Showing posts with label proprietor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label proprietor. Show all posts

Monday, 20 May 2024

Bombay HC: The revisional Court has power to award costs in appropriate case.

At this juncture, it will be relevant to note that the trial Court has awarded compensation of Rs. 30,000/- only, as against the cheque of Rs. 1,00,000/- which by any standard cannot be said to be proper determination of compensation, however, it cannot be enhanced for want of proper challenge at the instance of the complainant. However, considering the fact that the complainant was dragged in litigation right from the year 1996 till this date, i.e. for ten years, in my considered view, complainant/respondent No. 1 would be entitled to costs from the applicant-accused, quantified in the sum of Rs. 25,000/

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Crl. Revn. Appln. No. 119 of 2002

Decided On: 15.10.2007

Natesha Securities Vs. Vinayak Waman Mokashi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V.C. Daga, J.

Citation: 2008 Cri L J 1115 (Bom), MANU/MH/1320/2007.

Print Page

Sunday, 23 February 2020

Whether proprietary firm can file complaint for dishonour of cheque through it prioprietor?

 The proprietary concern, however, is an unincorporated business entity, if it were an entity at all. Its registration, if any, is for fulfilling other statutory purposes, such as licensing by a civic body or taxing authority. Though it is usually called "the sole-proprietary concern", the expression "sole" is tautological--saying the same thing twice. There can be no more than one proprietor, after all. In this statutory backdrop, let us examine the trial Court's findings on this point: Who is the complainant?

(b) Who is the Complainant?

35. The trial Court takes note of P.W. No. 2's evidence. He is the official from the payee bank, that is the complainant's banker. The witness has deposed that BC Doshi is the proprietor; he produced a copy of account opening form, too. Despite that, the trial Court concludes that Doshi has no proper "authorization" to present the complaint "on behalf of the complainant company." To repeat, in relation to a proprietary concern, its Proprietor getting authorisation does not arise. The proprietary concern and the proprietor are but one; there is no dichotomy.

36. Here curiously, perhaps adding to the trial Court's discomfiture, the proprietor has sued in the assumed name; that is, in the proprietary concern's name. As it is not a legal entity, no proceedings could be maintained in its name. It is, actually, the proprietor who should have sued or who is deemed to have sued here. First, this issue has never been raised in the trial Court, so it passed sub silentio. Second, it is a curable defect; therefore, no need to make adjudicatory mountains out of procedural molehills.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Appeal No. 657 of 2018

Decided On: 23.07.2019

Doshi Brothers Vs.  The State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dama Seshadri Naidu, J.

Citation: 2020(1) MHLJ 759
Print Page

Saturday, 27 August 2016

Whether proprietorship firm can be prosecuted if proprietor dies?

 In respect of A3 is concerned, A3 is a proprietary concern. A proprietary concern does not have a separate legal entity apart from its proprietor since the proprietary concern and the proprietor are one and the same person. Thus, proprietary concern is not an independent, legal and juristic entity having legal recognition in the eye of law and it can neither initiate proceedings nor proceedings be initiated against it. In the instant case, A1 has borrowed money and a complaint has been preferred against A1 for failing to repay the money. Since A1 died, A3 shall not be impleaded as  accused and so, the proceeding against A3 is liable to be quashed. In the decision relied by the learned counsel for the petitioner in 2007 (5) SUPREME COURT CASES 103, it has been stated as follows :

  The distinction between partnership firm and a proprietary concern is well known.  It is evident from Order 30 Rule 1 and Order 30 Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure.  The question came up for consideration also before this Court in Ashok Transport Agency Vs. Awadhesh Kumar wherein this Court stated the law in the following terms (SCC pp. 569-70 para 6)
6. A partnership firm differs from a proprietary concern owned by an individual.  A partnership is governed by the provisions of the Partnership Act, 1932.  Though a partnership is not a juristic person but Order 30 Rule 1 CPC enables the partners of a partnership firm to sue or to be sued in the name of the firm.  A proprietary concern is only the business name in which the proprietor of the business carries on the business.  A suit by or against a proprietary concern is by or against the proprietor of the business.  In the event of the death of the proprietor of a proprietary concern, it is the legal representatives of the proprietary concern, who alone can sue or be sued in respect of the dealings of the proprietary business.  The provisions of Rule 10 of Order 30 which make applicable the provisions of Order 30 to a proprietary concern enable the proprietor of a proprietary concern.  The real party who is being sued is the proprietor of the said business.  The said provision does not have the effect of converting the proprietary business into a partnership firm.  The provisions of Rule 4 of Order 30 have no application to such a suit as by virtue or Order 30 Rule 10, the other provisions of Order 30 are applicable to  suit against the proprietor or proprietary business 'in so far as the nature of such case permits.'  This means that only those provisions of Order 30 can be made applicable to proprietary concern which can be so made applicable keeping in view the nature of the case. 

15.  A Constitution Bench of this Court in S.M.S.Parmaceuticals Ltd. V. Neeta Bhalla furthermore categorically stated that the complaint petition must contain the requisite averments to bring about a case within the purview of Section 141 of the Act so as to make some persons other than the company vicariously liable therefor.  

It is a proprietary concern.  On the date of borrowal, it was stated that he borrowed for business purpose.  But the cheque has been issued as an individual capacity.  In such circumstances, I am of the view that the third petitioner is also not an accused because it is not a juristic person for prosecution.  
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
 DATED : 04.02.2016
CORAM :
THE HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE R.MALA
Crl.O.P.No.19324 of 2015 & M.P.No.1 of 2015

  M/s.Lakshmi Metal Works 
     Proprietor K.Rajasekar 
 
Vs.

 State rep. by.
     The Inspector of Police
    Citation: 2016 CRLJ 2730
Print Page

Friday, 21 March 2014

Suit by proprietory concern -misdescription of plaintiff whether can be amended?

The counsel for respondent No. 1 cited J. D. Singh and Ors. v. Calcutta Port Trust, . It was held in this cited case that though a plaint in the name of an unregistered firm is legally non est for all purposes, yet, a plaint or a proceeding instituted in the trade or business name of a sole owner is not similarly deemed to be void for all future purppses. In cases of bona fide error where the mistake has been made not for any ulterior purpose that Court permits a rectification of the name so that the person suing is permitted even at a late stage to show himself as the claimant on record. Thus the case cited by the learned counsel for respondent No. 1 also accepts the proposition that the sole owner cannot file a suit in the trade name. However, the authority enables the rectification of the bona fide mistake.
8. The counsel for revision-petitioner cited Neogi Ghose & Co. v. Sardar Nehalsingh and Anr. . This case approves the proposition of permissibility of rectification. In this regard, the relevant facts were that on the objection being raised about the non-maintainability of suit as it was brought in the name of firm, the plaintiff, who was the sole proprietor of the firm, moved an application for amendment of plaint by inserting certain words before the name of firm, so as to indicate that the person carrying on business under the name and style of firm was the plaintiff. The learned Judge opined that the application should not be dismissed but having regard to the arguments, he expressed his preparedness to make the order directing that the amendment should be allowed upon the terms of payment of costs and holding that the plaintiff would be entitled to claim such relief if the suit had gone on from the time of his being joined as plaintiff.

Bombay High Court

Municipal Council vs K. Ravindra And Company And Ors. on 4 February, 2003

Equivalent citations: 2003 (6) BomCR 287, 2003 (2) MhLj 987, 2003(4)ALLMR672, , 2003(2)MhLj986, 

Print Page