Showing posts with label further examination of witness. Show all posts
Showing posts with label further examination of witness. Show all posts

Wednesday, 5 August 2020

Whether the court can examine witnesses again in de novo trial?

But so far as the other option is concerned, while earlier he could resummon the witnesses and recommence the inquiry or trial - which necessarily meant a de novo trial - he can now only resummon a witness who has already been examined for further examination and discharge him after such further examination, cross-examination and re-examination, if any. It is evident therefore that now the Magistrate or Judge can exercise his judicial discretion only for further examination of a witness already examined and not for fresh examination of witnesses for a fresh trial. Obviously, keeping in view the inevitable frequent changes in the office of the Magistrate and Judge and in order to provide a speedy trial the legislature has taken away the well established right of the accused to claim a de novo trial and that of the Court to so direct by express words of the amending statute of 1955. 
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 34 of 1992

Decided On: 21.03.1995

Ranbir Yadav  Vs.   State of Bihar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dr. A.S. Anand and M.K. Mukherjee, JJ.

Equivalent citations: 1995 AIR 1219, 1995 SCC (4) 392,JT 1995 (3) 228 1995 SCALE (2)331,MANU/SC/0245/1995
Print Page

Tuesday, 10 March 2020

Whether court can permit further examination of witness after his cross-examination?

Perusal of the evidence of the concerned photographer indicates that he
had clearly deposed that he had brought the memory card as well as compact disk
with him in Court. The trial Court however marked the photographs as Articles as
there was no certificate in terms of Section 65 B (4) of the said Act. It is seen that
on the same day, the plaintiff moved the application at Exhibit 104. The trial Court
ought to have allowed that application in the light of the examination-in-chief of the
photographer in which he had stated that he had brought the memory card and the
compact disk in Court. There is no question of wiping out any admission in the
cross-examination in the light of the fact that the photographs had been marked as
Articles. Moreover, the deposition of the said photographer as a whole would have
to be considered so that the aspect of wiping out admission if any is taken care of.
The trial Court was therefore not justified in rejecting the said application.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
WRIT PETITION NO. 4298/2019

Vasant Janrao Gaoner Vs  Rajkanya  Manikrao Ughade


CORAM : A.S.CHANDURKAR, J.
DATED : 24.09.2019
Print Page

Friday, 31 July 2015

Whether court can record further examination in chief of plaintiff?

The Counsel for the Defendants, would, however, argue that in the examination-in-chief, the Plaintiff has made no mention about the fact as to who had signed the said document and whether it was signed in his presence or that he was in a position to identify the signature appearing on the said document. According to the Defendants, this evidence ought to have come in the affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief as is required to be filed in terms of Order XVIII Rule 4 of the C.P.C. It was argued that although the Plaintiff later on entered the witness box and his further examination-in-chief has been recorded by the Court, in which all necessary details are mentioned in relation to the suit Bill of Exchange, that evidence cannot be looked into. This argument deserves to be merely stated to be rejected. There is nothing in the amended C.P.C. which precludes the Court from recording further examination-in-chief of the Plaintiff. In the present case, recording of further examination-in-chief of the Plaintiff was necessitated as the Defendants admitted all documents relied by the Plaintiffs, except the suit Bill of Exchange. For that reason, the Plaintiff, upon entering the witness box, was first examined for the purpose of further examination-in-chief. He deposed about the details in relation to the execution of said document, whereafter the document was taken on record and marked as Exhibit P-9. Ideally, the Plaintiff could have spoken about such details in the affidavit filed in lieu of examination-in-chief itself. However, failure to mention those details in the affidavit does not preclude the Plaintiff to enter the witness box to depose further; nor does it preclude the Court from permitting the Plaintiff to lead further evidence of examination-in-chief before the Court in addition to the affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief already placed on record, filed in terms of Order XVIII Rule 4 of C.P.C. All that the Court ought to ensure is that the Defendants get fair opportunity to cross-examine the Plaintiff on matters deposed by him in the further examination-in-chief.

Bombay High Court

Rajesh Varma vs Aminex Holdings And Investments, ... on 10 January, 2008

Bench: A Khanwilkar
Citation; AIR 2008(NOC)1385 Bom,2008 (2) BomCR 588
Print Page