Showing posts with label co-plaintiffs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label co-plaintiffs. Show all posts

Tuesday, 31 December 2024

Supreme Court: Whether one plaintiff is entitled to get decree in suit for specific performance of contract if co-plaintiff is not willing to get specific performance?

 ON QUESTION - (f)

19. Now, the question is whether the Plaintiffs were entitled to a decree for specific performance. In his deposition, the first Plaintiff has proved the service of notice of demand to the first Defendant. The suit is filed within limitation, and the Defendants did not raise a plea of delay and laches. There are concurrent findings of the three Courts on the issue of the readiness and willingness shown by the first Plaintiff. There is no reason to disturb the said findings. Now, the question is, what is the effect of the failure of the second Plaintiff to support the first Plaintiff and his conduct of supporting the Defendants? In the facts of the case, the answer lies in the submissions made by the second to fourth Defendants before the High Court. In paragraph 9 of the judgment, the High Court has recorded the following submissions made by the counsel for the second to fourth Defendants:


9. The learned Senior Counsel for the Appellants submitted that the Plaintiff No. 2 Murari Singh did not file the suit nor had signed the vakalatnama and that the said Plaintiff had admitted this fact in his deposition, consequently, the suit was not maintainable. It was further submitted that the percentage of share between the Plaintiffs were not defined in the agreement to sell and, consequently, Under Section 45 of the Transfer of Property Act, the Plaintiffs would be deemed to have equal shares, namely, 50 percent. The learned Senior Counsel for the Appellants contended that since Murari Singh did not institute the suit, the decree for specific performance for the whole land, which was undivided could not have been decreed by the trial court and, consequently, to that extent, the decree passed by the trial court was erroneous. ...............................................................

(emphasis added)

20. In our view, as the second Plaintiff was not interested in getting the specific performance, the decree ought to have been restricted to the undivided one-half share in the suit property in favour of only the first Plaintiff.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 6782 of 2013

Decided On: 09.07.2024

Maharaj Singh and Ors. Vs. Karan Singh (Dead) thr. L.Rs. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Shreeniwas Oka and Sanjay Karol, JJ.

Author: Abhay Shreeniwas Oka, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/0587/2024,2024 INSC 491.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.


Print Page

Thursday, 28 November 2019

Whether court can allow party to be impleaded as co-plaintiff if there is conflict of interest between original plaintiff and that party?

There is a serious dispute as to whether the plaintiff Nos. 2, 7 to 10 and 12 have assigned their entire rights in the suit premises in favour of GITCPL as contended by Mr. Ankhad who represents plaintiff Nos. 4 to 6 in the suit or whether the plaintiff Nos. 2, 7 to 10 and 12 have only assigned 75% of their rights to the suit premises as contended by both Mr. Godbole and Mr. Dhakephalkar. GITCPL relying upon the deeds of assignment, has applied for impleadment and relied upon the provisions in Order XXII Rule 10 of CPC. At the stage of deciding whether leave is to be granted under Order XXII Rule 10 of CPC, a detailed enquiry is really not contemplated. Only a prima facie satisfaction would normally suffice. From this perspective, it will be only appropriate that both GITCPL as well as plaintiff Nos. 2, 7 to 10 and 12 continue as parties in the suit. The question really is about capacity in which they ought to continue in this suit.


16. There is also no warrant for the proposition that a party to the suit who may have assigned its interest in favour of a third party, is required to be necessarily struck out from the array of parties. The party to the suit who may have assigned its interest is entitled to continue as a party in the suit, because, in a given case, the covenant to supply a good title to the assignee and to assign property free from any encumbrances or litigations may continue upon such party. In the present case, there is a serious dispute as to whether the plaintiff Nos. 2, 7 to 10 and 12 have assigned their 100% rights or the assignment is restricted to only 75% of the rights which they claim to have in the suit premises. In these circumstances, there was no justification to order deletion of the plaintiff Nos. 2, 7 to 10 and 12 from the array of parties in the suit.

17. Although, GITCPL is entitled to become a party, the learned trial Judge, was not at all justified in impleading the GITCPL as 'co plaintiff' particularly when there is a serious conflict of interest between plaintiff Nos. 4 to 6 on one hand and GITCPL on the other. Although, the exercise of power under Order I Rule 10 of CPC is discretionary, the discretion in such matters, cannot be exercised in unreasonable manner. In fact, this is what is held in Mumbai International Airport Pvt. Ltd. (supra) upon which reliance was placed by Mr. Godbole. In Bayajabai Patil (supra) Chief Justice M.C. Chagla, in the context of exercise of power under Order I Rule 10 of CPC has held that a party may be added as a co-plaintiff, when the plaintiff does not dispute the right of the co-plaintiff to the decree which might be passed; but where his right to property in suit is disputed by the plaintiff, the proper procedure is to join him as a defendant and not as a co-plaintiff. The principle in such matters appears to be that the original plaintiff, who is even otherwise dominus litis, cannot be compelled to proceed with the suit with a co-plaintiff, with whom, such original plaintiff may have a conflict of interest.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition Nos. 5917 of 2017 and 13794 of 2016

Decided On: 20.09.2017

Daksha Keshrichand Jhaveri  Vs.  Nikhilesh Keshrichand Jhaveri and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
M.S. Sonak, J.

Citation: Manu/MH/2165/2017:2017 SCC Online Bom 8448

Print Page

Friday, 7 December 2018

Whether two different Advocates can conduct case of co-plaintiffs separately?

Mr. Bhabha was unable to point out even a single instance of any case in England in which different counsel were engaged for different plaintiffs who had joined in one suit. On the other hand the learned Government Pleader, Mr. Chandrachud, invited my attention to a very old case Wedderburn v. Wedderburn, (1853) 51 ER 993, decided as far back as in 1853, where the Master of the Rolls observed;
"When persons undertake the prosecutions of a suit they must make up their minds whether they will become co-plaintiffs; for if they do, they must act together. I cannot allow one of several plaintiffs to act separately from and inconsistently with the others."
In fact, I never expected any reported case on this question, because, in my opinion, the practice of one or more counsel appearing for all the co-plaintiffs in a suit jointly and not severally both here and in England has been so uniform and confirmed that there would not be any possibility of any question ever arising of different plaintiffs in one suit being represented by different counsel. The case cited by the learned Government Pleader, however, clears up any difficulty or doubt that might have never existed in regard to this question.
3. It is clear that two or more persons would agree to join as co-plaintiffs in a suit only if there is any common question of law or fact between them, and their respective claims arise out of the same transaction. The law permits these different plaintiffs to join in one action by filing one common plaint only with a view to save multiplicity of suits and consequent wastage of time of the Court. If this is the object of allowing several persons to join as plaintiffs in one action, the object would be frustrated if each of these persons is allowed to be represented by a separate counsel and each one of the counsel is also permitted to be in charge of the case for his own client. I fail to see how, if such things are permitted, the wastage of the time of the Court, which is otherwise intended to be saved by allowing several persons to join together as co-plaintiffs in one action, could at all be saved. On the contrary, far more time would be taken and a number of unnecessary complications would arise in trying one such action if every one of the plaintiffs is allowed to be represented by his own counsel and each counsel is allowed to conduct the case separately for his own client. It may be for this reason that the tradition has taken deep roots both in the courts here as in England that in cases where more persons than one join as co-plaintiffs in one action they should all be jointly represented by one or more counsel. It may be that at some stage or the other of the action some of the plaintiffs might feel that there is a conflict of interest between them and the other plaintiffs. Just for that reason, however, as was held by the Master of the Rolls in the case cited above, such plaintiffs cannot be allowed to engage a different counsel. If they so wish, they might well apply to the Court to transpose them as defendants.

Bombay High Court
Venkatrao A. Pai And Sons Ltd. vs Narayanlal Bansilal And Ors. on 2 August, 1960
Equivalent citations: AIR 1961 Bom 94, (1960) 62 BOMLR 947, ILR 1961 Bom 459
Bench: Shah
Print Page

Sunday, 25 May 2014

When principle of res judicata has been held to bind Co-plaintiffs?


It is true that under s. 11 C.P.C. when the matter has been directly or substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties or between parties under whom they or any of them claimed litigating under the same title, the decree in the former suit would be res judicata between the plaintiff and the defendant or as between the co-plaintiff or co-defendant. But for application of this doctrine between co-defendants four con- ditions must be satisfied, namely, that (1) there must be a conflict of interest between the defendants concerned; (2) it must be necessary to decide the conflict in order to give the reliefs which the plaintiff claims; (3) the question between the defendants must have been finally decided; and (4) the co-defendants were necessary or proper parties in the former suit. Ibis is the settled law as held in SM. Sadat Ali Khan v. Mirza Wiquar Ali, AIR 1943 PC 115,Shashibushan Prasad Mishra v. Babuji Rai & Ors., 1969 (2) SCR 971; and Iftikhar Ahmed & Ors. v. Syed Meharban Ali, 1974 (2) SCC 151. Take for instance that if in a suit by 'A' against 'B & C', die matter is directly and substantially in issue between B & C, and an adjudication upon that matter was necessary to determine the suit to grant relief to 'A'; the adjudication would operate as res judicata in a subsequent suit between B & C in which either of them is plaintiff and the other defendant. in other words, if a plaintiff cannot get at his right without trying and deciding a can between co-defendants, the court will try and decide the case, and the co-defendants will be, bound by the decree. But if the relief given to the plaintiff does not require or involve a decision of any case between co- defendants, the codefendants will not be bound as between each other.
9.Where the above four conditions did not exist the decree does not operate as res judicata. It must, therefore., be that all the persons who have right title and interest are made parties to the suit and that they should have knowledge that the right, tide and interest would be in adjudication and the finding or the decree therein would operate as a res judicata to their right, title and interest in the subject- matter of theformer suit. Even in their absence a decree could be passed and it may be used as an evidence of the plaintiffs title either accepted or negatived therein. The doctrine of res judicata would apply even though the party against whom it is sought to be enforced, was not eo-nomine made a party nor entered appearance nor did he contest the question. The doctrine of res judicata must, however, be applied to co- defendants with great care and caution. The reason is that fraud is an extrinsic collateral act, which vitiates the most solemn proceedings of courts of justice. If a party obtains a decree from the court by practicing fraud or collusion, be cannot be allowed to say that the matter is res judicata and cannot be re-opened. There can also be no question of res judicata in a case where signs of fraud or collusion are transparently pregnant or apparent from the facts on record.
10. Therefore, in applying the doctrine of res judicata between co-defendant or co-plaintiff, care, must, of necessity, be taken by the courts to see that there must in fact be a conflict of interest between the codefendants or co-plaintiffs concerned and it is necessary to decide the conflict in order to give relief which the plaintiff in the suit claimed and the question must have been directly and substantially in issue and was finally decided therein

Supreme Court of India
Mahboob Sahab vs Syed Ismail & Ors on 23 March, 1995
Equivalent citations: 1995 AIR 1205, 1995 SCC (3) 693
Print Page