Shri Godbole submitted that the tenant is not necessarily required to pay a rent in money and can be permitted to pay it in kind. He specifically referred section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act, whereunder in a lease of immovable property a service rendered can be the consideration for the lease. He drew my attention to the fact that it was the understanding between the parties that apart from his service in the School, Hasan Jahagirdar was to look after the Hostel. Shri Godbole submitted that this service was the consideration for the tenancy. Shri Godbole, therefore, submitted that the premises occupied by Hasan Jahagirdar were covered under the Bombay Rent Act and the first respondent landlord was required to take action under the provisions of that Act only and could not file a civil suit to evict Hasan Jahagirdar and his family members from the suit premises.
Shri Jamdar drew my attention to the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Dipak Banerjee v. Lilabati Chakraborty, reported in MANU/SC/0752/1987 : [1987]3SCR680 , wherein the question before the Supreme Court was as to whether the sewing activity can be considered to be the rent paid in kind and in a para 10, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in terms held that under the provisions of the particular Rent Act, service cannot be a consideration for sub-lease is the question. The Court observed "It is however, not possible to accept that services in lieu of the right of occupation would amount to receipt of rent... This frustrates and defeats the purpose of the Rent Act".
Shri Jamdar took me through the provisions of the Rent Act and particularly the provisions regarding fixation of the standard rent, arrears of rent, additions to the rent etc., and submitted that if any such interpretation is accepted, a number of provisions of the Act would become redundant and in that context he drew my attention to the observations of the Supreme Court in the case of M/s. Alphali Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra and others, reported in : 1989 (44) ELT 613 (SC) , that the provisions should be so construed in the context of the Act that no word of the statute is rendered redundant, superfluous or meaningless. There need not be two views on what Shri Jamdar canvassed. The provisions of the Rent Act are quite clear. If one looks into a number of provisions contained in the Act, it is very clear that the rent has to be paid through money. If that was not so in number of provisions of the Act relating to the arrears of rent, additions to the rent, standard rent etc., would become redundant. The notice to be given by the landlord to the tenant calling upon him to pay the rent has also to be for payment in money and it cannot be in service. Under these circumstances, the submission of Shri Jamdar, is required to be accepted that the provisions of section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act, cannot be invoked for urban residential tenancy which are specifically covered under the Acts of the tenancy such as Bombay Rent Act.
6. In the circumstances, stated above, it is very clear that Hasan Jahagirdar was not required to pay any rent per month and was not a tenant of the first respondent institution. His occupation was at the highest a personal privilege of occupation and not tenancy.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
S.A. No. 758 of 1997
Decided On: 12.07.1999
Chinnupashabi Vs. Fatesingh Sikshan Sanstha and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
H.L. Gokhale, J.
Citation: 1999 (4) ALL MR 405