Showing posts with label probation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label probation. Show all posts

Thursday, 10 May 2018

When Judge on probation can be discharged from service ?

 In so far as the judgments relied upon on behalf of the Petitioner
are concerned, the facts involved in the said cases can be said to have common
thread inasmuch as in all the cases either an explanation was called for or
enquiry was conducted and a report was submitted against the probationer.
The facts of the said cases were such that having regard to the allegations
which were made against the probationers in each of the said cases and having
regard to the fact that an enquiry report was on record, the discharge of the
probationers in the said cases was found to be as and by way of punishment as
being in violation of the principles of natural justice.  In fact in one of the cases
i.e. Samsher Singh's case, the Rules provided that the adverse material shall be
placed before the probationer. It is in the facts of the said cases that the
allegations of misconduct in the said cases were held not the motive but the
foundation for discharge or termination of the probationer. Such is not the case
in the instant matter, as in the instant case apart from the fact that there is no
preliminary enquiry or vigilance enquiry into any misconduct in fact even no

explanation was called for from the Petitioner and it is on the basis of the
overall assessment of the material on record that the decision was arrived at by
the Probation Committee to discharge the Petitioner from service.  
30 At the cost of repetition it would have to be said that the Apex
Court has in terms held that having regard to the allegation or suspicion of
misconduct that the master/employer may have against the probationer, the
employer may not choose to hold an enquiry to discharge the probationer
whom the employer is not desirous of keeping. (See Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd.
v/s. Gujarat Steel Tubes Mazdoor Sabha).
It is also trite that the enquiry conducted to go into the suitability
of a probationer cannot attract the provisions of Article 311 of the Constitution
of India.   Hence even assuming that the tenor of the letters of the learned
Principal   District   Judge   would   amount   to   casting   aspersions   or   suspicion
against the Petitioner, the administration was entitled to take a decision to
discharge the Petitioner without choosing to go into the allegations.  Since the
Petitioner was not found to be  suitable  for  continuation  by the  Probation
Committee, the contention of the learned counsel for the Petitioner founded on
the basis of the letters of the learned Principal District Judge that the Petitioner
is   found   to   be   undesirable   and   therefore   amounts   to   a   stigma   cannot   be
accepted. We therefore conclude that the order passed against the Petitioner is

a simple order of discharge, on being found not suitable for continuation, and
is therefore not stigmatic.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.2470 OF 2014 

Mr. Girish Chandrakant Gosavi  Vs  The Chief Secretary


CORAM : R. M. SAVANT & 
SARANG V. KOTWAL,  JJ.

Pronounced on :­ 03rd May 2018
Citation: 2018(6) MHLJ 568

Print Page

Tuesday, 28 March 2017

Principles to be followed by court while releasing accused on probation?

 We have referred to the aforesaid authority to stress the
point that the Court before exercising the power under Section
4 of the PO Act has to keep in view the nature of offence and
the conditions incorporated under Section 4 of the PO Act. Be
it stated in Dalbir Singh vs. State of Haryana and others
AIR 2000 SC 1677
it has been held that Parliament has made it clear that only if
the Court forms the opinion that it is expedient to release the
convict on probation for the good conduct regard being had to
the circumstances of the case and one of the circumstances
which cannot be sidelined in forming the said opinion is “the
nature of the offence”. The Court has further opined that
though the discretion as been vested in the court to decide
when and how the court should form such opinion, yet the
provision itself provides sufficient indication that releasing the
convicted person on probation of good conduct must appear to
the Court to be expedient. 
10. It was then held that the court must construe
the said word in keeping with the context and object
of the provision in its widest amplitude. Here the
word “expedient” is used in Section 4 of the PO Act
in the context of casting a duty on the court to take
into account “the circumstances of the case including
the nature of the offence…”. This means Section
4 can be resorted to when the court considers the
circumstances of the case, particularly the nature of
the offence, and the court forms its opinion that it is
suitable and appropriate for accomplishing a specified
object that the offender can be released on probation
of good conduct.”
We have also opined that the court has to be guided by
the provisions of the PO Act and the precedents of this Court.
Regard being had to the facts and circumstances in entirety,
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1218 OF 2016
(Arising out of S.L.P. (Crl) No. 6104 of 2014)
Mohd. Hashim 
 V
State of UP & Ors. 
Dated:November 28, 2016.
Citation:(2017) 2 SCC198
Print Page