The draft SOP as suggested by the learned Amicus Curiae is as under:
“1. It is suggested that testimony of children, who are victims of inter-state/inter-district child trafficking, is recorded through video conferencing either at the video conferencing room of the court complex in the district or vulnerable witness room in the court complex of the district or the office of DLSA in the district where the child is residing.1
2. To facilitate the above, it is prayed that the Ld. District Judges of all districts may ascertain the availability of video conferencing facility in the district/Taluk court complex or DLSA office and communicate the same to the jurisdictional High Court. The High Court may be requested to place the said information on its website on or before 30.04.2022. Further, it is prayed that efforts should be made to ensure that such video-conferencing infrastructure/facility is created in every district, especially in those states where the incidence of child trafficking cases is high.
3. The Secretary, DLSA of the district can be requested to be the Remote Point Coordinator (RPC) for recording of the testimony of child witnesses. However, if the Chairman of the DLSA considers necessary or desirable, he/she may appoint a Retired judicial Officer as a Remote Point Coordinator. It is prayed that the Hon'ble High Courts may place the aforesaid information i.e. the names and contact details of the RPC of each district on the website alongwith the information in para 2 above.
4. When an offence of inter-state/inter-district child trafficking is taken up for trial by a Court, and if the Court point and the remote point have video conferencing facilities, the Trial Court should ordinarily give preference to examination of the child witness through video conferencing.
5. The authorized officer at the Court Point may get in touch with the RPC at the Remote Point and work out all modalities for recording of the child witness statement through video conferencing.
6. If video conferencing is feasible, a date and time be fixed by the trial court for examination of the witness(es). Summons may be issued to the child witness(es) to present himself/herself for evidence before the RPC. The summons may be served in addition through the local process server of the remote point. The witness would be required to come with identification documents. The summons would also have the name and contact details of the RPC at the Remote Point and would also mention that the witness can take help of legal aid or other assistance through the Secretary, District Legal Service Authority, if required.
7. The child witness shall be entitled to the presence of a support person as defined in the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Rules, 2020 or any other applicable laws/guidelines or as allowed by the Trial Court. Further, best practices that are required to be followed in recording the evidence of child witnesses should continue to be followed even during the recording of the testimony through video conferencing. These include, ensuring that the child witness is provided diet money on the basis of the distance travelled by him or her to reach the remote point, the presence of a police officer at the remote point to ensure that the chid witness does not come in contact with the accused (if out on bail) or any relative of the accused, and any other best practice required by the law/relevant guidelines/being followed by the States.
8. Copy of documents, if any, required to be marked or shown to the witness may be transmitted by the Court electronically to the RPC. The RPC at the Remote Point would assist in examination of the witness and ensure that no tutoring takes place and no unauthorized person or recording device is present in the room.
9. The RPC may take all measures possible and shall seek the assistance of the support person to ensure that the child witness is comfortable. Questions posed by the Public Prosecutor/Defense Counsel may be put to the Ld. Trial Judge, who in turn will put them to the witness and the Trial Court would record the testimony of the witness. The RPC may help with translation or take the assistance of a translator/special educator if required or render any other assistance which the Learned Trial Court may require.
10. On completion of recording of evidence, the deposition will be sent by the Trial Court on email to the RPC at the Remote Point who shall take a print-out and read the same out to the witness. After ascertaining the deposition is correct and verified as under law including the affixation of the child's thumb impression/signature, the RPC may certify the same and send the deposition back, in a secure manner, to the Trial Court by Speed Post and by electronic means as permitted by law. An original may also be kept by RPC in case the Speed Post is misplaced for some reason.
11. Whenever a Trial Court proposes to record the testimony of a child witness, who is residing in another State, an intimation of the same should also be given to the Registrar of the High Court of the Court point. The Ld. Registrar may intimate the same to the Ld. Registrar of the High Court of the Remote Point with a request to render all assistance possible for recording of the testimony of the child.
12. This Standard Operating Procedure is only a broad guideline. The method and manner of recording of testimony be dependent upon the video conferencing rules framed by the respective High Courts, which would be kept in mind while recording the testimony of the child witness. It should be kept in mind that the recording of the testimony should be done expeditiously, without undue delay.
1 It can also be done at Taluk level as in some cases, video conferencing room can be available in a court complex at Taluk level or Sub Divisional level.”
9. We have carefully examined the draft SOP which contains minute details about steps to be taken for recording the testimony of child witnesses at Remote Points. Responses have been filed by the High Courts. There is no objection taken by any High Court to the SOP being put in practice immediately. We direct that the SOP, as has been reproduced above, shall be followed in all criminal trials where child witnesses, not residing near Court Points, are examined and not physically in the courts where the trial is conducted. We direct the RPCs to ensure that child-friendly practices are adopted during the examination of the witnesses.
In the Supreme Court of India
(Before L. Nageswara Rao and B.R. Gavai, JJ.)
SMW (C) No(s). 6/2021
In Re Children in Street Situations
Decided on February 1, 2022
Citation: 2022 SCC OnLine SC 189
Print Page