Showing posts with label instrument. Show all posts
Showing posts with label instrument. Show all posts

Tuesday, 12 November 2024

What is difference between document and instrument?

 Document vs. Instrument


Document: Defined under Section 3(18) of the General Clauses Act, 1897. A document can be any written or recorded proof like letters, emails, photographs, or agreements. Basically, anything that can be used as evidence.

Section 2(d) of BSA 2023- "Document" means any matter expressed or described or otherwise recorded upon any substance by means of letters, figures or marks or any other means or by more than one of those means, intended to be used, or which may be used, for the purpose of recording that matter and includes electronic and digital records.
Print Page

Thursday, 21 March 2019

Whether a party can adduce secondary evidence of photocopy of insufficiently stamped document after impounding it?

 It was the case of the appellant-tenant that the original copy of the agreement which was with him was stolen and thus he was unable to produce the original document dated 28.3.1988, but was in possession of a photostat copy of the agreement and made a prayer for receipt of the photocopy of the agreement as secondary evidence under Section 63 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.


The provisions of this section (section 35) which allow a document to be admitted in evidence on payment of penalty, have no application when the original document, which was unstamped or was insufficiently stamped, has not been produced; and, accordingly, secondary evidence of its contents cannot be given. To hold otherwise would be to add to the Act a provision which it does not contain. Payment of penalty will not render secondary evidence admissible, for under the stamp law penalty is leviable only on an unstamped or insufficiently stamped document actually produced in Court and that law does not provide for the levy of any penalty on lost documents . This Court had an occasion again to consider the scope and ambit of Sections 33(1), 35 and 36 of the Act and Section 63 of the Indian Evidence Act in Jupudi Kesava Rao v. Pulavarthi Venkata Subbarao and others AIR 1971 SC 1070 and held that :-
13. The first limb of Section 35 clearly shuts out from evidence any instrument chargeable with duty unless it is duly stamped. The second limb of it which relates to acting upon the instrument will obviously shut out any secondary evidence of such instrument, for allowing such evidence to be let in when the original admittedly chargeable with duty was not stamped or insufficiently stamped, would be tantamount to the document being acted upon by the person having by law or authority to receive evidence. Proviso (a) is only applicable when the original instrument is actually before the Court of law and the deficiency in stamp with penalty is paid by the party seeking to rely upon the document.
Clearly secondary evidence either by way of oral evidence of the contents of the unstamped document or the copy of it covered by Section 63 of the Indian Evidence Act would not fulfil the requirements of the proviso which enjoins upon the authority to receive nothing in evidence except the instrument itself. Section 35 is not concerned with any copy of an instrument and a party can only be allowed to rely on a document which is an instrument for the purpose of Section 35. `Instrument is defined in Section 2(14) as including every document by which any right or liability is, or purports to be created, transferred, limited, extended, extinguished or recorded. There is no scope for inclusion of a copy of a document as an instrument for the purpose of the Stamp Act.
14. If Section 35 only deals with original instruments and not copies Section 36 cannot be so interpreted as to allow secondary evidence of an instrument to have its benefit.
Law is now no doubt well settled that copy of the instrument cannot be validated by impounding and this cannot be admitted as secondary evidence under the Indian Stamp Act, 1899.

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Hariom Agrawal Vs. Prakash Chand Malviya dated 8 October 2007.

B.N. Agrawal,P.P. Naolekar & P. Sathasivam
(arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil)No.12573 of 2006)
Citation:(2007) 8 SCC 514
(2007)
Print Page

Tuesday, 12 May 2015

How to ascertain stamp duty chargeable on an instrument?

In this regard, it would be necessary to refer to the
provisions of Section 2(d) of the said Act to determine the
date on which the instrument in question became chargeable
under the said Act. The provisions of Section 2(d) of the said
Act are clear inasmuch as the relevant date when the
instrument becomes chargeable is the date of its execution.
In ITC Limited & another (supra), the learned Single Judge
while considering the provisions of Section 2(d) of the said
Act in para 10 held as under :-
“10. From the aforesaid two definitions of the
expression, ‘chargeable’ and ‘duly stamped’, it
is clear that the stamp duty chargeable on an
instrument is the duty chargeable in
accordance with law in force in the State at the

time of execution of such instrument. The
chargeability of instrument starts at the time of
its execution in the State.”
In the case in hand, the document was executed on
27-03-1981 and registered on 30-03-1981. Thus, in terms of
provisions of Section 2(d) of the said Act the deed of
conveyance became 'chargeable’ on 27-03-1981. It will,
therefore, have to be determined as to whether the said
instrument was ‘chargeable' under the provisions of Section
25 of the said Act as it stood on 27-03-1981.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH NAGPUR.
WRIT PETITION NO.6069 OF 2005

Universal Ferro & Allied Chemicals Limited, Vs The Deputy InspectorGeneral of Registration & Deputy Controller of Stamps
Nagpur.
CORAM: A. S. CHANDURKAR J.
Dated : SEPTEMBER 24 & 25, 2014.
Citation;2015(2) MHLJ 152
Print Page