Showing posts with label judicial independence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label judicial independence. Show all posts

Monday, 4 February 2019

Whether High court can stay an order before it is passed by subordinate court?

 In our considered view, the High Court ought
not to have issued directions of this nature. It was
legally not permissible to do so. Indeed, the High
Court by issuing such directions which are
essentially passed in anticipation of the order being
passed by an appellate authority, interfered with the
judicial independence of an appellate authority in
deciding the appeals in accordance with law.
73) It is the sole discretion of the appellate authority
under the Act to decide the appeal based on the facts
involved in the appeal, and legal provisions which

eventually result in passing a judicial order. No
higher court can pass such directions merely on
anticipation of an order being passed by an appellate
authority. It is only after the order is passed, that
the aggrieved person has a legal right to take
recourse to a legal remedy available in law against
such order by approaching to a higher forum and
pray for grant of appropriate relief against such
order.
74) This stage in this case is yet to arrive. The High
Court should not have, therefore, preempted
the
passing of any order of the appellate authority, while
deciding the Writ Petition. It is a settled law that the
Court can stay or quash only those orders, which are
impugned in the lis before it. A fortiori, the Court
cannot stay or/and quash the orders in anticipation,
before they are passed. We cannot, therefore, uphold
such writ/directions issued by the High Court.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL Nos.126-156
OF 2019

Manish S. Pardasani Vs  Inspector State Excise, P1,Division, Mumbai(Suburbs)

Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.
Dated:January 7, 2019
Print Page