Showing posts with label enquiry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label enquiry. Show all posts

Sunday, 12 March 2017

Whether it is mandatory for magistrate to make enquiry prior to issue of process against accused residing beyond jurisdiction of court?

32. Admitted position in law is that in those cases where the accused is residing at a place beyond the area in which the Magistrate exercises his jurisdiction, it is mandatory on the part of the Magistrate to conduct an enquiry or investigation before issuing the process. Section 202 of the Cr.P.C. was amended in the year by the Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Act, 2005, with effect from 22nd June, 2006 by adding the words ‘and shall, in a case where the accused is residing at a place beyond the area in which he exercises his jurisdiction’. There is a vital purpose or objective behind this amendment, namely, to ward off false complaints against such persons residing at a far off places in order to save them from unnecessary harassment. Thus, the amended provision casts an obligation on the Magistrate to conduct enquiry or direct investigation before issuing the process, so that false complaints are filtered and rejected. The aforesaid purpose is specifically mentioned in the note appended to the Bill proposing the said amendment. The essence and purpose of this amendment has been captured by this Court in Vijay Dhanuka v.Najima Mamtaj8 in the following words:
“11. Section 202 of the Code, inter alia, contemplates postponement of the issue of the process “in a case where the accused is residing at a place beyond the area in which he exercises his jurisdiction” and thereafter to either inquire into the case by himself or direct an investigation to be made by a police officer or by such other person as he thinks fit. In the face of it, what needs our determination is as to whether in a case where the accused is residing at a place beyond the area in which the Magistrate exercises his jurisdiction, inquiry is mandatory or not.
12. The words “and shall, in a case where the accused is residing at a place beyond the area in which he exercises his jurisdiction” were inserted by Section 19 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Act (Central Act 25 of 2005) w.e.f. 23-6-2006. The aforesaid amendment, in the opinion of the legislature, was essential as false complaints are filed against persons residing at far off places in order to harass them. The note for the amendment reads as follows:
“False complaints are filed against persons residing at far off places simply to harass them. In order to see that innocent persons are not harassed by unscrupulous persons, this clause seeks to amend sub-section (1) of Section 202 to make it obligatory upon the Magistrate that before summoning the accused residing beyond his jurisdiction he shall enquire into the case himself or direct investigation to be made by a police officer or by such other person as he thinks fit, for finding out whether or not there was sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused.”
The use of the expression “shall” prima facie makes the inquiry or the investigation, as the case may be, by the Magistrate mandatory. The word “shall” is ordinarily mandatory but sometimes, taking into account the context or the intention, it can be held to be directory. The use of the word “shall” in all circumstances is not decisive. Bearing in mind the aforesaid principle, when we look to the intention of the legislature, we find that it is aimed to prevent innocent persons from harassment by unscrupulous persons from false complaints. Hence, in our opinion, the use of the expression “shall” and the background and the purpose for which the amendment has been brought, we have no doubt in our mind that inquiry or the investigation, as the case may be, is mandatory before summons are issued against the accused living beyond the territorial jurisdiction of the Magistrate.”
33. For this reason, the amended provision casts an obligation on the Magistrate to apply his mind carefully and satisfy himself that the allegations in the complaint, when considered along with the statements recorded or the enquiry conducted thereon, would prima facie constitute the offence for which the complaint is filed. This requirement is emphasised by this Court in a recent judgment Mehmood Ul Rehman v. Khazir Mohammad Tunda9 in the following words:
“20. The extensive reference to the case law would clearly show that cognizance of an offence on complaint is taken for the purpose of issuing process to the accused. Since it is a process of taking judicial notice of certain facts which constitute an offence, there has to be application of mind as to whether the allegations in the complaint, when considered along with the statements recorded or the inquiry conducted thereon, would constitute violation of law so as to call a person to appear before the criminal court. It is not a mechanical process or matter of course. As held by this Court in Pepsi Foods Ltd. [Pepsi Foods Ltd. v. Judicial Magistrate, (1998) 5 SCC 749 : 1998 SCC (Cri) 1400] to set in motion the process of criminal law against a person is a serious matter.
22. The steps taken by the Magistrate under Section 190(1)(a) CrPC followed by Section 204 CrPC should reflect that the Magistrate has applied his mind to the facts and the statements and he is satisfied that there is ground for proceeding further in the matter by asking the person against whom the violation of law is alleged, to appear before the court. The satisfaction on the ground for proceeding would mean that the facts alleged in the complaint would constitute an offence, and when considered along with the statements recorded, would, prima facie, make the accused answerable before the court. No doubt, no formal order or a speaking order is required to be passed at that stage. The Code of Criminal Procedure requires speaking order to be passed under Section 203 CrPC when the complaint is dismissed and that too the reasons need to be stated only briefly. In other words, the Magistrate is not to act as a post office in taking cognizance of each and every complaint filed before him and issue process as a matter of course. There must be sufficient indication in the order passed by the Magistrate that he is satisfied that the allegations in the complaint constitute an offence and when considered along with the statements recorded and the result of inquiry or report of investigation under Section 202 CrPC, if any, the accused is answerable before the criminal court, there is ground for proceeding against the accused under Section 204 CrPC, by issuing process for appearance. The application of mind is best demonstrated by disclosure of mind on the satisfaction. If there is no such indication in a case where the Magistrate proceeds under Sections 190/204 CrPC, the High Court under Section 482 CrPC is bound to invoke its inherent power in order to prevent abuse of the power of the criminal court. To be called to appear before the criminal court as an accused is serious matter affecting one's dignity, self-respect and image in society. Hence, the process of criminal court shall not be made a weapon of harassment.”
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
(Before A.K. Sikri and Abhay Manohar Sapre, JJ.)
Criminal Appeal No. 1225 of 2016
[Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 9318 of 2012]
Abhijit Pawar 
v.
Hemant Madhukar Nimbalkar & Anr.
With
Criminal Appeal No. 1226 of 2016

Decided on December 14, 2016
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
A.K. Sikri, J.:— Leave granted.
Citation: 2016 SCC OnLine SC 1533,AIR 2017 SC 299,
(2017) 3 SCC528
Print Page

Friday, 8 May 2015

Scope of enquiry prior to order of issue process by magistrate?

We are, in this case, concerned only with the question as to whether, on a reading of the complaint, a prima facie case has been made out or not to issue process by the Magistrate. The law as regards issuance of process in criminal cases is well settled. At the complaint stage, the Magistrate is merely concerned with the allegations made out in the complaint and has only to prima facie satisfy whether there are sufficient grounds to proceed against the accused and it is not the province of the Magistrate to enquire into a detailed discussion on the merits or demerits of the case. The scope of enquiry under Section 202 is extremely limited in the sense that the Magistrate, at this stage, is expected to examine prima facie the truth or falsehood of the allegations made in the complaint. Magistrate is not expected to embark upon a detailed discussion of the merits or demerits of the case, but only consider the inherent probabilities apparent on the statement made in the complaint. In Nagawwa v. Veeranna Shivalingappa Konjalgi and Others (1976) 3 SCC 736, this Court held that once the Magistrate has exercised his discretion in forming an opinion that there is ground for proceeding, it is not for the Higher Courts to substitute its own discretion for that of the Magistrate. The Magistrate has to decide the question purely from the point of view of the complaint, without at all adverting to any defence that the accused may have.
Supreme Court of India
Fiona Shrikhande vs State Of Maharashtra & Anr on 22 August, 2013

Bench: K.S. Radhakrishnan, A.K. Sikri
Citation;(2013)14SCC44;2013 ALLSCR3108
Print Page

Friday, 27 December 2013

Whether it is necessary for magistrate to hold enquiry for disposal of golden ornaments?

It  appears  that  the  accused  persons had not  claimed  the 
property as belonging to them.   The wife of the petitioner, to whom the 
ornaments in question were belonging, was not examined as a witness 
during  the  trial.     The identity of  the property, as  the same  that was 
robbed, was not established during the  trial and as such  the order of 
acquittal was proper and legal.   However, the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 
were also not examined as witnesses during the trial.   Their stand, viz. 
as   to   whether   the   property   produced   before   the   Court   had   been 
recovered   from   them   and   further   whether   that   property   had   been 
purchased by any of them from accused No. 1 or any other accused, was 
also not ascertained during the trial.   In such a case, instead of passing 
an  order  of  return  of  property  to  the  respondent  Nos.  2  and  3,  the 
learned Magistrate ought to have held an inquiry for the limited purpose 
of  the disposal of property.     The persons  to whom  the property was 
directed to be returned, viz. the respondent Nos. 2 and 3, had not at all 
appeared before the Court and had not made any claim that the gold 

that was produced as stolen property, was actually belonging to them or 
that it had been recovered by the investigating agency from them.   In 
the   context   of   the   claim   of   the   petitioner,  it   was  also  necessary  to 
ascertain as to from whom the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 had obtained 
the   property   and   whether   it   had   been   obtained   by   them   from   the 
accused No. 1 or anybody else and under what circumstances.   It was 
also necessary to ascertain as to the circumstances in which the property 
came to the investigating agency and under what circumstances,if at all, 
it was parted with by the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 without any protest.  
8. Thus, this was a fit case where the learned Magistrate ought 
to have held an inquiry for the disposal of the property. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
              BENCH AT AURANGABAD
  CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 998 OF 2010
Anandi Roy S/o Dilipkumar Roy

V
 The  State of  Maharashtra
  
 CORAM :  ABHAY M. THIPSAY, J. 
DATE  OF JUDGMENT :  28/08/2013
Citation; 2013 ALL M R(cri)3898
Print Page