Showing posts with label dispute settlement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dispute settlement. Show all posts

Sunday, 22 December 2024

Supreme Court: Plaintiff in Maharashtra will get refund of entire court fees if case is settled in any one of the modes of settlement of dispute referred to in Section 89 of CPC after court fees amendment Act 2018

 As extracted supra, the High Court in the impugned judgment had made a suggestion to the State legislature that the differences in the court fees in Lok Adalat, vis-à-vis, the forms of ADR should be done away with the view to promote the adaptation of such methods of dispute resolution among the public. It has been brought to our attention that the State legislature has indeed carried out such an amendment to the MCFA, 1959 and Section 16A has been introduced therein by way of Maharashtra Act No. X of 2018, the relevant extract of which reads under:

MAHARASHTRA ACT No. X OF 2018.

(First published, after having received the assent of the Governor in the "Maharashtra Government Gazette", on the 16th January 2018.)

An Act further to amend the Maharashtra Court-fees Act.

WHEREAS it is expedient further to amend the Maharashtra Court-fees Act, for the purposes hereinafter appearing; it is hereby enacted in the Sixty-eighth Year of the Republic of India as follows:

2. After Section 16 of the Maharashtra Court-fees Act (hereinafter referred to as "principal Act"), the following Section shall be inserted, namely:

16A. Where the court refers the parties to the suit to any one of the modes of settlement of dispute referred to in Section 89 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and suit is disposed of by the court by adaptation of any of the modes prescribed under the said section, the Plaintiff shall be entitled to a certificate from the court authorising him to receive back from the collector, the full amount of the fee paid in respect of such plaint.''. {Para 22}

23. The effect of the above being that for the time when the amendment to the MCFA, 1959 granting partial or complete refund, as the case may be, in accordance with Section 43 as amended, the persons whose matters were settled by way of ADR would not be entitled to 100% refund. Any matter settled under the processes mentioned in Section 89 Code of Civil Procedure after the coming into force of the above-extracted amendment, such parties shall receive refund of court fees in its entirety.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 14742 of 2024.

Decided On: 19.12.2024

Sanjeevkumar Harakchand Kankariya Vs. Union of India (UOI) and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

C.T. Ravikumar and Sanjay Karol, JJ.

Author: Sanjay Karol, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/1377/2024.
Print Page

Tuesday, 7 March 2023

How to determine the court's jurisdiction when an agreement contains both arbitration and recourse to court clauses for dispute settlement?

The law related to the jurisdiction of the court in the matters pertaining to arbitration is no longer res integra. It has been held in various pronouncements that all the matters arising out of an agreement/contract would be decided by the court in whose jurisdiction the seat of arbitration is decided.


 17. In the case of Shree Bhowani Cotton Mills vs Union Textile Traders, MANU/WB/0114/1966, the Calcutta High Court has held as under:


"4. the other contention on behalf of the petitioner was that it appeared from a clause of the agreement that the Courts at Calcutta would have jurisdiction, that it was open to the parties to come to a Court of law and therefore the agreement as to arbitration was vague. Settlement of dispute through the medium of arbitration and through recourse to Court of law are two different aspects. It may be that the parties envisaged disputes which are not covered by the arbitration clause and in such a case the parties might have recourse to a Court of law. That is why the parties stipulated that the Courts at Calcutta would have jurisdiction. I am unable to find any inconsistency between the provisions or to hold that there is any vagueness or uncertainty or that the clause providing for resort to Courts of law in Calcutta nullifies the arbitration agreement. Further, counsel, for the respondent rightly contended that in a document of this nature if there was any inconsistency the earlier clause would prevail unlike in a Will where the later clause would prevail. I make it quite clear that I do not hold that there is any inconsistency....."


18. Thus, in light of the detailed discussions above, this court is inclined to hold that clause 18.2 shall have a prevailing effect over the latter clause 18.3 of the agreement dated 26th August 2013 with respect to the mode of dispute resolution. It is further observed that parties have agreed for the arbitration proceedings to take place in New Delhi which can be construed as the "seat" of the arbitration and therefore, this court has the jurisdiction to entertain the present petition.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Arb. P. 1102/2022 and O.M.P. (I) (Comm.) 328/2022

Decided On: 18.01.2023

Sunil Kumar Chandra Vs. Spire Techpark Pvt. Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Chandra Dhari Singh, J.

Citation: MANU/DE/0337/2023

Print Page