The charges
levelled against the petitioner were that he misbehaved with the female
employees working in the department and the behaviour of the petitioner with
the female employees was improper.
After hearing the learned advocates for the respective parties and
examining the record, particularly, the report submitted by the Enquiry Officer, I
find that the report submitted by the Enquiry Officer is as vague as it could be
and it cannot be said that there is any finding recorded by the Enquiry Officer
which brings home the alleged guilt of the petitioner. There is no justification on
the record as to why the complaint about the alleged incidents was made after
the period of 7 or 8 years. The Enquiry Officer has found that the statements
given by some of the witnesses examined during the enquiry are not supported
by the statements of the other witnesses or there are contradictions. I am
conscious that the charges against the delinquent in the departmental enquiry
are required to be considered on the basis of the theory of preponderance of
probabilities and it is not necessary that the parameters applicable in criminal
trial are required to be applied. However, the employee cannot be deprived of
his legal right of continuing in the employment on the basis of motivated
complaints without examining the truthfulness of the allegations made against
the employee. Moreover, the Enquiry Officer is required to give definite finding
after considering the material on the record that the charges levelled against the
delinquent are proved. In the present case, the Enquiry Officer has not been
able to bring home the alleged guilt for which the petitioner was charged and
therefore, he has recorded that charges 1 and 2 are partly proved against the
petitioner.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH AT NAGPUR
Dhanraj s/o Nankuprasad Gupta V Public Works Department,
CORAM : Z.A. HAQ, J.
DATE : 12.11.2014
Citation;2015(2) MHLJ 351
