Showing posts with label permanent disability certificate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label permanent disability certificate. Show all posts

Thursday, 6 November 2025

Bombay HC: Whether Motor accident claim tribunal can grant compensation under conventional heads if petitioner fails to prove permanent disability certificate?

 The disability certificate at Exh.77 is issued by Civil Surgeon. However, perusal of Exh.77 does not make it clear, as to whether that permanent disability is restricted to particular limb or not and the handwritten part of the same is giving three different injuries. Further, though that disability certificate is given by Civil Surgeon, who can be said to be the Government servant, yet said Civil Surgeon was not examined. In view of the decision in Rajesh Kumar vs. Raghuveer Singh, MANU/SC/7686/2008 : 2008 ACJ 2131 SC, Tribunal cannot accept disability certificate without examining the Doctor concerned. Under such circumstance the further evidence ought to have been led by the claimant that the said disability had affected his earning capacity. Mere statement by the claimant that he cannot perform work as before is not sufficient under such circumstance. However, that does not estop or preclude him from claiming compensation under other heads. Each of the Doctor has given the details of the treatment that was given to the claimant. He has undergone operations twice which required hospitalization. Under such circumstance, definitely case is made out to grant compensation under those conventional heads. The medical bills have been proved through these doctors as well as through PW 4 Sucheta Shah. Those bills which have been proved on record to the tune of Rs. 45,000/-. A statement has been made by the claimant that he has incurred medical expenses of more than Rs. 1,00,000/- but the documents are not supporting his statement. Therefore, whatever he is entitle to get reimbursement is to the tune of Rs. 45,000/-. Further, taking into consideration the fact that he has undergone two operations, he is entitle to get compensation of Rs. 40,000/- towards pains and sufferings. In all he was required to be hospitalized for about 15 days and therefore, he would have been looked after by somebody. Under such circumstance, under the head of attendance it would be just and proper to award amount of Rs. 10,000/- to him.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

First Appeal No. 155 of 2017

Decided On: 26.06.2019

Girdhar Brijmohan Maru Vs. Vimal Lalchand Mutha and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vibha Kankanwadi, J.

Citation:  MANU/MH/1607/2019.

Read full judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Saturday, 1 November 2025

Supreme Court: Unless author of permanent disability certificate is examined, permanent disability certificate is not admissible in evidence

 The certificate in question in this case was obtained after two years. It is not known as to whether the Civil Surgeon of the hospital treated the appellant. On what basis, such a certificate was issued two years after the accident took place is not known. The author of the said certificate had not been examined. Unless the author of the certificate examined himself, it was not admissible in evidence. Whether the disability at 60% was calculated on the basis of the provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act or otherwise is not known. It is also not known as to whether he was competent to issue such a certificate.  {Para 9}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3538 of 2008 

Decided On: 13.05.2008

Rajesh Kumar Vs. Yudhvir Singh and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S.B. Sinha and L.S. Panta, JJ.

Author: S.B. Sinha, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/7686/2008 : 2008 ACJ 2131 SC.

Print Page

Bombay HC: Motor Accident claim Tribunal cannot accept permanent disability certificate unless concerned Doctor is examined

The disability certificate at Exh.77 is issued by Civil Surgeon. However, perusal of Exh.77 does not make it clear, as to whether that permanent disability is restricted to particular limb or not and the handwritten part of the same is giving three different injuries. Further, though that disability certificate is given by Civil Surgeon, who can be said to be the Government servant, yet said Civil Surgeon was not examined. In view of the decision in Rajesh Kumar vs. Raghuveer Singh, MANU/SC/7686/2008 : 2008 ACJ 2131 SC, Tribunal cannot accept disability certificate without examining the Doctor concerned. Under such circumstance the further evidence ought to have been led by the claimant that the said disability had affected his earning capacity. Mere statement by the claimant that he cannot perform work as before is not sufficient under such circumstance.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

First Appeal No. 155 of 2017

Decided On: 26.06.2019

Girdhar Brijmohan Maru Vs. Vimal Lalchand Mutha and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vibha Kankanwadi, J.

Citation:  MANU/MH/1607/2019.

Print Page

Wednesday, 24 September 2025

Supreme Court: Under which circumstances , Motor accident claim tribunal can admit permanent disability certificate without examining issuing doctor?

We  consider it appropriate to issue the following  directions:

(iv) As far as the aspect of the issuance of

certificate on disability of victims is concerned,

it is reiterated that the guidelines laid down by

this Court in Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and Anr.,

(2011) 1 SCC 343 mandatorily must be followed by the

MACTs, in respect of loss of income due to

injury/disablement. The District Medical Board is

also directed to follow the guidelines issued by the

Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment,

Government of India vide Gazette Notification S. No.

61, dated 05.01.2018, for issuance of disability

Certificate in order to bring Pan India uniformity.

The consequence is that the MACT would ascertain

that permanent disability certificate issued by the

District Medical Board or body authorized by it is

in accordance with the Gazette Notification alone.

Once the certificate is issued in this manner, the

same can be marked for purposes of being taken into

consideration as evidence without the necessity of

summoning the concerned witness to give formal proof

of the documents unless there is some reason for

suspicion on the document;

S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A

 RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

Writ Petition(s)(Civil) No(s). 534/2020

BAJAJ ALLIANZ GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY PRIVATE LTD. Vs UNION OF INDIA & ORS. 

(IA No. 52588/2020 - EX-PARTE AD-INTERIM RELIEF)

Date : 16-11-2021 The matter was called on for hearing today.

CORAM :

 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KISHAN KAUL

 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.M. SUNDRESH

Print Page

Sunday, 7 September 2025

Supreme Court: How to appreciate evidence of income tax or sales tax return while assessing compensation in motor accident claim petition?

 As far as the income is concerned, we agree with the High Court that the Tribunal had entered into mere surmises and conjectures to decline adoption of the income as per the income tax returns. In this context, we have to notice that the registration of the firm of the claimant took place on 06.03.2006 and the income tax returns produced are also for the assessment years 2005-2006 and 2006-2007 relatable to the financial years 2004-2005 and 2005-2006 which are prior to the accident which occurred on 09.04.2007. It cannot be said that the claimant apprehended an accident and got registration of a firm and filed his income tax returns two years prior to the accident. Further, the claimant had also produced sales tax returns which was also rejected by the Tribunal on the ground that there was no taxable profits in the said year. Insofar as the levy of sales tax is concerned, the levy is on the sales and not on the profits. The finding of the Tribunal also is that in the first year, there was no tax payable and hence there was no profits or income. The exemption from tax is only because the purchase and sales did not exceed the taxable value. The sale proceeds being not within the taxable limit is not an indication of the profit accrued, or the income received from the business which is reflected in the income tax returns. On the above reasoning, we have to accept the income tax returns for the financial year 2007-2008 in which the total gross income is seen as Rs. 1,96,000/- out of which the tax of Rs. 4,641/- has to be deducted. The income, hence, has to be assessed at Rs. 1,91,000/-.  {Para 8

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 12098-12099 of 2024

Anoop Maheshwari Vs. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

K. Vinod Chandran and N.V. Anjaria, JJ.

Author: K. Vinod Chandran, J.

Citation: 2025 INSC 1076, MANU/SC/1233/2025

Decided On: 04.09.2025.

Read full judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Supreme Court: Medical board's certificate can be accepted in motor accident claim petition even without a witness being examined

 Insofar as the disability is concerned, we have no doubt that the medical board's certificate can be accepted, even without a witness being examined. {Para 7}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 12098-12099 of 2024

Anoop Maheshwari Vs. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

K. Vinod Chandran and N.V. Anjaria, JJ.

Author: K. Vinod Chandran, J.

Citation: 2025 INSC 1076, MANU/SC/1233/2025

Decided On: 04.09.2025.

Print Page

Saturday, 30 August 2025

Himachal Pradesh HC: Claimant of Motor accident must examine Doctor to prove permanent disability certificate

The Tribunal should also act with caution, if it proposed to accept the expert evidence of doctors who did not treat the injured but who give "ready to use' disability certificates, without proper medical assessment. There are several instances of unscrupulous doctors who without treating the injured, readily giving liberal disability certificates to help the claimants. But where the disability certificates are given by duly constituted Medical Boards, they may be accepted subject to evidence regarding the genuineness of such certificates. The Tribunal may invariably make it a point to require the evidence of the Doctor who treated the injured or who assessed the permanent disability. Mere production of a disability certificate or Discharge Certificate will not be proof of the extent of disability stated therein unless the Doctor who treated the claimant or who medically examined and assessed the extent of disability of claimant, is tendered for cross-examination with reference to the certificate. If the Tribunal is not satisfied with the medical evidence produced by the claimant, it can constitute a Medical Board (from a panel maintained by it in consultation with reputed local Hospitals/Medical Colleges) and refer the claimant to such Medical Board for assessment of the disability. {Para 12}

10. Thus, it is obvious that mere production of a disability certificate is no proof of the extent of disability till the Doctor who issued the certificate or treated the patient is tendered for cross examination in Court. The Apex Court also held that the same injury can lead to different loss of earning capacity and summarized the principles in the following terms:


Fourthly, in cases where the certificates are not contested by the Respondents, they may be marked by consent, thereby dispensing with the oral evidence. These small measures as also any other suitable steps taken to ensure the availability of expert evidence, will ensure assessment of just compensation and will go a long way in demonstrating that Courts/Tribunals show concern for litigants and witnesses.


13. Consequently, the award is set-aside and the matter is remanded to the learned Tribunal. The learned Tribunal shall decide the application filed by the Insurance Company under Section 170 of the Act at the first instance. Thereafter, it shall give only one opportunity to the claimant to produce the Doctor since in this case the claimant had already taken a number of opportunities and had also taken dasti summons to produce the doctor. No application for examination of the doctor on commission shall be entertained and it shall be the responsibility of the claimant to serve and produce the doctor who issued the disability certificate. Only one opportunity in this behalf shall be given and in case the claimant fails to produce the doctor, the evidence of the claimant shall be closed. In case the doctor is examined, an opportunity to rebut the evidence shall be given to the Respondents and to the Insurance Company if it is permitted to contest the claim on all grounds.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA

CMPMO No. 227 of 2009

Decided On: 09.03.2011

Oriental Insurance Company Vs. Parveen and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Deepak Gupta, J.

Citation: MANU/HP/0662/2011,2012 ACC 2 3192011 SCC ONLINE HP 7432011 ACJ 2692.

Print Page

Wednesday, 27 August 2025

J & K HC: Doctor who is not Neurologist can not give opinion if permanent disability of claimant relates to Neuro problem.

 From the above, it is clear that the disability certificate EXTP-RK is based upon the certificate dated 15.04.2014 issued by the Standing Medical Board which, in turn, has been issued on the basis of opinions of three Doctors from the fields of Psychiatry, Neuro-Surgery and Neurology. The witness Dr. Raj Kumar Bhagat examined by the claimant before the Tribunal has stated that he is only a consultant Surgeon and not a Neuro expert/Surgeon. He has also stated that the other two Members of the Medical Board are Physician Specialists and there was no Neuro expert/surgeon to assess the disability of the claimant. The said witness has gone on to state that the certificate of disability of the claimant is with respect to Neuro problems, as such, he cannot comment upon the Neuro related problem or disability. He has confirmed the fact that he has never examined the claimant. {Para 11}


12. It is an admitted fact that the disability of the claimant relates to Neuro problem. It is also an admitted case that Dr. Raj Kumar Bhagat, who was examined as a witness by the claimant, has neither treated, nor examined the claimant and he is not even associated with the field of Neurology. The question that arises for determination is, as to whether, on the basis of the statement made by a Doctor, who has neither examined the claimant, nor he is an expert in the relevant field, it can be stated that the claimant has suffered a particular type of disability simply on the basis of a certificate issued by the Medical Board.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT JAMMU

Mac App. Nos. 96/2022 and 128/2022

Decided On: 11.05.2023

National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Subash Chander and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sanjay Dhar, J.

Citation: MANU/JK/0412/2023.

Print Page