Showing posts with label general public. Show all posts
Showing posts with label general public. Show all posts

Thursday, 22 March 2012

Whether Cause of action will accrue to individual if a legal right is for benefit of general public?

A plan sanctioned in favour of the defendant in conformity with municipal rules would not justify defendant's trespass on plaintiff's land or his interference with plaintiff's right of easement or customary right. Plaintiffs can equally challenge any public nuisance committed by the defendant.
Class of persons protected. An individual can sue for a breach of statutory duty only if the statute imposes a duty enforceable by a party aggrieved as well as a public duty. The answer to the question whether the statute imposes a duty so enforceable does not necessarily depend upon whether the statute was intended to protect a limited class of persons or the public as a whole. Nevertheless it is of importance to determine what was the intention of the statute in this respect, because, if the statute on its true construction is intended to protect a particular class, it is some indication that members of that class are intended to have a right of action, as for example in the case of statutes for the protection of factory workers, mine workers, building workers, merchants, seamen, dock labourers, shipyard workers and other employees, or intended for the protection of the public when exposed to certain dangers. On the other hand, if the statute is intended to protect the public as a whole, it will not usually be construed as giving a right of action to individual members of a particular class. In any case in which a class of individuals has a common law right of action in respect of the breach of a duty imposed by a statute, a plaintiff to succeed must show that he is within the class of persons which is intended to be protected and to which the duty is therefore owed."
ORISSA HIGH COURT


Krushna Kishore Bal vs Sankarsan Samal And Ors. on 28 November, 1973
Equivalent citations: AIR 1974 Ori 89

Bench: G Misra, B Patra, S Acharya

Print Page