Showing posts with label foreign law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label foreign law. Show all posts

Saturday, 2 September 2017

Whether expert in foreign law can apply foreign law to facts of case before court?

What he would not be entitled to do,
however, is apply what he believes to be the foreign law in question to the facts of
the case before him and to recommend a solution. That has always been within
the exclusive province of the Court deciding the matter. This is to my mind is a
point of distinction between foreign law as a body of learning and other scientific
disciplines. A court, given its legal training, would be perfectly capable of applying
foreign law, once it is ascertained, to the facts before it. However, in respect of
other fields of inquiry, such as medicine, odontology or psychiatry, an expert
witness may legitimately bring his learning to bear upon the facts of the case in
expressing his opinion, which the Court would then proceed to weigh in the
balance along with other factors in deciding the ultimate issue. Indeed, expert
evidence of this nature would not be meaningful unless it bore upon the facts in
question. Even here, however, the role of the expert is not, as the Hon’ble
Supreme Court observes in Ramesh Chandra Agrawal v. Regency Hospital Ltd. &
Ors.(supra), that of a judge or jury and the task of adjudication falls upon the
court alone.

22. If one were to test the evidence of Mr. Keel against this touchstone viz., an
expert in foreign law would be entitled to express an opinion as to what the law is,
but not apply that law to the facts before the Court.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
NOTICE OF MOTION NO.1428 OF 2015
IN
SUIT NO. 536 OF 2011

DHIRAJLAL ALIAS DHIRUBHAI BABARIA AND ANR. … 
V
NAVINBHAI C. DAVE & ANR.
 CORAM: S. J. KATHAWALLA, J.
 Dated : 29th August, 2017

Print Page

Tuesday, 24 March 2015

Whether foreign law is a question of fact?

 It is the pleaded case of the appellant that its legal
obligation as transporter ends on its delivering the goods
entrusted to it at Benapole Customs station. Unloading of
imported goods at any customs station in this country is also
regulated by the provisions of the Customs Act, 1962. We are

sure that it must be equally regulated by the law of
Bangladesh. What exactly the law of Bangladesh is in this
regard and how the factum of delivery of goods allegedly
carried and delivered by the appellant at Benapole is to be
proved are two distinct and different matters. It is a settled
principle of private international law that foreign law is always
a question of fact which is required to be pleaded and proved
by the party whose rights or obligations flow from such foreign
law. There is no pleading or proof in this regard in the instant
case.
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 1427 OF 2007
M/s Transport Corporation of India Ltd. 
V
M/s Ganesh Polytex Ltd. 
Citation;AIR2015SC 826
Read original judgment here; click here
Print Page