Showing posts with label decree of nullity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label decree of nullity. Show all posts

Monday, 30 January 2017

Whether wife is entitled to file proceeding under DV Act after decree for nullity is passed?

In my opinion, an application by an ‘aggrieved person’ or a
Protection Officer is essential for maintaining a proceeding in view
of the provisions of Section 12 of the P.W.D.V. Act. Here petitioner filed the application as ‘aggrieved person’. Question is whether her
right to claim herself as aggrieved person was ceased with effect
from 23.04.2012. ‘Aggrieved person’ has been defined in Section 2
(a) of the P.W.D.V. Act as- “aggrieved person” means any woman
who is, or has been, in a domestic relationship with the respondent
and who alleges to have been subjected to any act of domestic
violence by the respondent. In her application petitioner alleged
that she had been subjected to physical as well as mental torture by
her husband during her living with the O.P. No. 1 in a shared
household as wife of the opposite party no. 1 which attracts the
definition of “domestic violence” as per Section 3 of the Act.
Undisputedly petitioner was wife of the opposite party no. 1 till the
passing of the decree of nullity of marriage on 23.04.2012. In order
to establish herself as aggrieved person any woman must prove first
that she is or has been in a domestic relationship with the
respondent. As per definition in Section 2 (f) “domestic
relationship” means a relationship between two persons who live or
have, at any point of time, lived together in a shared household,
when they are related by consanguinity, marriage, or through a
relationship in the nature of marriage, adoption or are family
members living together as a joint family. According to factual
matrix in this case the petitioner and opposite party no. 1 have
lived together in a shared household till petitioner’s departure from
that house during her pregnancy stage as the petitioner and
opposite party no. 1 were related each other by marriage.
Significantly, it is mentioned that out of their such joint living a
child has born. Therefore, as per definition of “domestic
relationship” it can be said that even after passing the decree of
nullity of marriage the domestic relationship between petitioner and
the opposite party no. 1 for the purpose of P.W.D.V. Act subsists
out of their past joint living as legally wedded couple. In this
connection I like to note that petitioner’s application cannot be
treated as an application under Section 125 of the Cr.P.C. The
P.W.D.V. Act is a special beneficial legislation to protect the rights
of women expanding the limited scope of Section 125, Cr.P.C. Suchwider scope is required to be kept in mind in course of dealing with
any matter under the provisions of the P.W.D.V. Act but certainly
within the ambit of the language used in the statute. Be it noted
that in a judgment in the case of D. Velusamy Vs. D.
Patchaiammal reported in (2010) 10 SCC 469 (cited by learned
counsel for the petitioner) extended scope in the P.W.D.V. Act has
been discussed. Said case, though not similar according to facts to
this case, but it throws light to understand the legal position on the
subject.
In the instant case, petitioner alleged physical and mental
torture upon her by opposite party no. 1 during continuation of
their marital relationship. She also alleged that opposite party no.
1 kept her ‘Stridhana’ property with him and she was not provided
maintenance for herself and her child by the opposite party
although the petitioner is unable to maintain herself and her child.
Since her marital relation with opposite party no. 1 has been
declared a nullity with effect from 23.04.2012, her right to claim
maintenance from opposite party no. 1 may not be proper under
Section 125 of the Cr.P.C. But she cannot be debarred from
seeking reliefs against the opposite party no. 1 ventilating her
grievances against opposite party no. 1 who is engaged in legal
profession as an advocate. In my opinion, the P.W.D.V. Act is the
proper enactment for her redress. In this regard the latin maxim,
“Ubi jus ibi remedium” (wherever there is a right there is a
remedy) may be mentioned.
 IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
 CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
Appellate Side
Present :
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE SANKAR ACHARYYA
 C.R.R. No. 3963 of 2013
 In the matter of :

Priti Dey (Chandra) Vs. Subhasish Dey & Anr.

Citation:2016 ALLMR(CRI)JOURNAL 554

Print Page

Wednesday, 11 February 2015

Whether wife can be restrained from performing re-marriage after decree of nullity is passed in her favour?

Family - Limitation on Re-marriage - Section 15 of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 - Trial Court dismissed husband's suit for restitution of conjugal rights but decreed suit of wife annulling marriage between parties on ground of former's impotency since marriage - Husband filed appeal during pendency of which wife got re-married and thereafter, applied for dismissal of appeals as infructuous - Appellant prayed status quo till final decision of appeals - Held, there was no legal incompetency in Respondent wife for contracting re-marriage once her marriage with Appellant had been annulled by a decree of nullity - Marriage between Appellant and Respondent having been annulled, their status as husband and wife of each other had ceased to exist - If Appellant wanted status quo to be preserved till final decision of appeals, he should have applied for prohibitory order restraining Respondent from marrying again till appeals filed by him had been decided - In absence of any such order, Respondent was no more wife of Appellant and there was no provision in law which created any impediment to her re-marriage - Re-marriage was thus valid marriage, it was neither void nor voidable - It could not be annulled or dissolved for reason that it was contracted during pendency of appeals, nor could it be affected by ultimate decision of appeals, even if it went in favour of Appellant - Limitations to re-marriage provided by Section 15 have no application to decree of nullity - Respondent cannot revert to her status as wife of Appellant even if his appeals succeed, because her re-marriage, under law, is neither void nor voidable, but valid and irrevocable - Appeals became infructuous and were liable to be dismissed - Appeal dismissed.


Madhya Pradesh High Court


Mohanmurari vs Smt. Kusumkumari on 22 December, 1964
Equivalent citations: AIR 1965 MP 194

Bench: T Naik, S Dayal
Print Page