Showing posts with label premises. Show all posts
Showing posts with label premises. Show all posts

Saturday, 14 December 2019

Which is material date for ascertaining whether suit property is Premises for the purpose of Maharashtra rent control Act?

 Which is the material date for ascertaining, whether the suit property is 'Premises' for the purpose of Section 6 of the Bombay Rent Control Act, i.e. whether the date of letting or the date on which right conferred by the said Act is sought to be exercised, was the question before the Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in the case of Nalanikant Ramadas Gujjar v. Tulasibai (Dead) by Lrs. And Others MANU/SC/0111/1997 : AIR 1997 SC 404.

In the case of Mst. Subhadra v. Narsaji Chenaji Marwadi MANU/SC/0287/1961 : AIR 1966 Supreme Court 806, it was held that material date for ascertaining whether the plot is 'Premises' for the purpose of Section 6 is the date of letting and not the date on which application for fixation of standard rent was made by the tenant or the landlord.

However, in the case of Vasudev Dhanjibhai Modi v. Rajabhai Abdul Rehman and Ors. MANU/SC/0531/1970 : AIR 1970 SC 1475, the Apex Court held that, 'whether the provisions of Bombay Rent Control Act shall be applicable or not, the crucial date for ascertaining the nature of the use of the land in question shall be the date when the rights under the aforesaid Act are to be exercised.'

The Constitution Bench has agreed with the views expressed in the case of Vasudev Modi (Supra) and therefore, material date for ascertaining whether suit property is 'Premises' is the date on which right conferred by the Act is sought to be exercised.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Second Appeal No. 638 of 2014

Decided On: 03.05.2019

 Narendra Harilal Jethwa  Vs.  Bholadasji Mandir 
Print Page

Wednesday, 4 December 2019

Under which law eviction suit is to be filed if open plot was let out on which saw mill was constructed?

It is pertinent to note that the definition of expression 'premises' given in the Act clearly indicates that the Act is not applicable to open lands and it applies to the buildings and structures and parts thereof used as separate premises for residence, education, business, trade or storage. However, the Rent Control Order applied to open lands also but by virtue of provisions of Section 58 of the Act, the said Rent Control Order has been repealed and by virtue of the provisions of Section 46 of the Act, the Rent Control Order is applicable only to the suits or proceedings pending on the date of commencement of the Act. Admittedly, on the date of commencement of the Act, no suit or proceeding for eviction of the defendant from the suit premises was pending and, therefore, in my opinion, it is the Transfer of Property Act which would govern the field and would be applicable to the matter in question and as such, the notice to quit issued by the plaintiffs to the defendant under Section 106 of Transfer of Property Act determining his tenancy without obtaining prior permission of the Rent Controller cannot be said to be illegal or invalid and, therefore, in my opinion, the learned trial Judge has rightly held so. I, therefore, find no substance in the contentions canvassed by the learned Counsel for the applicant in this regard.
Bombay High Court
Gangdas S/O Moujibhai Patel vs Harshvardhan S/O Balkrushna ... on 14 October, 2002
Equivalent citations: 2003 (4) BomCR 712, 2003 (1) MhLj 203

Print Page

Wednesday, 30 October 2019

Whether lessee can seek protection of Maharashtra rent control Act if construction was to be removed after expiry of lease period?

 On the date of expiry of the lease period, i.e. on 31st December, 2003, the Rent Control Legislations were not in force as the same was repealed by provisions of Section 58(1)(b) of Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 with effect from 31st March, 2000. In the given set of facts, the learned Judge has held thus;

"It is not in dispute that the leases in respect of open land are not governed by the provisions of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act Hence, the only remedy available was to file a suit invoking the ordinary jurisdiction of a Civil Court for eviction of tenant and for possession under the general law of the Transfer of Property Act, and neither the provisions of the Rent Control Legislations, nor the provisions of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act were applicable, as the lease in question was for the open land."

19. Thus, taking into consideration facts of the case and the law laid down by the Apex Court as well as by this Court in aforesaid two cases and for the reasons stated here-in-above, suit property was not "Premises" within the meaning of Section 7(9) of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 and, therefore, suit for eviction filed under the general law of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 was maintainable and as such, provisions of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act were not applicable as the lease in question was for open plot. Questions are answered accordingly.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Second Appeal No. 638 of 2014

Decided On: 03.05.2019

Narendra Harilal Jethwa Vs. Bholadasji Mandir and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Sandeep K. Shinde, J.

Citation: AIR 2019(NOC) 648 Bom
Print Page