Showing posts with label nominal deed. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nominal deed. Show all posts

Wednesday, 8 February 2017

When registered sale deed should not be treated as nominal?

The deed of sale being a registered one and apparently containing stipulations of transfer of right, title and interest by the vendor in favour of the vendee, the onus of proof was upon the defendant to show that the said deed was, in fact, not executed or otherwise does not reflect the true nature of transaction.
A document, as is well known, must be construed in its entirety. Reading the said in its entirety, there cannot be any doubt whatsoever that it was a deed of sale. It satisfies all the requirements of a conveyance of sale as envisaged under Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act.
In Bishwanath Prasad Singh v. Rajendra Prasad& Anr. [(2006) 4 SCC 432], this Court held :
"16. A deed as is well known must be construed having regard to the language used therein. We have noticed hereinbefore that by reason of the said deed of sale, the right, title and interest of the respondents herein was conveyed absolutely in favour of the appellant. The sale deed does not recite any other transaction of advance of any sum by the appellant to the respondents which was entered into by and between the parties. In fact, the recitals made in the sale deed categorically show that the respondents expressed their intention to convey the property to the appellant herein as they had incurred debts by taking loans from various other creditors.
 It will bear repetition to state that with a view to ascertain the nature of a transaction the document has to be read as a whole. A sentence used or a term used may not be determinative of the real nature of transaction."
 The document in question was not only a registered one but also the title deeds in respect of the properties have also been handed over. Symbolical possession if not actual physical possession, thus, must be held to have been handed over. It was acted upon. Appellants started paying rent in respect of the said property. No objection thereto has been raised by the respondent.
If the sum of Rs.50,000/- was the amount of loan wherefor the deed of sale was executed by way of security, having regard to his admission that the firm is an income-tax payee and maintains books of account in regular course of business, failure on his part to produce any documentary evidence merited drawing of an adverse inference.
Right of possession over a property is a facet of title. As soon as a deed of sale is registered, the title passes to the vendee. The vendor, in terms of the stipulations made in the deed of sale, is bound to deliver possession of the property sold. If he does not do so, he makes him liable for damages. 
If the appellant was able to prove that the deed of sale was duly executed and it was neither a sham transaction nor represented a transaction of different character, a suit for recovery of possession was maintainable. A heavy onus lay on the respondent to show that apparent state of affairs was not the real state of affairs.
A heavy burden of proof lay upon the defendant to show that the transaction was a sham one. It was not a case where the parties did not intend to enter into any transaction at all. Admittedly, a transaction had taken place. Only the nature of transaction was in issue. A distinction must be borne in mind in regard to the nominal nature of a transaction which is no transaction in the eye of law at all and the nature and character of a transaction as reflected in a deed of conveyance. The construction of the deed clearly shows that it was a deed of sale. The stipulation with regard to payment of compensation in the event appellants are dispossessed was by way of an indemnity and did not affect the real nature of transaction.
Reportable

Supreme Court of India

Vimal Chand Ghevarchand Jain & Ors vs Ramakant Eknath Jajoo on 23 March, 2009

Bench: S.B. Sinha, Mukundakam Sharma
Citation:2009(5)MHLJ 597
Print Page

Sunday, 19 April 2015

When sale deed can not be treated as nominal sale deed?

The trial Court held that after execution of sale-deed in 1972, the plaintiff never exercised right under the sale-deed for five years. It is to be noted that the suit property is open plot and the defendant after five years started activity of digging the pits for making construction. There was nothing wrong if the defendant wanted to start activity on the suit plot after five years of its sale-deed, since there was no structure standing on the plot. On the contrary, the record shows that the defendant got a plan sanctioned from the Municipal Council after five years of the sale-deed for making construction which is at Exh.68. Merely because the defendant started his activity of getting plan sanctioned for constructing a house or making some construction on a open plot, one cannot jump to a conclusion that the sale-deed was nominal. On the contrary, the appellant/plaintiff did not say a word as to within what period he was to repay the entire amount and get back the sale-deed executed in his favour. If the sale transaction was really nominal, what steps did he take in those five years to assert accordingly. What amount did he repay during those five years. Appellant/plaintiff kept all this a 'mystery'. To repeat, this is all the more so because the appellant/plaintiff never asserted during this period of five years that the sale-deed was nominal particularly because he had transferred the property by a registered sale-deed.

Bombay High Court

Shankarlal Ganulal Khandelwal Vs Balmukund
 Surajmal Bharuka

Second Appeal No.136/1983  on 20 April, 2011
Bench: A. B. Chaudhari
   
Print Page