Showing posts with label charge. Show all posts
Showing posts with label charge. Show all posts

Wednesday, 20 January 2021

Questions and Answers on law Part 17

Q 1:- Whether Judgments and orders passed by Civil court are executable throughout the territory of India?

Ans:-Yes, as per Article 261(3) in The Constitution Of India 1949

(3) Final judgments or orders delivered or passed by civil courts in any part of the territory of India shall be capable of execution anywhere within that territory according to law.
Print Page

Saturday, 22 August 2015

Distinction between charge and mortgage

Mr. Kuhad in support of his
submission that the interim order dated 15th April,
1987 has to be treated as a mandate of the Court,
has relied on J.K. (Bombay) (P) Ltd. Vs. New
 Kaiser-I-Hind Spinning and Weaving Co. Ltd.(1969) 2 SCR 866
In the aforesaid judgment, undoubtedly it is held that
“no particular form of words is necessary to create a
charge and all that is necessary is that there must be
a clear intention to make a property security for
payment of money in praesenti.” The aforesaid
observations of this Court ought not to be read out of
context. The judgments of this Court are not to be
read as statutory instruments. The ratio of the
judgment has to be culled out, keeping in view the

facts and circumstances involved in a particular case.
The facts in that case are noticed in paragraph 26
from wherein the aforesaid three lines have been
extracted by Mr. Kuhad in support of his
submission. We quote the relevant part of paragraph
26 of the aforesaid judgment which is as under:
“26……. It was argued that where an
agreement specifies a property out of which a
debt is to be payable and is coupled with an
intention to subject such property to a
charge, the property becomes subject to a
charge in praesenti even though a regular
mortgage is to be executed at some future
date. Such an intention, the learned Attorney General
argued, was demonstrated by the
agreement that (1) the debts were to be paid
out of profits and (2) the engagement by the
company not to deal with its assets. The
distinction between a charge and a mortgage
is clear. While in the case of a charge there is
no transfer of property or any interest
therein, but only the creation of a right of
payment out of the specified property, a
mortgage effectuates transfer of property or
an interest therein. No particular form of
words is necessary to create a charge and all
that is necessary is that there must be a clear
intention to make a property security for
payment of money in praesenti.
………”
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 1746 OF 2006
Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. …
Appellant
VERSUS
Official Liquidator of M/s. Ambica Mills
Company Ltd. & Ors.
...Respondents

SURINDER SINGH NIJJAR, J.
Citation;(2015) 5 SCC300
Print Page

Monday, 12 May 2014

Whether plaintiff in maintenance suit will get charge on specific immovable property from date of filing of suit?

 The only question then is if it can be deemed to have come into existence on the date when the suit was instituted. If the doctrine of relation back, as applied to the orders of adjudication can also be applied to the decrees passed in suits for maintenance, the appellant's position would be secure. It has been held by a Division Bench of this Court that a maintenance decree creating a charge on a specific immovable property mentioned in the plaint operates to give a charge to the plaintiff not merely from the date of the decree but from the date on which the plaint was presented : Seetharamanujacharyulu v. Venkatasubbamma (1930) 17 A.I.R. Mad. 824. The proposition settled by this case was not controverted by the learned Counsel for the respondent but it was argued that as the learned Judges were not dealing with a case of supervening insolvency it could not be of any assistance to the appellant. It is true that the contest in that case was between a widow and an auction-purchaser but I cannot see what difference in principle would it make if an Official Receiver is substituted for the auction-purchaser. The question in both the cases would relate to the date on which the charge should be deemed to have come into existence and it was this point which has been settled by that case.

Madras High Court
Katrapati Hanumayamma vs Official Receiver on 10 February, 1939
Equivalent citations: AIR 1940 Mad 749

Coram:
Abdur Rahman, J.
Print Page