it is held
that submission of a bid/ tender in response to a notice inviting
tenders is only an offer which State or its agencies are under no
obligation to accept and bidders participating in the tender process
cannot insist that their bids/ tenders should be accepted simply
because a bid is the highest or lowest.
12. None of the judgments referred to by the learned
Addl. Govt. Advocate for the State is applicable to the present
context.
13. In view of the reasons assigned in the foregoing
paragraphs, it appears that since no reasons have been assigned in
the order impugned in Annexure-4 and subsequently by filing
affidavit, the opposite parties have tried to justify their action by
giving explanation, this Court is inclined to interfere with the same.
Thus, the order impugned in Annexure-4 dated 5.2.2016 and the
consequential invitation of bid in Annexure-5 also cannot sustain
and accordingly, the same are hereby quashed.
ORISSA HIGH COURT: CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No. 2656 of 2016
M/s.Shree Ganesh Construction v State of Orissa and others
P R E S E N T :
THE HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. VINEET SARAN
AND
THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE B.R.SARANGI
Dated : 18.05.2016
Print Page
Gordhandas Bhanji, AIR 1952 SC 16, the Apex Court held as
follows :
“Public orders publicly made, in exercise of a
statutory authority cannot be construed in the light
of explanations subsequently given by the officer
making the order of what he meant, or of what was
in his mind, or what he intended to do. Public orders
made by public authorities are meant to have public
effect and are intended to affect the acting and
conduct of those to whom they are addressed and
must be construed objectively with reference to the
language used in the order itself. Orders are not like
old wine becoming better as they grow older.”
Similar view has also been taken in Bhikhubhai Vithlabhai Patel and
others v. State of Gujarat and another, (2008)4 SCC 144.
9. In view of the law laid down by the Apex Court
mentioned supra and looking at the impugned order in Annexure-
4, a conclusion can be drawn that by a cryptic order the
cancellation of tender has been made, which has been explained by
filing subsequent affidavit, the same is not permissible under law.
10. Relying on Air India Ltd. (supra), learned counsel
for the State has urged that in exercise of judicial review, the Court
cannot interfere with the decision, but it can interfere with the
decision-making process on grounds of mala fides,
unreasonableness or arbitrariness and Court should exercise its
discretionary power with great caution and only in furtherance of
overwhelming public interest.
11. In Maa Binda Express Carrier(supra), it is held
that submission of a bid/ tender in response to a notice inviting
tenders is only an offer which State or its agencies are under no
obligation to accept and bidders participating in the tender process
cannot insist that their bids/ tenders should be accepted simply
because a bid is the highest or lowest.
12. None of the judgments referred to by the learned
Addl. Govt. Advocate for the State is applicable to the present
context.
13. In view of the reasons assigned in the foregoing
paragraphs, it appears that since no reasons have been assigned in
the order impugned in Annexure-4 and subsequently by filing
affidavit, the opposite parties have tried to justify their action by
giving explanation, this Court is inclined to interfere with the same.
Thus, the order impugned in Annexure-4 dated 5.2.2016 and the
consequential invitation of bid in Annexure-5 also cannot sustain
and accordingly, the same are hereby quashed.
ORISSA HIGH COURT: CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No. 2656 of 2016
M/s.Shree Ganesh Construction v State of Orissa and others
P R E S E N T :
THE HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. VINEET SARAN
AND
THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE B.R.SARANGI
Dated : 18.05.2016
