Further, it is to be noted that P.W. 4, in his cross-examination, specifically stated that his sister had not told the name of the accused. In the background of these statements, the testimony of P.W. 5-victim is required to be considered. Though she was mentally retarded, it appears that the learned Trial Judge recorded her testimony. Rather it was the decision by the prosecution to examine the victim though she was mentally challenged. Section 118 of the Indian Evidence Act specifies who may testify. It is prescribed that all persons shall be competent to testify unless the Court considers that they are prevented from understanding the questions put to them, or from giving rational answers to those questions, by tender years, extreme old age, disease, whether of body or mind, or any other cause of the same kind. Therefore, the said Section rather gives a discretion to the Court to consider whether a witness prevented from testifying himself or herself due to above-said in capacities. The explanation of Section 118 of the Evidence Act states that a lunatic is not incompetent to testify, unless he is prevented by his lunacy from understanding the questions put to him and giving rational answers to them. Under such circumstance, even a lunatic/mentally challenged person can also testify, but it would be for the Court to consider the capacity of such witness. With this legal position, if we consider the testimony of P.W. 5, it appears that even the oath was administered to the witness. Before administering oath, whether certain questions were put to the victim to testify, whether she is able to give rational answers is not reflected. A note has been taken that witness being mentally retarded, her brother, who can understand the language of the witness and, therefore, he was ordered to stand near the witness box to interpret her statement. We find that proper procedure has not been adopted by the learned Trial Court to record the testimony of P.W. 5-victim. Whether she had given answers by gestures or any other language, is not clarified. Further, P.W. 1-brother of the victim who was allowed to stand nearby the victim when victim's testimony was recorded, his own testimony as P.W. I was recorded on 14.10.2014, whereas the victim's testimony was taken on 06.02.2015. In the note it is stated that he was given the job of an interpreter. If it is so, then again oath ought to have been administered to the interpreter before recording the testimony of the victim. With these procedural lacuna's, we try to consider what the victim has stated. She has stated that she has two brothers and two sisters. P.W. 1 is the elder brother. The year prior to her deposition, P.W. 1 was out of village. Male issue was begotten to her from guest . Then it appears that five photographs were shown to witness and she was asked to identify the "Guest" out of those five photographs and then it is stated that she identified the guest in photograph No. 3 and shown to the Court and that photograph is marked as Exhibit-26. Then she has stated that the accused present in the Court is the same guest. We failed to understand what kind of procedure was adopted. The Trial Court has no clarified, who were those other four persons, whose photographs were shown to the victim. When the accused was present before the Court, then why this task was undertaken by the learned Presiding Officer. It is then certain that in her examination-in-chief, she has not given the name of the accused, but she named him as 'guest' . The learned APP who was conducting the matter before the Trial Court has not taken pains to ask the relationship of the accused and how accused could have been termed as 'guest' . In cross-examination, it has been taken on record that she has two sisters. Both are married and the husband of sister is called as 'guest' . Now, going back to testimony of P.W. 1, at the cost of repetition, it can be said that P.W. 1 has not disclosed that accused is the husband of sister. Further, the victim in her cross-examination has stated that the male issue she had begotten was not from the accused, who is present before the Court. That means, she is denying the said fact. Before we further analyse this fact, it is to be noted that in the testimony of P.W. 1, it was not brought on record that the victim delivered a child and what happened to the child.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)
Criminal Appeal No. 306 of 2016
Decided On: 15.03.2023
Suresh Devidas Malche Vs The State of Maharashtra
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Vibha Kankanwadi and Y.G. Khobragade, JJ.
Author: Vibha Kankanwadi, J.
Citation: MANU/MH/0997/2023,2023 Lawweb (Bom HC ) 22.
Print Page
