Since the plaintiff did not perform his part
of contract within the extended period in the legal
notice referred to supra, the agreement of sale was
terminated as per notice dated 28.3.1985 and thus
there is termination of the agreement of sale between
the plaintiff and Defendants 14 w.e.f. 10.4.1985.
37. As could be seen from the prayer sought
for in the original suit, the plaintiff has not sought
for declaratory relief to declare the termination of
agreement of sale as bad in law. In the absence of
such prayer by the plaintiff the original suit file dby
him before the trial court for grant of decree for
specific performance in respect of the suit schedule
property on the basis of agreement of sale and
consequential relief of decree for permanent
injunction is not maintainable in law.
38. Therefore, we have to hold that the relief sought
for by the plaintiff for grant of decree for specific
performance of execution of sale deed in respect of the
suit schedule property in his favour on the basis of nonexisting
agreement of sale is wholly unsustainable in
law. Accordingly, Point (i) (see Para 32.1) is answered
in favour of Defendant 5.”
What is significant to note in the instant case is that, by
refusal Exh. 82 dated 12.7.1982, the plaintiff was fully made aware
about the intention to refuse the performance of contract for whatever
reasons given in Exh.82. The submission made by Mr K.H. Deshpande
that such a refusal has no place in law or is not a valid refusal in the
eye of law is a matter of adjudication by the Court on facts and
evidence. But then having been made fully aware about the cancellation
of agreement by Exh.82 and its full understanding by plaintiff which is
reflected in Exh. 83 dated 03.08.1982 by the plaintiff itself, it is
difficult to fathom as to why the plaintiff failed to pose a challenge to
the act of cancellation Exh.82 in the suit itself by saying that refusal
was not valid in law. In paragraph 37 of the judgment cited supra, the
Apex Court in clear terms held that in the absence of such a prayer by
the plaintiff, the original suit is not maintainable in law since no
declaratory relief declaring that agreement of sale as bad in law, was
sought in the suit. I think the ratio of the above decision is as clear as
it could be and there is no reason for me to hold that in the absence of
any challenge to the act of termination of contract by Exh.82 the suit
would be maintainable. To sum up, this Question No.(iii) will have to be
answered by holding that the original suit was not maintainable, in the
absence of challenge to the termination of agreement dated 31.07.1975
by termination notice Exh.82 dated dated 12.07.1982.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT NAGPUR, NAGPUR.
SECOND APPEAL NO. 235/2012
Smt. C. Padmawati Naidu
v e r s u s
Friends Cooperative Housing Society Ltd.
CORAM : A.B.CHAUDHARI, J.
DATED : 3/4th March, 2016
Citation:2016(4) MHLJ289 Bom
