Showing posts with label measurement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label measurement. Show all posts

Friday, 5 May 2017

Whether court should appoint commissioner at initial stage of proceeding?

In Mahendranath Parida (supra), this
Court held that when the controversy is as to
identification, location or measurement of the 
land or premise or object, local investigation
should be done at an early stage so that the
parties can be aware of the report of the
Commissioner and can go to trial prepared.
In Ramakant Naik and others vs. Bhanja
Dalabehera, 2015 AIR CC 1724 (ORI), this
Court held that issuance of a Commission for
local investigation is the discretion of the
Court. While considering the prayer for
appointment of Commission, the Court must
apply its mind to the facts and circumstances
of the case and pass order. No straight jacket
formula can be laid down. Before issuance of
Commission, the Court must be satisfied that
there is prima facie case in favour of the
applicant.
On a reading of Order 26 Rule 9 C.P.C.,
it is manifest that the stage of appointment of
Survey Knowing Commissioner has not been
prescribed. When the legislature in its wisdom
has not prescribed the stage of appointment of
Survey Knowing Commissioner, the power of
the Court to appoint the Survey Knowing
Commissioner can not be cabined, cribbed or
confined.”
9. In view of the authoritative pronouncement of this Court in
the case of Bhabesh Kumar Das (supra), the order dated 2.9.2016
passed by the learned Addl. Civil Judge (Junior Division), Narasinghpur
in I.A No.06 of 2016 arsing out of C.S. No.20 of 2016 is quashed. 
HIGH COURT OF ORISSA: CUTTACK
CMP No.1403 of 2016

Nayana Manjari Sahoo V  Rajakishore Sahoo & another

PRESENT:
 DR. JUSTICE A.K.RATH
Citation: AIR 2017 Orissa

Date of judgment: 15.02.2017

Print Page

Thursday, 2 March 2017

When boundary of land will not prevail over measurement of land?

The Madras High Court in the case of Dina Malar
Publications, A Tamil Daily, Reptd., by its Partner, R.K.
Krishnamoorthy Vs. The Tiruchirapalli Municipality, Reptd., by its
Executive Authority, The Commr., reported in (1983) 2 MLJ 340
(Madras) has held that in case of doubtful or varying extents in the
documents of title relating to the property, boundaries should be preferred
to the extent. It is held that this principle can be applied only to a case
where there is an element of doubt with reference to the extent of the
area sold. In my view, since the area of the land sold to the defendants
was absolutely clear in the sale deed itself which was duly proved by the
documentary as well as the oral evidence, the question of the boundaries

prevailing over the area of the land mentioned in the sale deed did not
arise.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
SECOND APPEAL NO.209 OF 1994

 Bhujanga Abba Patil  V Dnyanu Ramchandra Powar 

 CORAM : R.D. DHANUKA, J.

PRONOUNCED ON : 26th October 2016
Citation: 2017(1) ALLMR 110
Print Page

Sunday, 24 July 2016

Whether boundaries will prevail over measurement of land?

 It is well established by several decisions of courts that where the boundaries in a document are vague and indefinite, the area should prevail, but where the boundaries are specific and definite the area must be taken as given only approximately vide Bholanath Chattopadhyaya v. Mrityunjay Chattopadhya, 153 Ind Cas 532: (AIR 1934 Cal 851). A decision of our High Court in Subbaya Chakkaliyan v. M. Mutbiah Gounden, 19 Mad LW 245: (AIR 1924 Mad 493) of Krishnan and Waller, JJ. has also put the position thus:
"Ordinarily when a piece of land is sold with definite boundaries, unless it is very clear from the circumstances surrounding the sale that a smaller extent than what is covered by the boundaries was intended to be sold, the rule of interpretation is that boundaries must prevail as against measurement?."
A similar view is also expressed in the Palestine Kupat Am Bank Co-operative Society Ltd. v. Government of Palestine, AIR 1948 PC 207 "In construing a grant of land a description by fixed boundaries is to be preferred to a conflicting description by area."
Madras High Court
Dharmakanny Nadar ... vs Mahalingam Nadar Gopalakrishna ... on 20 April, 1962
Equivalent citations: AIR 1963 Mad 147

Bench: Ramakrishnan
Print Page

Monday, 16 December 2013

Encroachment suit- measurement of land -procedure to be followed


  Inspite of having the original record of measurement available with the D.I.L.R., filing of only copies of the said record before the Court and Court coming to the conclusion that the defendant has encroached over the land of the plaintiff to the extent of 5 R., was prima facie incorrect approach. In fact the original record of measurement and map should have been insisted by the trial Court.

12. The fourth point i.e. without measuring both the Survey Numbers whether inference can be drawn on the basis of the measurement of only plaintiff's land that the defendant has made encroachment, in my considered view, the Surveyor/ D.I.L.R. should have measured both the Survey Numbers i.e. Survey No. 74 and Survey No. 75. Unless both the Survey Numbers are measured, it is not possible to come to the conclusion that there is encroachment by defendant over the plaintiff's land. The D.I.L.R. should have measured Survey No. 74 and 75 and after measurement of both Survey Numbers, should have submitted report to the Court and on the basis of measurement of both the Survey Numbers belonging to plaintiff and defendant, the Court should have adjudicated the point in issue.
Bombay High Court
Harsing Kewala Rathod vs Ramji S/O Hemla on 15 December, 2008
Bench: S. S. Shinde1
Citation; 2009 (2) ALL M R 169

Print Page