Showing posts with label Indian succession Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indian succession Act. Show all posts

Tuesday, 24 June 2025

What is the difference between representative suit and administration suits as per indian law?

 Representative Suits vs Administration Suits

Representative suits and administrative suits serve entirely different purposes under Indian law and are governed by different legal frameworks.

Representative Suits

Print Page

Friday, 2 August 2024

Bombay HC: There is no embargo to raise counter-claim in suit and or proceedings, application filed under Indian Succession Act

After reading the clear provisions of counter-claim, I am also of the view that there is no embargo of whatsoever created to raise counter-claim in the suit and or proceedings/ application filed under the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (for short," the Indian Succession Act"). There is nothing to show that the counter-claim as provided under Order 8, Rule 6A is limited to the case involved in the money claims only. The Rules 6A to 6G if read together, no restriction whatsoever, is created to file counter-claim in any suit and or proceedings of any nature. {Para 16}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

First Appeal No. 537 of 1995

Decided On: 17.12.2007

Namdeo Mali Vs. Jayram Barde and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Anoop V. Mohta, J.

Citation:  MANU/MH/1351/2007.

Print Page

Friday, 25 March 2022

Whether the court can revoke letter of administration if all legal heirs are not made parties to the suit?

  As per Section 263, the grant of Letters of Administration may be revoked for “just cause”. Explanation (a) under Section 263 states that just cause shall be deemed to exist where the proceedings were defective in substance. Illustration (ii) under Section 263 deals with a case where “the grant was made without citing parties who ought to have been cited”. {Para 6}

7. It may be of interest to note that some of the colonial statutes contain Illustrations which form part of the statutes themselves. The Indian Succession Act, 1925 is one such enactment.

8. Therefore, the High Court was right in holding that a just cause existed for revoking the grant. Hence, we do not find any error in the order of the High Court warranting our interference. Therefore the appeals are dismissed.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 798-799 OF 2013;

SWAMINATHAN & ORS. Vs ALANKAMONY (DEAD) THROUGH LRS.

Coram: HEMANT GUPTA; V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN, JJ.

Dated: 9 March, 2022

Print Page

Sunday, 22 August 2021

Questions and answers on law Part 26

Q 1 :-  Whether a person can validly execute will after accepting consideration?

Ans:-Will is the wish of testator in respect of disposal of his property after ones death. It should be made by free wish and without any force, undue influence or coercion. Further a Will can be revoked any time by testator.

When money consideration is given in respect of will, it will not be a free wish of testator as he will not be able to revoke it anytime due to acceptance of consideration and thus it will be binding upon testator. Therefore, in my opinion, it will not be a valid will if consideration of money is present in that transaction.

Q 2:- Which law will be applicable if non resident Indian execute  will in respect of immovable property situated in India and in foreign country?

Ans: Section 5 in The Indian Succession Act, 1925
5. Law regulating succession to deceased person’s immovable and movable property, respectively.—
(1) Succession to the immovable property in 1[India] of a person deceased shall be regulated by the law of 1[India], wherever such person may have had his domicile at the time of his death.

As per this section  as far as immovable properties are concerned, all matters relating to capacity to make Will, revocation of Will, power of disposition and all such related matters are governed by the lex situs or in other words, the law of the land where the property is situated.

Print Page

Sunday, 8 December 2019

Whether Hindu is entitled to inherit property of christian relative as per Indian Succession Act?

 There is authority in this Court in favour of the view that a Hindu relation, if he is otherwise entitled to inherit the estate of a Christian deceased under the Indian Succession Act, which would admittedly govern cases of Christian succession, would not be disentitled to such inheritance merely because he is a Hindu (vide -- 'Neepen Bala Debi v. Siti Kanta Banerjee' 15 Cal WN 158 (A)). 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA

A.F.O.D. No. 173 of 1954

Decided On: 12.01.1956

Benoy Kumar Mondal  Vs.  Panchanon Majumdar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
P.N. Mookerjee and Renupada Mukherjee, JJ.

Citation: AIR 1956 Calcutta 177

Print Page

Wednesday, 2 October 2019

Whether application for legal heir certificate is maintainable if legal heir certificate is already granted to other party?

The facts leading to filing of the present writ petition are that the petitioners had filed an application for grant of legal heirship certificate under Bombay Regulation VIII of 1827 (hereinafter referred to "Regulation"). The said application was granted by the Court of Civil Judge, Junior Division, Nagpur by judgment and order dated 13/06/2017. An application was filed by the respondent on 02/03/2017 under the very same Regulation for grant of legal heirship certificate wherein the petitioners were made parties as non-applicants. 

 A perusal of the above quoted provisions shows that section 387 of the Act of 1925 and clause 7 second of the said Regulation specifically provide for revocation and annulment of a certificate in the nature granted in favour of the petitioners herein. Section 385 of the Act of 1925 specifically provides that a certificate granted in favour of a person shall be invalid if there has been a previous grant of such a certificate and when such a previous grant is in force. Section 387 of the Act of 1925 provides that no decision in Part X of the said Act would prevent the question involved to be raised in a suit or "any other proceedings between the same parties". A proper reading of the aforesaid provision clearly shows that there is a scheme provided for revocation or annulment of certificate, with which any person is aggrieved and that there is also the option of approaching the Civil Court by filing a suit or any other proceedings and that grant of earlier certificate would not act as res judicata between the parties. In the present case, even if the respondent was not aware about grant of heirship certificate in favour of the petitioners, the moment the grant of certificate in favour of the petitioners was brought to her notice, the only course available for her was to have taken appropriate steps either for revocation of the certificate under section 383 of the said Act or for annulment of the said certificate under clause 7 second of the said Regulation or to have filed a suit as contemplated under section 387 of the Act of 1925. To proceed with the present application, filed by the respondent, which is only for grant of legal heirship certificate to her would be an exercise in futility, in view of section 385 of the said Act.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 5447 of 2018

Decided On: 13.02.2019

 Parvatabai  Vs.  Surekha

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Manish Pitale, J.

Citation: 2019(5) MHLJ 214
Print Page

Monday, 1 July 2019

Whether suit filed on basis of will is tenable if probate of will is not obtained?

Sub-section (1) of Section 213 of the Indian Succession Act which is relevant for the purpose reads as follows:--

"213. Right as executor or legatee when established--

(1) No right as executor or legatee can be established in any Court of Justice, unless a Court of competent jurisdiction in [India] has granted probate of the Will under which the right is claimed, or has granted letters of administration with the Will or with a copy of an authenticated copy of the Will annexed."

8. From a perusal of the provision aforesaid it is apparent that no right as executor or legatee can be established in any court of justice unless the 'Will' is probated by the competent court. In the present case the 'Will' was not probated on the date of institution of the suit as such the suit was itself incompetent. If the impugned order would have been passed in favour of the petitioner whole suit would have been dismissed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PATNA

Civil Revision No. 293 of 2010

Decided On: 10.01.2019

Sushila Devi Vs.  Chandra Bhushan Chaudhary and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Birendra Kumar, J.

Citation: AIR 2019 Patna 51
Print Page

Sunday, 17 March 2019

Whether executor of will can enter into contract contrary to terms of will?

A probate when granted binds the whole world. It is a judgment in rem. The Executor, therefore, has to administer the estate of the testator in terms of the Will and not on the basis of the settlement arrived at by and between the parties which would be inconsistent with the terms of the Will. In case of any conflict between the terms of the Will and the settlement, the former will prevail. The court, thus, in exercise of its jurisdiction under Section 302 of the Act can enforce only the terms of the Will and not the terms of the agreement.

18. The agreement although formed part of the terms of settlement, but it may only be held to be a collateral document. A purported agreement of family arrangement which in effect and substance is a development agreement cannot form the part of a decree granting probate.

 The effect of termination of such agreement entered into by and between the parties is required to be gone into in an independent suit and not in a proceeding under Section 302 of the Act. The testamentary court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Section 302 of the Act cannot enforce a contract qua contract; only because the Executor is a party thereto.

If the agreement was not a part of the Will, in our opinion, Section 302 will have no application.

23. It is not necessary for us also to go into the question in regard to the effect of delay in termination of the agreement. We must, however, make a distinction between the two functions of the respondent No. 1; one as an Executor of the Will and the other as a developer. Whereas his action as an Executor is subject to the direction of the testamentary court, his action as a developer is not. An Executor or a Trustee would not put him in such a position in which his personal interest and his duties under the Will come in conflict with each other. The testamentary court must give effect to the Will and not an agreement by and between the Executor and the third party, which would be contrary to the wishes of the testator.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 6575 of 2008 (Arising out of SLP (Civil) No. 13488 of 2007)

Decided On: 07.11.2008

 Chandrabhai K. Bhoir  Vs  Krishna Arjun Bhoir and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.B. Sinha and Cyriac Joseph, JJ.

Citation: (2009) 2 SCC 315.
Print Page

Friday, 11 May 2018

Whether foreign nationals are barred from inheriting property in India?

Dr. S.L. Singh died on 20.3.1976 without leaving any issue. It is not
disputed that Ida Utarid is the real sister of Dr. S.L. Singh. According to the
admitted pedigree, M. Utarid had two sons, namely, Dr. M.B. Utarid and Nazir
Utarid. Nazir Utarid had two daughters, namely, Dr. S.L. Singh (wife of the
original plaintiff) and Ida Utarid. J.M. Utarid (defendant No.1) is the son of E.
Udarid and grandson of Dr. M.B. Utarid. Dr. S.L. Singh is admittedly an Indian
Christian. Therefore, the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (for short ‘the Act’) would
be applicable to the succession of the property left by her. This Act does not bar
the succession of property of any Indian Christian by a person who is not an Indian
national. There is no prohibition for succession of the property in India by a
foreign national by inheritance.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 6935 OF 2011

B.C. SINGH (D) BY LRS.  V J.M. UTARID 
Dated:May 8, 2018.
Print Page

Thursday, 19 October 2017

When appeal will lay before district Judge from order passed by civil judge senior division in probate proceeding?

255. (i) Under Section 265 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 the High Court has appointed all Civil Judges to act for the District Judge as delegates to grant probate and letters of administration in non-continuous cases arising within the local limits of their respective jurisdiction.

(ii) In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 28-A(1) of the Bombay Civil Courts Act (XIV of 1869), the High Court has invested all Civil Judges (Senior Division), with all the powers of a District Judge to take cognizance of any contested proceeding Indian Succession Act 1925, within the local limits of their respective jurisdiction that may be transferred to them by their respective District Judges."

6. A bare at the aforesaid paragraphs would make it clear that in case of the contested proceedings, arising under the Indian Succession Act, 1925, the said matters may be adjudicated by the District Judge or the Civil Judge, Senior Division to whom the such proceedings have been transferred. Once the Civil Judge, Senior Division has exercised the jurisdiction over the application field by the petitioner for grant of probate of the will having valuation of Rs. 10,000/-, in view of the provisions contained in Section 28-A of the Bombay Civil Courts Act, 1869, the appeal lay against such order passed by the Civil Judge, Senior Division to the Court of the District Judge. Section 28-A of the Bombay Civil Courts Act, 1869 reads as under:--

"28-A (1) The High Court may by general or special order invest any Civil Judge within such local limits and subject to such pecuniary limitation as may be prescribed in such order with all or any of the powers of a District Judge or a District Court as the case may be under the Indian Succession Act, 1865, the Probate and Administration Act, 1881 or paragraph 5 of Schedule III to the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.

(2) Every order made by a Civil Judge by virtue of the powers conferred upon him under sub-section (1) shall be subject to appeal to the High Court or the District Court according to the amount or value of the subject-matter exceeds or does not exceed fifty thousand rupees.

(3) Every order of the District Judge passed on appeal under sub-section (2) from the order of a Civil Judge shall be subject to an appeal to the High Court under the rules contained in the Code of Civil Procedure applicable to appeal form the appellate decrees."

7. No doubt is left on careful perusal of the said section that the order passed by the Civil Judge, Senior Division on application under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act having a valuation of Rs. 10,000/- i.e. less than Rs. 50,000/-, the appeal against the said order lay before the District Court and the appeal filed by the respondents before the Additional District Judge was maintainable and it cannot be said that no appeal lay before him.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Civil Rev. Application No. 925 of 1989

Decided On: 08.03.1995

Manohar son of Bapurao Sapre Vs. Bhaurao son of Tukaramji Shirbhate and another

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.M. Lodha, J.

Citation:1995 (2) Mh.L.J. 336, 

Print Page

Monday, 2 October 2017

Whether succession certificate proceedings can be stayed till decision of civil suit?

Undisputed facts of the case are that the petitioner has initiated the proceedings as per the provisions prescribed under Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act, 1925') for grant of succession certificate with regard to the service dues of late Jagarniya as she is her sole legal heir. During its pendency, a civil suit bearing Civil Suit No. 62-A of 2016 was instituted by the petitioner for declaration of title and injunction with regard to the immovable property left by said Jagarniya.
 During the pendency of aforesaid proceedings, the petitioner has moved an application under Section 10 of the CPC, for staying the said succession proceedings till decision of the said civil suit.
 Upon due consideration of the said application, the trial Court by its order impugned dated 26.9.2016 has rejected the said application on the ground that as per the provision of Section 10 of the CPC, only the suit could be stayed and not the proceeding initiated under the Act, 1925. The trial Court has observed further that since both the proceedings are different with each other, therefore, the application as filed is liable to be rejected. In consequence the said application filed under Section 10 of the CPC is rejected.
 In any case, the provision of Section 10 of the CPC would be attracted only when the decision of a suit operates as a res judicata in a subsequently instituted suit. The nature of both the matters are not only entirely different with each other but the jurisdiction of the Courts are also different. In such circumstances, the principles of res judicata would also not be attracted, so as to stay the proceedings initiated under the Act, 1925.
On the basis of the precedent as well as the principle, it has become evident that the proceedings, in a regular suit and the proceedings which are summary in nature contemplated by Section 372 of the Act, 1925 are entirety different and the latter proceedings would not be covered by Section 10 of the CPC. The object of issuance of a certificate and its effect is entirely different which would not result into deciding the issue finally between the parties. Consequently, the orders impugned as passed by the Courts below deserve to be and are hereby affirmed.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH

Writ Petition No. 190 of 2017

Decided On: 09.03.2017

 Hirman Bai Vs. Divisional Forest Officer, Koriya Forest Division and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Sanjay K. Agrawal, J.

Citation: AIR 2017 Chhatis 117
Print Page

Sunday, 26 February 2017

When it is not necessary to obtain probate of will?

 It can clearly be seen that the present Will is executed at Yavatmal which is admittedly not covered under the territories included in Clause, (a) of Section 57. For all other territories, if the property is an immovable property, it will be governed by the general rule of Section 213 if the property is an immovable property. However, admittedly, the property in question is not an immovable property. Therefore, the Will of the nature with which we are concerned would be governed by Clause (c) of Section 57. Now referring back to Section 213, it will be clear that the general rule, wherein it has been made necessary to obtain a probate or letter of administration for raising a right as executor or legatee, by virtue of Sub-section (2) has been made applicable to wills made by any Hindu. Buddhist. Sikh or Jaina where such Wills are referable to clauses specified in Clauses (a) and (b) of Section 57. It is, therefore, clear that the Wills of the nature covered by Sub-clause (c) of Section 57 are not covered by the general rule under Section 213, which requires a probate or letter of administration to enable a person to raise a claim to a right as an executor or legatee. The Legislature by exclusion has not made the provisions of Section 213 applicable to the Wills covered under the provisions of Sub-clause (c) of Section 57.
 Citation : 2004 (4)MhLj 887 ,2004 (4)MhLj 886
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)
W.P. No. 2084 of 2002
Decided On: 29.03.2004
 Prabhakar s/o Chinappa Chavan Vs. State of Maharashtra
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B.R. Gavai, J.


Print Page

Sunday, 21 August 2016

What is meaning of near relatives as used in S 372 of Indian succession Act?

 I am of the considered opinion that the expression "near relatives" as used in Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act, must refer to the persons who would be entitled to succeed the person who had.died intestate on the principle of nearer excluding the remoter. The "family" may comprise of the husband and wife and their minor children either being sons or unmarried daughters for the purpose of the law. The "family" may have a restricted meaning as a small unit. It cannot be lost sight of that in modern times the trend indicates "fission" and not "union". The bigger family concept of joint Hindu family is by and by withering away giving rise to small units of family.
Madhya Pradesh High Court
Munni Devi And Ors. vs Anguri Devi on 9 May, 1998
Equivalent citations: AIR 1999 MP 31, 1998 (2) MPLJ 648

Bench: S Srivastava
Print Page

Friday, 22 July 2016

Whether letter of administration can be revoked on ground of absence of personal citation to daughters of deceased?

 There happens to be no controversy with regard to
grounds so enumerated under Section 263 of the Indian Succession
Act permitting revocation and one of the grounds happens to be
absence of citation. The judgment and order impugned deals with the
aforesaid theme only. In order to scrutinize the finding recorded by
the learned lower Court, the original petition of Civil Misc. (Probate)
Case No.33 of 2010 has been gone through wherefrom it is evident
that in Para-6 of the petition only presence of three daughters have 
been shown without disclosing their names as well as full address (at
present or permanent). In absence thereof, really personal service
would have been effected as contended on behalf of learned counsel
for the appellant is a matter of concern which, ultimately frustrate the
submission made on behalf of learned counsel for the appellant.
Record did not speak with regard to identification of three daughters
of testator Late Basudeo Tiwary by name and further, any requisite for
issuance of notice against them to be available on the record.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Miscellaneous Appeal No.78 of 2012

RAMA SHANKAR TIWARI V SNEH LATA PANDEY 

CORAM:  MR. JUSTICE ADITYA KUMAR TRIVEDI
Citation:AIR 2016 (NOC)435 PAT
Date: 05-04-2016
Print Page

Saturday, 14 February 2015

Whether succession certificate can be granted in contravention of Nomination?



IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
Decided On: 07.05.2008
Smt. Naseem Begum alias Naseem AktharVs. Smt. Shaista and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Amitava Lala and Shishir Kumar, JJ.
Citation: 2008 (72) ALR 701, 2008 4 AWC3467All, II(2008)DMC669
Indian Succession Act, 1925 - Succession certificate--Nominee in service record of deceased--Whether appellant is legally wedded wife of deceased or respondent No. 1--To be determined by civil court--Suit for declaration that appellant is legally married wife--Already instituted by her--Unless service record corrected, authority obliged to pay amount to nominee.
Print Page

Friday, 13 February 2015

Whether succession certificate can be granted in respect of immovable property?

Indian Succession Act, 1925 - Part X - Issue of succession certificate - Application only in respect of debts and securities. Secs. 192 to 207 of the Act - Intended to curb interlopers - Grant of succession certificate in respect of immovable property declined.

Held: The deeming provision under Section 30 of the Act is for considering the circumstances under which a deceased person could be said to have died intestate. Section 192 to 207 are mainly intended to curb interlopers from meddling with the property of the deceased and are in the nature of summary procedure which is subject to the right of either party to bring a regular suit as saved by Sec. 208 of the Act. Thus the court below was perfectly justified in declining to grant a succession certificate in respect of the immovable property described in the II Schedule of the O.P.

Kerala High Court
Vishalakshi vs Bank Of India on 6 April, 2006
Equivalent citations: AIR 2006 Ker 255, 2006 (2) KLT 488

Bench: K Denesan, V Ramkumar
Print Page

Saturday, 22 November 2014

Whether probate can be granted by consent of parties?



In support of his contention that the said Terms of Settlement is no bar to any probate being granted to the present Will dated June 29, 1979, the learned Counsel for the respondent has cited a decision of this Court in the case of A.E.G. Carapiet v. A.Y. Derderian, reported in MANU/WB/0074/1961: AIR1961Cal359 . The learned Counsel for the respondent has referred to paragraph 28 of the Report, where it has been observed by P.B. Mukharji, J. (as His Lordship then was), speaking for the Division Bench, that a Court of probate always shies at terms of settlement. A court of probate is said to be a court of conscience which is not to be influenced by private arrangements of the parties. Either it grants probate to a Will or it rejects such grant. The court has to be satisfied in each case whether the Will for which grant of probate is proposed, is truly the Will of the capable testator or not. It has also been observed by the Division Bench in the said case that in England there is a procedure available for making the terms of settlement a rule of court, but in our country that is not so. The terms of settlement as annexed to the decree, is not a part of the grant of probate or executable as such. We will refer to the said decision in detail later on.
The learned trial Judge has held that it is a well known principle that no probate can be granted by consent of parties or as a result of any settlement. The learned trial Judge has also found that moreover in terms of the Terms of Settlement filed the caveator did not carry out his part and admitted that he made defaults in payments. The learned trial Judge has also found that the evidence of the caveator was not corroborated by any other oral or documentary evidence and also that he was not a truthful witness. It has also been found by the learned trial Judge that the propounder had discharged the onus of proving due execution, attestation and also possession of testamentary capacity by the testatrix and relying on such evidence, the trial Court was satisfied that the Will was executed by Sushila Bala Sana on June 29, 1979 and that was her last Will and Testament duly executed.
15. We have considered the respective submissions of the parties. It is now well known proposition of law that probate court cannot go into the question of title and it is a function of the probate court to see in the probate proceedings whether the Will has been duly executed, whether the testator at the relevant time was in sound and disposing state of mind and whether the testator had understood the nature and effect of such disposition and put his signature and/or mark to the document at his free will and volition. It is also a settled proposition of law that probate court cannot, by consent of parties, grant probate or reject the grant of probate.
Calcutta High Court

Sushila Bala Saha vs Saraswati Mondal on 23 February, 1989
Equivalent citations: AIR 1991 Cal 166

Bench: P K Majumdar, A M Sinha
Print Page

Saturday, 22 June 2013

Good legal article on succession certificate

A succession certificate, strictly speaking, does not effect adjudication of title of the deceased far less than that of the holder as regards the debts and securities covered thereunder. Yet, simply to afford protection to the parties paying the debts. The grant of succession certificate is conclusive against the debtor. A succession certificate is effect throughout the whole India as per section 380 of The Indian Succession Act,1925 (herein after referred as the Act). According to sections 381 and 386 of the Act, a succession certificate is conclusive as against the person/persons liable to whom full indemnity is afforded (make available) for payments made. But, despite the succession certificate is only conclusive of the representative title of the holder thereof as against the debtors, a suit of declaration will not lie that the holder of the certificate is not the legal representative of the deceased.
Print Page

Friday, 24 May 2013

Probate for will made outside specific territory by Hindus is not required


A combined reading of Sections 213 and 57 of the Act would show that where the parties to the will are Hindus or the properties in dispute are not in territories falling under Section 57(a) and (b), sub-section (2) of Section 213 of the Act applies and sub-section (1) has no application. As a consequence, a probate will not be required to be obtained by a Hindu in respect of a will made outside those territories or regarding the immovable properties situate outside those territories. 

Supreme Court of India
Clarence Pais & Ors vs Union Of India on 22 February, 2001
Print Page