Showing posts with label pronote. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pronote. Show all posts

Sunday, 1 February 2015

How to appreciate evidence in case of suit based on promissory note?



It is undisputed, rather admitted that the plaintiff-
respondent is a money lender. Naturally he would be well aware
how to write-fill in the pronote and receipt and at which place the
adhesive stamps are to be affixed. The perusal of Ex.P-2 and Ex.P-
3 shows that the stamps have been affixed at an unnatural place. It
shows that the same were not affixed at the time when Gurpal
Singh allegedly signed it. Moreover, no date or signatures of
Gurpal Singh are thereon the said stamps. The other point which
shows the falsity of the case of the respondent-plaintiff is that if
infact Gurpal Singh appellant had received an amount of Rs.5000/-
and he did sign in English script why the receipt of amount was not
got recorded from him in his handwriting. Then most suspicious
circumstance is that why the witnesses of alleged pronote and
receipt did write in their own handwriting that Rs.25,000/- was
received in their presence. It shows that these persons have signed
the document later on at the behest of the plaintiff-respondent.
They too have committed forgery. While committing a wrong
conscience of men becomes the best and the worst evidence against
him. He trembles. Moreover, there is a cutting in the date 28.6.85
written by Parmod Kumar. There is over writing in digit ‘6’ and
digit ‘2’ and to make the matter clear the plaintiff attempted to add-
Behari in the letter ‘Panch’ which has been made ‘Panchi’. No
explanation has been given by the plaintiff-respondent for their
over-writings and forgeries. Even none of these made up witnesses
were produced in witness box by the plaintiff-respondent. Had
they appeared they could have been cross examined. So, until and
unless, these persons were not examined by him and they were
given up, neither due execution of the pronote and receipt can be
said to have been proved nor the passing of consideration can be
said to have taken place.”
The plaintiff has not pleaded the advancement of loan of
Rs.5,250/- vide cheque Ex.P1 dated 05.05.1982 in the plaint, it was so
stated in the rejoinder only. A perusal of the pronote (Ex.P2) and the
receipt (Ex.P3) shows that signatures of Gurpal Singh, the defendant
are not on the stamps affixed. Though, there is no attesting witness on

the pronote part of the document but in respect of receipt part, Parmod
Kumar Chuchra and Krishan Lal son of Daulat Ram are the two
attesting witnesses. There is date underneath the signatures of Parmod
Kumar Chuchra as well as over-writing whereas there is no date
underneath the signatures of Gurpal Singh, the defendant.
The
amount of Rs.25,000/- mentioned in the endorsement signed by
Krishan Lal has also overwriting. The stamp on the pronote part had
the words written 12500/- as half of the amount of pronote. The
stamps have been cancelled on the basis of writings which are in the
hand of the person who has filled up the receipt and pronote. They are
not in the hands of Gurpal Singh. There is no date mentioned under
the signatures of the defendant who signed in English, whereas the
date and the amount mentioned by the attesting witnesses. It is an
unusual mode of execution of pronote. The manner of execution of
pronote creates enough doubt in respect of execution of pronote and
receipt by the defendant. It only confirms the finding recorded that the
signatures of the defendant were obtained on blank papers and has
been used for preparation of pronote and receipt.
The findings recorded by the learned first Appellate
Court, that execution of the pronote (Ex.P2) and the receipt (Ex.P3)
are not proved to be executed on the date and time purported and has
been prepared on an already signed document, is based upon proper
appreciation of evidence. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
RSA No.1429 of 1997 (O&M)
Date of decision:10.10.2014

Krishan Kumar  Vs Gurpal Singh

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HEMANT GUPTA
Citation;AIR2015(NOC)2 P&H
Print Page