Challenge is given under section 7 and it was argued vehemently
that section 7, which is non-bailable, cannot be invoked. Under section 7,
the phrase 'use of any other unfair means' takes care of all mal-practices
or the misdeeds done when the examination is conducted. Though the
punishment is upto 6 months, the offence is made non-bailable because of
the nature and gravity of the offence. At the time of conducting
examination, the degree of sanctity required is very high and, therefore, it
is made non-bailable. The word 'examination' is defined under section
2(b) of the Act. It is as under:
“2(b). “Examination” means any examination held or proposed to be
held by any University or the Board and includes such other
examination held or proposed to be held by such other authority as
may be specified in this behalf, from time to time, by the State
Government by notification in the Official Gazette.”
The section is clear that if at all the examination is conducted by the
University or Board, then, it is covered under the examination as defined
under the Act. Besides this, when an examination is conducted by any
other authority than the university and the Board, then, the State
Government may issue notification in the official gazette specifying the
authority and the examination. I cannot accept the submission of the
learned Public Prosecutor that the “Collector” himself is to be considered
as a authority. On plain reading of the section, the legislature did not
intend to give standing authority to the Collector in respect of conducting
examination. “The other authority as may be specified' means that the
State Government has option to issue notification in the official gazette
about the said authority and once such authority is specified in the official
gazette, then, the examination conducted by the said authority, comes
within the sweep of the word 'examination' as defined under section 2(b) of
the Act and then only section 7 of the Act can be attracted. In the absence
of such notification, if the examination is conducted by any authority, then
that examination is valid and legal, however, the said Act cannot be made
applicable to that examination. However, to bring that examination within
the ambit of section 2(b) of the Act, the State Government needs to issue
notification in the official gazette specifying the authority. In the absence
of such notification, the examination cannot be an examination under 2(b)
of the Act and, therefore, if the mal practices have taken place during such
examination, cannot be said as offence as under section 7 of the Act.
Thus, notification issued by the State Government enables to bring the
acts, misdeeds, malpractices committed within the ambit of section 7 of
the Act. I am in agreement with the learned Prosecutor that the word 'may'
is not to be read as the word 'shall'. The choice is given to the State
Government to issue notification, specifying the authority. If the State
Government does not want to specify the authority, then, if any malpractice
takes place, at the time of conducting of any examination, in the absence
of such notification, those malpractices cannot be said as offences under
section 7 of the Act. Therefore, to that extent, for the interpretation of
section 7, I am with the learned Counsel for the applicants-accused.
However, the prosecution has not restricted the charges only to section 7
of the said Act but has also charged the applicants/accused under
sections 420, 464, 468, 471 of the Indian Penal Code which are nonbailable.
The manner in which the offence is committed, the custodial
interrogation of the applicants-accused is necessary. The absconding real
candidate is also to be traced. As it is a case of cheating, fraud and
forgery, I am not inclined to grant pre-arrest bail to the applicants/accused.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO.1851 OF 2015
Gajanan Ramrao Lande
Vs.
The State of Maharashtra
CORAM: MRS.MRIDULA BHATKAR, J.
DATE: MARCH 21, 2016
Citation: 2016 ALLMR(CRI)2168


