Thus, this Court feels that a human dignity attaches to
itself also a right of concept of autonomy and also a right to
take ones own decisions for himself or herself relating to
his/her body and choices of his/per partner for whom he or
she wishes to live or have sexual intercourse. These choices
and selections cannot be a subject matter of departmental
proceedings and no employer can be allowed to do moral
policing on its employees which go beyond the domain of his
public life.
44. In view of the above discussions and observations, this
Court is of the opinion that an act of relationship entered by
an individual with another female or male as the case may be
while is/her spouse is alive would be an act of amounting to
adultery and would be considered as an immoral act so far as
the Indian society is concerned. It is not to be appreciated.
The same would, however, not be a ground for initiating
(33 of 33) [CW-2067/1999]
departmental proceedings by the employer and it be left best
for the person who may be affected individually to take
remedy and proceed against him/her in civil law or for
initiating divorce proceedings as the case may be.
45. Thus, this Court concludes that the respondents had no
authority to issue letter dated 30/01/1999 directing the
petitioners to undergo DNA Test alongwith child of Dharma
Rani and the action of suspending the petitioners and issuing
subsequently memorandum dated 16/12/2000 under Rule 16
of the Rajasthan Civil Services (Classification, Control &
Appeal) Rules, 1958 is found to be illegal and unjustified and
the same is quashed and set aside and further, it is held that
the State Government shall not initiate departmental
proceedings on the basis of a complaint of any person against
a Government servant alleging therein of the said
Government servant having extra-marital relationship with
another man or woman whether married or unmarried.
Reportable
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 2067/1999
Mahesh Chand Sharma Vs State of Rajasthan
MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA
Pronounced on 07/03/2019
Print Page
itself also a right of concept of autonomy and also a right to
take ones own decisions for himself or herself relating to
his/her body and choices of his/per partner for whom he or
she wishes to live or have sexual intercourse. These choices
and selections cannot be a subject matter of departmental
proceedings and no employer can be allowed to do moral
policing on its employees which go beyond the domain of his
public life.
44. In view of the above discussions and observations, this
Court is of the opinion that an act of relationship entered by
an individual with another female or male as the case may be
while is/her spouse is alive would be an act of amounting to
adultery and would be considered as an immoral act so far as
the Indian society is concerned. It is not to be appreciated.
The same would, however, not be a ground for initiating
(33 of 33) [CW-2067/1999]
departmental proceedings by the employer and it be left best
for the person who may be affected individually to take
remedy and proceed against him/her in civil law or for
initiating divorce proceedings as the case may be.
45. Thus, this Court concludes that the respondents had no
authority to issue letter dated 30/01/1999 directing the
petitioners to undergo DNA Test alongwith child of Dharma
Rani and the action of suspending the petitioners and issuing
subsequently memorandum dated 16/12/2000 under Rule 16
of the Rajasthan Civil Services (Classification, Control &
Appeal) Rules, 1958 is found to be illegal and unjustified and
the same is quashed and set aside and further, it is held that
the State Government shall not initiate departmental
proceedings on the basis of a complaint of any person against
a Government servant alleging therein of the said
Government servant having extra-marital relationship with
another man or woman whether married or unmarried.
Reportable
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S. B. Civil Writ Petition No. 2067/1999
Mahesh Chand Sharma Vs State of Rajasthan
MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA
Pronounced on 07/03/2019