Showing posts with label co-lessee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label co-lessee. Show all posts

Monday, 31 August 2020

Whether a tenant can deny the title of the landlord if the landlord has constructed a tenanted structure on leasehold land of government?

1)Tenant has contended that the landlord was not the 'owner' of the subject premises, since it is leasehold property, with the Delhi Development Authority as the owner/lessor; and the landlord was only a 'co-lessee' under the DDA alongwith one Shri Prem Nath Ohri;


2)In view of the decision of the Supreme Court in Shanti Sharma (supra), all that the law requires is that the landlord should hold a premises in a capacity of something more than that of a tenant and proof of title beyond that point is not required. In the present case, as per the tenant's own allegations, the landlord holds the land on which the subject premises is constructed on long lease granted by the DDA. The landlord is therefore owner of leasehold rights in the land comprised in the subject premises. For purposes of section 14(1)(e) of the DRC Act, 'ownership' is not meant only to be freehold and absolute ownership of property but includes rights in the property that are more than that of a tenant, regardless of other imperfections in title. Yet again therefore, no trial is called for on this point.

3) Though it is the tenant's allegation that the landlord was only a co-lessee of the subject premises under the DDA along with one Shri Prem Nath Ohri, the fact that only one co-lessee had filed the eviction petition is no bar to its maintainability. This issue is no longer res integra and it stands settled by several decisions of the Supreme Court that even one of the co-owners can, alone and in his own right, file a proceeding for ejectment of a tenant; and a tenant cannot question the maintainability of the proceedings on this score. (cf. Kasthuri Radhakrishnan & Ors. vs. M. Chinniyan & Anr. MANU/SC/0075/2016 : (2016) 3 SCC 296 para 29).


IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

RC. Rev. 269/2018 and CM Appl. No. 24045/2018

Decided On: 09.07.2020

Gaffar Ahmad  Vs.   Shiv Kumar Ohri

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Anup Jairam Bhambhani, J.

Citation: MANU/DE/1361/2020
Print Page

Sunday, 5 July 2020

Whether surrender of tenancy by one co-lessee to the landlord will bind other co-lessee?

1) The appellant/plaintiff, on 6th June, 1984 instituted the suit from which this appeal arises, pleading (i) that the appellant/plaintiff and the respondent/defendant No. 1 Rakesh Kumar, vide Deed dated 3rd September, 1975 entered into a partnership, to start a firm in the name and style of M/s. Neel Jewellers, to carry on business of repair and sale of silver jewellery and repairing and making of gold ornaments, at Shop No. 47 U.B., Jawahar Nagar, Delhi which was jointly taken, on rent by the appellant/plaintiff and the respondent/defendant No. 1 Rakesh Kumar for partnership business, from the respondent/defendant No. 2 Maya Devi, who was the mother of the respondent/defendant No. 1 Rakesh Kumar.

2) A lease is nothing but a contract between the lessor/landlord and the lessee/tenant. Law relating to leases of immovable property is otherwise codified in the Transfer of Property Act. Section 4 of the Transfer of Property Act, which was enacted later in point of time, provides that the Chapters and Sections of the Transfer of Property Act which relate to contract shall be taken as part of the Contract Act. Chapter V, titled "Of Leases of Immoveable Property", of the Transfer of Property Act does not provide for relations inter se lessee, if more than one i.e. of performance of obligations of a lessee under the lease. However the same under Section 111 titled "Determination of Lease" provides for termination of lease inter alia by express or implied surrender. However it does not provide, whether surrender of lease, in the event of lease in favour of more than one person, has to be by all or even one of them is capable of so surrendering the lease and which surrender would bind the others as well. Mention may also be made of Section 108 titled "Rights and Liabilities of Lessor and Lessee", in the absence of a contract to be contrary, and which vide Section 108(B)(q) provides it to be a liability/obligation of the lessee to, on determination of lease, put the lessor into possession of the property. Here, there is no pleading or evidence of any contract between the appellant/plaintiff and the respondent/defendant No. 1 as lessees on the one hand and respondent/defendant No. 2 as lessor on the other hand, having contracted to the contrary. I had during the hearing also referred the counsels to Section 45 of the Transfer of Property Act which provides that when immovable property is transferred for consideration to two or more persons, they are, in the absence of a contract to the contrary, entitled to interests in such property equivalent to the proportion of the consideration paid by them and in the absence of evidence thereof, to equal interest in the property. A lease of property is a contract of transfer of property within the meaning of Section 45 of the Act.

3) I fail to see, that when under Section 43 of the Contract Act one of the two persons who have together taken a premises on rent, by making payment to the landlord is in a position to discharge the liability of the other tenant also, why the surrender of tenancy by respondent/defendant No. 1 herein, who along with the appellant/plaintiff had taken the premises on rent, would not bind the appellant/plaintiff. The appellant/plaintiff, if had intended to the contrary, considering that the landlord was none else but the mother of the respondent/defendant No. 1, ought to have contracted to the contrary and which was not done. In the absence of a contract to the contrary, under Section 43 of the Contract Act, the respondent/defendant No. 1 was entitled to surrender the tenancy.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

RSA 146/2005

Decided On: 09.05.2020

 Gauri Shankar Vs.  Rakesh Kumar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.

Citation:  MANU/DE/1023/2020
Print Page