Showing posts with label private place. Show all posts
Showing posts with label private place. Show all posts

Thursday, 28 April 2016

When private place shall be treated as public place for purpose of grant of compensation under motor vehicle Act?


   As far as the provisions under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988

are concerned, we are of the view that the statute is framed with the

anxiety and the purpose to compensate the victims of accidents which

may occur in different circumstances.           According to us, while

considering the meaning of the term public place, a literal interpretation



will lead to anomalous results and will defeat the purpose.             A

purposive interpretation thus will have to be adopted. It is a matter of

common knowledge that in view of the increased spheres of activities

in daily life of people, the necessity to hire goods vehicles either to

transport household articles or the articles for use, merchandise, sand,

cement etc. as well as agricultural crops arise of and on. The purpose

of a goods vehicle will be to transport various items of goods. If the

words "public place" are interpreted in such a manner that the place

where accident occurred should be one where the place itself is

dedicated for the use of the public, it will go against the purpose of the

provision. The definition clause under Section 2(34) does not go to

that extent. In our view the decision of the Division Bench in United

India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Lakshmi (1997(1) KLT 449),

which was relied upon in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pierce

Leslie India Ltd. And others (2000(1) KLT 792) clearly went to the

extent of holding that a place will be a public place though it is a

private property when it is shown that the public are in the habit of


resorting to it and no one is prevented therefrom so resorting to it.

      28.   The idea given by the dictum laid down therein will

promote the object of the statute and if we adopt a narrow

interpretation it will defeat the intent and purport of the statute also.

According to us the Division Bench in United India Insurance Co.

Ltd. v. Pierce Leslie India Ltd. And others (2000(1) KLT 792 has

expressed in clear terms that the private premises or houses also could

be termed as a public place, where it is shown that public are in the

habit of resorting to it. It could not be taken that the travel of goods

vehicles can only be through the national highways or PWD roads or

such other public roads. Herein also, going by the evidence the vehicle

was actually heavily loaded with bundles of paddy crops . Evidently

after it was loaded from the paddy fields it was being taken through

public way which was situated nearby going by the mahazar, for

unloading in the courtyard, made ready for stocking it. The vehicle had

access to the place as held in Rajan's case ( supra) which is sufficient.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

                              PRESENT:

         THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE T.R.RAMACHANDRAN NAIR
                                 &
          THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K.P.JYOTHINDRANATH

       FRIDAY, THE 12TH DAY OF JUNE 2015.

                     MACA.No. 1400 of 2008 ( )
                   

            PARUKUTTY, W/O. LATE SASIDHARAN NAIR,
       
                      Vs
           K.P.JOSEPH, S/O. PAILAN,
       KATTILAPPEDIKA HOUSE, MATTATHUR.

        Citation;2016(2)ALLMR(JOURNAL)90
Print Page

Sunday, 20 March 2016

Whether any obscene act in private place causing no annoyance of others constitutes offence punishable U/S 294 of I.P.C. ?

 Considering the challenge in the instant petition,
short question that arises for consideration is,
“ Whether any obscene act in a private place causing no
annoyance of others constitutes an offence punishable
under section 294 of I.P.C. ? ”

10. Before adverting to this aspect on merits, it would
be useful to reproduce the provisions of section 294 of I.P.C.
for ready reference. This section reads as under:-
“ 294. Obscene acts and songs - Whoever, to the
annoyance of others-
(a) does any obscene act in any public place, or
(b) sings, recites or utters any obscene song, ballad or
words, in or near any public place,
shall be punished with imprisonment of either
description for a term which may extend to three
months, or with fine, or with both.”
11. From the perusal of the above penal provision
which is invoked against petitioners / accused persons, it is
seen that any obscene act for constituting offence punishable
under section 294 of I.P.C. needs to be done in any public
place and the same is also required to cause an annoyance to
others. Similarly, if any person recites or utters obscene song,
ballad or words, in or near any public place, thereby causing
annoyance to others, then he can be said to have committed

an offence punishable under section 294 of I.P.C. Keeping in
mind these ingredients of section 294 of I.P.C., let us examine
whether averments made by informant prima facie fulfills
requirement of the offence punishable under section 204 of
I.P.C.
12. The main ingredient of section 294 of I.P.C. is
commission of an obscene act at a public place. The Black's
Law Dictionary, Eight Edition defines public place as under:-
“public place – Any location that the local, state or
national government maintains for the use of the public,
such as a highway, part, or public building. ”
13. Section 294 of I.P.C. is meant for punishing persons
indulging in obscene act in any public place causing
annoyance to others. As such, the places where such obscene
act is committed needs to be a public place and meant for use
of public at large. Public must have free access to such place
so as to call it a public place. The place where public have no
right rather a lawful right to enter into, cannot be said to be a
public place for invoking the penal provisions of section 294 of
I.P.C. for calling a place as a public place. It must be shown

that public at large has a right to have free ingress to such
place. Viewed from this angle, the flat / apartment in building
owned by some private person meant for private use of such
owner cannot be said to be a public place. It is not the case
of respondents that any member of the public has free access
to the flat bearing Flat No.C-201 located in Evershine Cosmic,
Kureshi Compound, Andheri (W), Mumbai. For resorting to the
penal provision of section 294 of I.P.C., the prosecution is
obliged to make out that the obscene act were performed at a
public place or singing, recitals, or utterances of any obscene
song, ballad or words were done in any public place.
14. Careful perusal of the F.I.R. lodged by informant
Mr.Jagjit Girmile and that too after conducting raid by police
along with panch witnesses does not show that the Flat No.C-
201, Evershine Cosmic, Kureshi Compound, Andheri (W),
Mumbai where the offence is alleged to have taken place is a
public place, wherein any member of the public had free and
lawful right to enter into. The F.I.R. in question was lodged on
the basis of prior intimation given by the informant Jagjit
Girmile to police and after conducting raid in presence of two
panch witnesses by police squad. Naturally, the F.I.R. which is

lodged subsequent to the raid is reflecting the entire episode.
The F.I.R. in question vividly describes each and every
particulars of the event right from the receipt of information,
preparation for raid and post raid events allegedly occurred in
Flat No.C-201 Evershine Cosmic, Kureshi Compound, Andheri
(W), Mumbai witnessed by the raiding police party. There is
no whisper in the F.I.R. that sound of music was being emitted
out from the flat in question and that too, to the annoyance of
the neighbourers and others. Rather, perusal of the F.I.R.
reveals that when the raiding party rang the door bell and
when members of the raiding party entered inside the flat,
they heard sound of music coming from the last room of the
flat. The F.I.R. does not disclose that sound of music coming
from the flat was annoying others. Similarly, the F.I.R. lodged
after the raid does not indicate that the activities which were
allegedly happening inside the flat were causing annoyance to
neighbourers or others. As such, even if the averments and
allegations made in the F.I.R. are accepted as it is, then also, it
cannot be said that the material contained in the F.I.R.
discloses any conginable offence, even prima facie. Obscene
act done in a private place or viewed in privacy is not covered
by the provisions of section 294 of I.P.C.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.127 OF 2016
Amardeep Singh Chudha,

V/s.
The State of Maharashtra

CORAM : NARESH H. PATIL AND
A.M. BADAR, JJ.
 DATED : 10TH MARCH, 2016
Citation:2016 ALLMR(CRI)2195

Print Page