Showing posts with label mobile number. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mobile number. Show all posts

Saturday, 15 August 2026

Supreme Court: Whether the court can convict the accused if Mobile numbers relied upon by the prosecution were not in the name of the accused persons?

 The appellants herein seek to question the findings on the ground that the mobile numbers reflected in the call detail records did not belong to the accused persons. This, in fact, is another incriminating circumstance because the numbers did not belong to the accused persons, but they were found running in the mobile devices recovered from the possession or at the instance of the accused persons. Thus, they were using fake numbers to conceal their identities and to evade surveillance. Notably, A1 was admittedly using two numbers - one registered in his own name and one in the name of his employee (a worker in his factory). Both the numbers were mentioned by him in his original complaint after the incident. The number used by A4 was found running in the mobile phone recovered from him, and the number used by A5 was installed in his phone, which was left by him at his home when he fled away after the incident. When called by the investigators, the call was picked up by the mother of A5 and she disclosed that it was used by A5 only. Again, no rebuttal has been advanced to dispute these facts. {Para 19}

20. The call details reveal that the accused persons were in constant touch with each other using these numbers, irrespective of the persons in whose names the numbers were officially registered. The evidence on record has indicated sufficient nexus between the numbers reflected in the call detail records and the accused persons. If there was any discrepancy in this evidence, the accused persons could have led counter evidence to that effect. However, they failed to rebut this crucial technical evidence. The Court cannot set aside consistent evidentiary findings on bare assertions, without any cogent evidence to support the assertions.

 In the Supreme Court of India

(Before Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma, JJ.)

Criminal Appeal No(s). 3866 of 2025


Piyush Shyamdasani  Vs State of Uttar Pradesh 

Decided on July 20, 2026


Citation: 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1357
Print Page

Wednesday, 3 June 2026

Shared for Service, Not for Personal Use: Why Misusing a Phone Number Can Raise Legal Concerns Under India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023


 
A mobile number is often shared casually in daily life — to book a cab, receive a delivery, complete a digital payment, or obtain a service update. Yet the fact that a number is visible in a transaction does not make it freely available for personal use. Under India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, a mobile number can constitute personal data when it relates to an identifiable individual, and its use must remain tied to a lawful purpose.

This means that if a number is shared for a limited purpose, such as ride coordination, billing, delivery, or customer support, it should not ordinarily be reused for personal messaging, unrelated marketing, or informal follow-up without a valid legal basis. The law is gradually reinforcing a simple principle: access to personal data is not the same as permission to use it however one wishes.

Print Page