The Apex Court reversing the concurrent judgments, observed thus:
10. It is however not possible to accept that services in lieu of the right of occupation would amount to receipt of rent under the Rent Act to create sub tenancy .This frustrates and defeats the purpose of the rent Act. Take for instance a case where a person renders services to the landlord in lieu of rent but this will completely erode the provisions of Rent Act and defeat the claims for services. Work performed by subtenants and the wages paid by doing certain kind of services may be in lieu of rent as in the case of agricultural tenancies. But in urban area in civilized times that cannot be so. The Rent Act, 1956 cannot be fitted into a position where the services can be rendered in exchange of the right of occupation.
12. The structure of the Rent Act in the instant case, as indicated above would also indicate that. We hold therefore that second ingredient, viz. rent agreed, was not there. And as such on the case pleaded and proved there could not have been any sub tenancy.
It can clearly be seen that the Apex Court in clear terms has held that insofar as tenancy in urban area is concerned, for creating sub tenancy, an agreed rent is an essential ingredient.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Writ Petition No. 6215 of 2008
Decided On: 04.05.2011
Shashikant G. Mehta Vs. Soonoo Minoo Khajotia and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B.R. Gavai, J.
Citation: 2011(4) MHLJ 247