Showing posts with label change report. Show all posts
Showing posts with label change report. Show all posts

Sunday, 27 January 2019

Whether appeal is maintainable against order passed by charity commissioner in intervention application?

 Section 73-A enables person to file application for impleadment as a party to any proceedings under the Act. The said person has to. prove his locus and interest in the public trust and then he can be joined as a party to such proceedings, in which he has moved the application. Thus, the section 73-A vests similar power as available to a Court under Order 1, Rule 10 of the Civil Procedure Code. The proceedings of application under section 73-A thus, does not merge in parent proceedings under section 22 of the Act.
 Thus, I answer the issue in para 4 accordingly. The order dated 14-12-2015 passed by the Deputy Charity Commissioner in the Intervention application under section 73-A of the Act which was filed in the proceedings under section 22 of the Act is not appealable under section 70 of the Act before the Joint Charity Commissioner.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

F.A. No. 1064 of 2017 and Civil Appln. No. 2961 of 2017

Decided On: 16.08.2018

Kashyap Odhavji Thakkar Vs. Chandrakant R. Ganatra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Mridula Bhatkar, J.

Citation: 2019(1) MHLJ 102
Print Page

Whether change report proceeding are to be tried as civil suit?

 The Assistant Charity Commissioner has permitted the reporting trustee to examine a witness by filing an affidavit in lieu of examination in chief. The Assistant Charity Commissioner thus could not have refused to grant permission to the petitioners to cross examine the said witness. It is not in dispute that the proceedings under section 22 of the Maharashtra Public Trust Act, 1950 are to be tried as a civil suit. The impugned order in my view thus is ex-facie contrary to section 73 of the Maharashtra Public Trust Act, 1950.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition (ST) No. 19077 of 2018

Decided On: 13.08.2018

Shaikh Mohd. Nadim Vs.  The Assistant Charity Commissioner, Maharashtra State and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.D. Dhanuka, J.

Citation: 2019(1) MHLJ 403
Print Page

Saturday, 23 June 2018

Basic principles for adding any person as party to proceeding

 It is an elementary principle of law that a legal proceeding is initiated for redressal of a grievance; it seeks an appropriate relief in response to such grievance. All those parties in whose absence such grievance cannot be considered or such relief cannot be granted are termed as "necessary parties", whilst all those other parties whose presence may be considered proper for an effective adjudication of the grievance are "proper parties" to such proceeding. Unless a party qualifies either as a necessary or a proper party, it cannot be joined.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 312 of 2018

Decided On: 20.04.2018

 Janak Dilip Dwarkadas  Vs. The Joint Charity Commissioner Greater Mumbai Region,

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.C. Gupte, J.
Print Page

Sunday, 6 May 2018

On which ground, change report filed before charity commissioner can be challenged?

 Here in the case, admittedly the notice of the proposed meeting, according to respondent No. 1 also was issued to appellant and respondent No. 2. The question is whether that notice was legal and valid in view of the mandate of the Memorandum of Association. As stated above, clause 16(C) of the Memorandum of Association lays down that 15 days written notice in advance be given to the members before the election of the members for executive committee. Clause 18 further lays down that the notice of 15 days in advance must be received by the member for any proposed meeting of General Body. Here in the case, admittedly the notice is alleged to be issued on 21/12/1990 and it is stated to be sent Under Certificate of Posting on 22/12/1990 as the meeting was proposed on 06/01/1991 and held on that day, it follows that there was no 15 days in advance notice before the date of meeting. It is apart that as per the case of appellant and respondent No. 2 they had not received the notice and the proof of Under Certificate of Posting cannot be a valid proof of service of notice as there is no acknowledgement receipt.

14. In view of this situation, it is apparent that in the first place 15 days notice in advance was not received by appellant and respondent No. 2 and on this very ground itself the DCC has rightly held that the meeting was not legal, proper and valid. Secondly, ousting of the appellant and respondent No. 2 in the said meeting and induction of some other members in the Executive Committee was also done without giving an opportunity of hearing to appellant and respondent No. 2. Even assuming that they had not paid the subscription fees, on this count also their removal from the membership in the said meeting and induction of some outsider members to the Executive Committee cannot be upheld.

15. Thus, looked at it from any angle, it cannot be said that the Change Report filed by the respondent No. 1 before the DCC on the basis of the resolution passed in the said meeting was legal, valid and correct. The DCC has rightly rejected the same. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

First Appeal No. 359/1998

Decided On: 18.07.2017

Santosh Vs. Purushottam and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dr. Shalini Phansalkar Joshi, J.

Citation: 2017(6) MHLJ 888
Print Page

Sunday, 4 March 2018

Whether resolution taken by general body of trust will not be effective till it is approved by charity commissioner?

 Learned Advocate Shri Sunil Manohar then placed reliance on reported judgment in Chembur Trombay Education v. D.K. Marathe reported in MANU/MH/0863/2001 : 2002(3)BomCR161 . In paragraph 11 of this judgment the learned Single Judge has observed as under:

... A priori, any amendment or change brought about in accordance with law would come into effect from the date of resolution of the Society to bring about such a change. This proposition is fortified from the plain language of Section 22 of the Bombay Public Trusts Act. The said section requires that where any change occurs in any of the entries recorded in the register kept under Section 17, the trustee shall, within 90 days from the date of occurrence of such change, report such change to the Deputy or Assistant Charity Commissioner, as the case may be. The dictionary meaning of expression "occur" as observed in the Black's Law Dictionary is:

To happy; to meet one's eyes; to be found or met with; to present itself; to appear; hence, to befall in due course; to take place; to arise.
Giving the natural meaning to this word in Section 22 of the Act, coupled with the principle enunciated by the Apex Court that when the Act does not require that registration of any change is a condition precedent to come into effect, I have no hesitation in taking the view that the amendment to the constitution as well as subsequent elections of the President and members of the Governing Council, therefore, came into effect from the date of the respective resolutions of the general body. The enquiry postulated under Section 22 is only to ascertain the factum as to whether the change has occurred or not. In the event, the competent authority is satisfied that the change has not occurred in accordance with law, only then that change will have to be undone and status quo ante will have to be restored. A fortiori, resolution of the general body of the Society is sufficient to ignite the change of amendment in the constitution as well as of electing new general body for administering the affairs of the Society. The fact that the change report is pending consideration before the Charity Commissioner, would be of no avail....

9. Learned Advocate Dr. Anjan De fairly conceded that the judgment of learned Single Judge of this Court in Chembur Trombay Education v. D.K. Marathe reported at MANU/MH/0863/2001: 2002(3)BomCR161 does not support his contentions.

10. We find that any of the provisions contained in Bombay Public Trusts Act or the Rules thereunder do not mandate that amendment to the bye-laws or the rules of constitution of society passed by the society or trust shall not operate unless and until said amendment gets approval of Charity Commissioner/ Assistant Charity Commissioner etc.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 2672 of 2007

Decided On: 26.07.2007

 Ganesh S/o. Mahadeorao Thawre Vs. Central Hindu Military Education Society 

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.H. Joshi and R.C. Chavan, JJ.


Citation: 2007 (6) MHLJ589

Print Page

Whether resolution taken by general body of trust will come in to effect from date of resolution?

Now we would revert to the second aspect of the matter regarding the relief of mandatory/injunction claimed against the appellants in A.O. No. 1260 of 1995 emanating from Notice of Motion No. 4762 of 1995 in suit No. 5470 of 1995. The same is pressed essentially on the premise that Shri Marathe still continues to be the life president of the Society. This premise, in my view, is wholly inappropriate. It clearly over looks the fact that the general body of the Society in its meeting dated March 19, 1995 resolved to amend the constitution thereby deleting the provisions which ordained that Shri Marathe shall remain life President of the Society. Besides deleting the said provision, the general body also resolved to amend the constitution by providing that the post of President as well as that of the Governing Council members shall be filled by election only and the term of their office would be upto a period of three years from the date of assuming office. Besides amending the constitution which effected the change, this change has been reported to the competent authority under section 22 of the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950. Besides this change, another change that occurred pursuant to the general body decision dated June 18, 1995 is that Shri V.M. Pant, Senior Member was elected as a President and other members were elected to the new Governing Council, who assumed office after the said resolution. Even this change was reported to the appropriate authority as required under section 22 of the Act. The argument, however, advanced on behalf of the respondent-Shri Marathe is that the said change will come into effect only after the same is accepted by the appropriate authority. The Counsel for the respondent further contends that the amendment to the constitution is yet to be approved by the appropriate authority and till such time the question of conducting elections on the basis of such amended constitution, as has been done in the present case, is totally without authority of law. He further submits that the change report with regard to the amendment of the constitution, being change Report No. 1456/1995, was initially rejected by the Assistant Charity Commissioner by order dated June 6, 1998 which order was later on set aside by the Joint Charity Commissioner on June 13, 1998 at the instance of appellants in A.O. No. 1260/1995. He however, contends that the said decision has been interdicted by the City Civil Court in Charity Appeal Application No. 15/1998. According to him, therefore, the said change report relating to amendment of the constitution is still pending consideration and till such time no steps can be taken on the basis of the amended constitution. This submission is totally misplaced and in the teeth of the settled legal position. The law with regard to the efficacy of any change brought about and its application is no more res integra. The Apex Court in decision reported in A.I.R. 1993 S.C.W. 3006; Managing Committee, Khalsa Middle School and another v. Smt. Mohinder Kaur and another, has considered this aspect of the matter. The Apex Court was called upon to examine similar provisions of the Societies Registration Act, 1860. The scheme of section 12-A of that Act is more or less same as section 22 of the Bombay Public Trusts Act. The Apex Court compared the said provision with the provisions of sections 18 and 19 of the Companies Act which mandate that the alteration or amendment to the Memorandum of Association of the Company takes effect from the date of its registration only. In that context the Apex Court in para 11 of the said judgment has observed that in absence of any requirement in the Act that the alteration in the Rules and Regulations must be registered with the Registrar, it cannot be held that registration of the amendment is a condition precedent for such an alteration to come into effect. A priori, any amendment or change brought about in accordance with law would come into effect from the date of resolution of the Society to bring about such a change. This proposition is fortified from the plain language of section 22 of the Bombay Public Trusts Act. The said section requires that where any change occurs in any of the entries recorded in the register kept under section 17, the trustee shall, within 90 days from the date of the occurrence of such change, report such change to the Deputy or Assistant Charity Commissioner, as the case may be. The dictionary meaning of expression "occur" as observed in the Black's Law Dictionary is:

"To happy; to meet one's eyes; to be found or met with; to present itself; to appear; hence, to befall in due course; to take place; to arise."
Giving the natural meaning to this word in section 22 of the Act, coupled with the principle enunciated by the Apex Court that when the Act does not require that registration of any change is a condition precedent to come into effect, I have no hesitation in taking the view that the amendment to the constitution as well as subsequent elections of the President and members of the Governing Council, therefore, came into effect from the date of the respective resolutions of the general body. The enquiry postulated under section 22 is only to ascertain the factum as to whether the change has occurred or not. In the event, the competent authority is satisfied that the change has not occurred in accordance with law, only then that change will have to be undone and status quo ante will have to be restored. A fortiori, resolution of the general body of the Society is sufficient to ignite the change of amendment in the constitution as well as of electing new general body for administering the affairs of the Society. The fact that the change report is pending consideration before the Charity Commissioner, would be of no avail. Understood thus, as a necessary corollary, it will have to be held that the respondent-Shri Marathe ceased to be the President of the Society from the date when the General Body elected another President in its meeting dated June 18, 1995. If this be the position, the respondent-Shri Marathe will have no right whatsoever to continue in the post of president and, there would be no question of granting any mandatory relief at this stage.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Appeal From Order No. 1260 of 1995 with Civil Application No. 6599 of 2000 with Appeal From Order No. 1256 of 1995

Decided On: 01.10.2001

Chembur Trombay Education Society and Ors. Vs. D.K. Marathe and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.M. Khanwilkar, J.
Citation: 2002(3)BomCR161 

Print Page