Showing posts with label private body. Show all posts
Showing posts with label private body. Show all posts

Wednesday, 20 April 2016

Whether private body is bound to follow principle of natural justice while deciding legal rights of its members?

In view of the above, the submission that Respondent No. 1/plaintiff, after trial, may get compensation/damages as claimed in the Suit is unacceptable basically at the instance of the Appellant as the abrupt action and its effect and its consequences are far reaching not only as it affects only Respondent No. 1/plaintiff, but also Gymkhana which nominated him apart from Appellant's own reputation itself. It is always legitimate acceptance of every member and basically the member of this type, that the MC though have a power, in view of the rule, still required to follow and/or the basic principle of natural justice, fair play and equity at every stage of the proceedings. The formality of completion of show cause notice itself was not sufficient. The issue even if raised, in my view, need to be tackled to avoid unnecessary publicity and/or affects the name and fame of everybody concern, specially when it is the requirement of the time that if certain issues are raised and/or pointed out, has to be tackled by inbuilt procedures, by giving opportunity to all concerned. Such abrupt punishment as sought in the present case, is not the solution and specially it is not permissible mode to decide the issue. Every body needs to follow the procedure, whether private body and/or public body, when it comes to deciding and/or taking away the legal rights and the obligations of any member/person/representatives. 
Equivalent Citation: 2014(1)BomCR687, 2014(2)MhLj726,2015(7) ALLMR363
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Appeal From Order (Stamp) No. 25497 of 2013 with CAAST/25580/2013
Decided On: 21.09.2013
Appellants: Mumbai Cricket Association
Vs.
Respondent: Mr. Ratnakar Shivram Shetty and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Print Page