Showing posts with label court of conscience. Show all posts
Showing posts with label court of conscience. Show all posts

Saturday, 22 November 2014

Whether probate can be granted by consent of parties?



In support of his contention that the said Terms of Settlement is no bar to any probate being granted to the present Will dated June 29, 1979, the learned Counsel for the respondent has cited a decision of this Court in the case of A.E.G. Carapiet v. A.Y. Derderian, reported in MANU/WB/0074/1961: AIR1961Cal359 . The learned Counsel for the respondent has referred to paragraph 28 of the Report, where it has been observed by P.B. Mukharji, J. (as His Lordship then was), speaking for the Division Bench, that a Court of probate always shies at terms of settlement. A court of probate is said to be a court of conscience which is not to be influenced by private arrangements of the parties. Either it grants probate to a Will or it rejects such grant. The court has to be satisfied in each case whether the Will for which grant of probate is proposed, is truly the Will of the capable testator or not. It has also been observed by the Division Bench in the said case that in England there is a procedure available for making the terms of settlement a rule of court, but in our country that is not so. The terms of settlement as annexed to the decree, is not a part of the grant of probate or executable as such. We will refer to the said decision in detail later on.
The learned trial Judge has held that it is a well known principle that no probate can be granted by consent of parties or as a result of any settlement. The learned trial Judge has also found that moreover in terms of the Terms of Settlement filed the caveator did not carry out his part and admitted that he made defaults in payments. The learned trial Judge has also found that the evidence of the caveator was not corroborated by any other oral or documentary evidence and also that he was not a truthful witness. It has also been found by the learned trial Judge that the propounder had discharged the onus of proving due execution, attestation and also possession of testamentary capacity by the testatrix and relying on such evidence, the trial Court was satisfied that the Will was executed by Sushila Bala Sana on June 29, 1979 and that was her last Will and Testament duly executed.
15. We have considered the respective submissions of the parties. It is now well known proposition of law that probate court cannot go into the question of title and it is a function of the probate court to see in the probate proceedings whether the Will has been duly executed, whether the testator at the relevant time was in sound and disposing state of mind and whether the testator had understood the nature and effect of such disposition and put his signature and/or mark to the document at his free will and volition. It is also a settled proposition of law that probate court cannot, by consent of parties, grant probate or reject the grant of probate.
Calcutta High Court

Sushila Bala Saha vs Saraswati Mondal on 23 February, 1989
Equivalent citations: AIR 1991 Cal 166

Bench: P K Majumdar, A M Sinha
Print Page