Showing posts with label costs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label costs. Show all posts

Thursday, 1 August 2024

Bombay HC: The Commercial court should award actual costs while deciding commercial suits

The meaning is plain. In an action under the Commercial Courts Act, costs follow the event. The losing party pays. If it is not to pay, i.e., if an order of no costs is to be made, then reasons are required. The conduct of the parties is relevant, including the gravity or frivolity of the claim, and whether or not judicial time is wasted. The earlier cap on compensatory costs is removed. The statutory intent is equally plain: no litigant in the commercial division can ordinarily escape a litigation loss without an accompanying order of costs. The amendment contemplates actual costs and compensatory costs both. {Para 36}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Notice of Motion (L) No. 693 of 2017 in Suit (L) No. 196 of 2017

Decided On: 21.03.2017

Dashrath B. Rathod and Ors. Vs. Fox Star Studios India Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

G.S. Patel, J.

Citation: 2018(1) MHLJ 474, MANU/MH/0490/2017.

Print Page

Monday, 20 May 2024

Bombay HC: The revisional Court has power to award costs in appropriate case.

At this juncture, it will be relevant to note that the trial Court has awarded compensation of Rs. 30,000/- only, as against the cheque of Rs. 1,00,000/- which by any standard cannot be said to be proper determination of compensation, however, it cannot be enhanced for want of proper challenge at the instance of the complainant. However, considering the fact that the complainant was dragged in litigation right from the year 1996 till this date, i.e. for ten years, in my considered view, complainant/respondent No. 1 would be entitled to costs from the applicant-accused, quantified in the sum of Rs. 25,000/

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Crl. Revn. Appln. No. 119 of 2002

Decided On: 15.10.2007

Natesha Securities Vs. Vinayak Waman Mokashi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V.C. Daga, J.

Citation: 2008 Cri L J 1115 (Bom), MANU/MH/1320/2007.

Print Page

Sunday, 19 September 2021

Supreme Court Guidelines for imposition of costs in commercial litigation

Costs:

51. The costs following cause is a principle which is followed in most countries. There seems to be often a hesitancy in our judicial system to impose costs, presuming as if it is a reflection on the counsel. This is not the correct approach. In a tussle for enforcement of rights against a State different principle apply but in commercial matters costs must follow the cause.


53. We may note that the common thread running through all these three cases is the reiteration of salutary principles: (i) costs should ordinarily follow the event; (ii) realistic costs ought to be awarded keeping in view the ever increasing litigation expenses; and (iii) the cost should serve the purpose of curbing frivolous and vexatious litigation.

54. There has to be a proportionality to the costs and if they are unreasonable, the doubt would be resolved in favour of the

paying party. As per Halsbury’s Laws of England, the discretion to award costs must be exercised judicially and in accordance with reason and justice. The following principles have been set out therein:

“In deciding what order (if any) to make about costs, the court

must have regard to all the circumstances, including:

(i) The conduct of all the parties;

(ii) Whether a party has succeeded on part of his case, even if he

has not been wholly successful; and

(iii) Any payment into court or admissible offer to settle made by

a party which is drawn to the court’s attention.

The conduct of the parties includes:

a. Conduct before, as well as during, the proceedings and in

particular the extent to which the parties followed any relevant

pre-action protocol;

b. Whether it was reasonable for a party to raise, pursue or contest

a particular allegation or issue;

c. The manner in which a party has pursued or defended his case

or a particular allegation or issue; and

d. Whether a claimant who has succeeded in his claim, in whole

or in part, exaggerated his claim.”

55. We may add that similar principles are followed in Australia, Hong Kong and Canada largely based on the Common Law principle. In fact in Canada, the Manitoba Law Commission Report analysed the ‘Costs Awards in Civil Litigation’ and referred to six broad goals as under:

a. indemnification – successful litigants ought to at least be

partially indemnified against their legal costs;

b. deterrence – potential litigants should carefully assess the merits

of the claim and should refrain from taking any unnecessary legal

actions;

c. rules should be made decipherable and simple to understand;

d. early settlement of disputes should be encouraged;

e. the costs regime should facilitate access to justice; and

f. there should be flexibility in rules to ensure that justice can be

done.

56. We have set forth the aforesaid so that there is appreciation of the

principles that in carrying on commercial litigation, parties must weigh the commercial interests, which would include the consequences of the matter not receiving favourable consideration by the courts. Mindless appeals should not be the rule. 

57. The best reflection of what costs have been incurred is what the parties have paid towards the counsel fee and out of pocket expenses. 

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NOs.4862-4863 OF 2021

UFLEX LTD. Vs  GOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU & ORS.

Author: SANJAY KISHAN KAUL, J.

Dated: September 17, 2021.

Print Page

Saturday, 28 November 2020

Questions and answers on law part 16

Q. 1:-Whether Tender contract comes under commercial dispute under Commercial Courts Act?

Ans:  Commercial Courts Act
2. Definitions.—(1) In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,—(c) “commercial dispute” means a dispute arising out of—
(vi) construction and infrastructure contracts, including tenders;


Q. 2 :- Whether civil revision is tenable if court fails to award costs while deciding suit?

Print Page

Tuesday, 7 July 2020

Whether provisions of S 35-B of CPC in respect of costs for causing delay are mandatory?

The facts of the case are given in the elaborate order of reference prepared by my learned brother P.C. Jain, J., and I need hot repeat them all over again. The short question, which this Full Bench is called upon to decide is whether the provisions of section 35-B of the Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter referred to as the Code) are mandatory, fend if so, to what extent.

 In accordance with the majority decision it is held that in the event of the party failing to pay the costs on the date next following the date of the order imposing costs, it is mandatory on the Court to disallow the prosecution of the suit or the defence, as the case may be and that no other extraneous consideration would weigh with the Court in exercising its jurisdiction against the delinquent party. However, where the costs are not paid as a result of the circumstances beyond the control of the defaulting party, then the Court will be well within its jurisdiction to exercise its power under Section 148 of the Code in favour of the defaulting party if a strong case is made out for the exercise of such jurisdiction.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

Civil Revision No. 1878 of 1978

Decided On: 03.06.1981

Anand Parkash  Vs.  Bharat Bhushan Rai and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.S. Sandhawalia, C.J., Prem Chand Jain and Mela Ram Sharma, JJ.
Authored By : Mela Ram Sharma, Prem Chand Jain, S.S. Sandhawalia

Citation: AIR 1981 P&H 269
Print Page

Saturday, 14 September 2019

Whether Civil court can execute order passed in writ petition?

In my opinion, the present execution proceedings are misconceived and have been filed on concealment of facts, and are accordingly liable to be dismissed for the following reasons:

"(i) A final judgment in a writ petition is not a decree or order which is capable of execution proceedings under CPC. Such a judgment is enforced by invoking the contempt jurisdiction of this Court.

(ii) Execution proceedings under CPC are with respect to decrees or orders passed in proceedings governed by CPC i.e. suits.

(iii) Final judgments of writ petitions, if not complied with, cannot be treated as decrees for seeking the execution in execution proceedings by applying CPC. I may note that it is not as if that the present execution proceedings seek execution of costs which are imposed by the Court as per a final judgment, and which costs can be taken as money decree for the purpose of execution. Section 141, CPC is clear that CPC does not apply to writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India."

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Ex. P. No. 85 of 2016

Decided On: 26.05.2016

 Shambhu Nath Das Vs. Director of Education and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Valmiki J. Mehta, J.

Print Page

Sunday, 8 September 2019

Supreme Court: High court should not impose costs on Judge of subordinate court

Having held so, the High Court made certain observations against
the appellant questioning his bona fide and casting aspersions on
his integrity and also accused him of favouring Mr. R.M. Singh.
The High Court also directed on the judicial side that the matter
be referred on the administrative side for an appropriate action.
As far as the remarks are concerned, we are clearly of the view
that all the adverse remarks in the judgment made against
appellant, whereby his integrity has been questioned or whereby
aspersions have been cast on his character, judicial orders or
otherwise are bound to be expunged.
This Court in a number of cases has cautioned that
remarks against judicial officers should normally not be passed in
judgments. We follow a system where the judgment of a Court is
subject to judicial scrutiny by Higher Courts. The judgment may be
right or wrong, but the Higher Courts should not pass scathing
remarks against the presiding officer of the lower courts only
because they do not agree with the point of view of the Trial
Court.

In the present case, the remarks especially those in para 15
cast aspersions on the integrity of the judicial officer. Even if
the High Court felt as strongly as it did that action needed to be
taken, then the proper course was to place the matter before the
Chief Justice on the administrative side with a request that action
be taken against the concerned judicial officer. In this case, the
High Court did that but in addition passed the scathing remarks
which virtually meant that the appellant stood condemned even
before any disciplinary proceedings were initiated against him.
The High Court can definitely say that the order passed shows
total lack of knowledge of law. But when the High Court went
further and virtually castigated the judicial officer as an
unworthy and corrupt person then the High Court, in our view,
over-stepped its boundaries and such remarks need to be expunged.
We, accordingly, expunge all such remarks and direct deletion
of para 15 of the judgment.
We also set aside the order in so far as the imposition of
costs of Rs.10,000/- on the appellant is concerned. Normally,
costs are not imposed on the presiding officer of the Court and
this practice should not be encouraged.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NOs. 6634 of 2019

SURENDRA PRASAD MISHRA Vs  SMT. RAMAWATI & ORS. 
Dated: August 16, 2019.
Print Page

Tuesday, 5 February 2019

Whether a party who has knowingly accepted benefits of order can assail said order later?

During the course of his submissions, Mr. Jafri, learned counsel for the petitioners has admitted that cost of Rs. 10,000/-, subject to which the ex-parte judgment and decree was set aside, was accepted by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners/plaintiffs.
4. The petitioners cannot “blow hot and cold”, “fast and loose” or “approbate and reprobate”. Where the petitioners have knowingly accepted the benefits of an order, they cannot be permitted to assail the same. This rule is applied to do equity. Therefore, in this case where the petitioners have already accepted the cost, they are estopped by their act, conduct and acquiescence to continue the present petition.
In the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi
(Before Vinod Goel, J.)

Mustaqeem  v.  Faiyaz alias Faizab 
C.R.P No. 65/2018
Decided on January 21, 2019
Citation: 2019 SCC OnLine Del 6751
Print Page

Sunday, 20 January 2019

Whether a party will forfeit right to prosecute suit or defence if he fails to pay costs imposed upon him?

A conspectus of the above provisions clearly demonstrates that under the scheme of CPC, a suit cannot be dismissed for non-payment of costs. Non-payment of costs results in forfeiture of the right to further prosecute the suit or defence as the case may be. Award of costs, is an alternative available to the court, instead of dispensing with the cross- examination and closing the evidence of the witness. If the costs levied for seeking an adjournment to cross-examine a witness are not paid, the appropriate course is to close the cross-examination of the witness and prohibit the further prosecution of the suit or the defence, as the case may be by the defaulting party.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 7554-7555 of 2009 

Decided On: 13.11.2009

Manohar Singh Vs.  D.S. Sharma and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.V. Raveendran and G.S. Singhvi, JJ.

Citation: 2010(2) MHLJ 515
Print Page

Sunday, 13 January 2019

Whether court can strike off defence of party if he fails to appear before mediator?

The reading of the above provision makes it very clear that neither Section 89 of Code of Civil Procedure nor Order 10 Rule 1-A nor the Karnataka (Case Flow Management in Sub-ordinate Courts) Rules 2005 nor the Karnataka Code of Civil Procedure (Mediation) Rules 2005 provide for striking of the defence for non-appearance of the parties before the Mediator. Only Sub-rule (2) of Rule 13 of the Karnataka Code of Civil Procedure (Mediation) Rules 2005 contemplates that the Court may impose cost for non-appearance of the parties before the Mediator. Hence, I am of the view that the order passed by the Learned Civil Judge striking off the defence of Defendants 1 to 3 is contrary to law and Rules referred above. If the parties fail to appear before the Mediator, the Court may impose some penalty fixing some other date to appear before the Mediator and accordingly the order passed by the Learned Civil Judge striking off the defence of the Defendants is liable to be set aside.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

W.P. No. 2208/2009 (GM- CPC)

Decided On: 16.04.2010

 Rudraaradya Vs.  Nanjundappa @ Nanjundaswamy and Anr.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B. Manohar, J.

Citation: ILR 2011Kar 221
Print Page

Tuesday, 4 December 2018

Whether court should impose heavy costs if false or misleading affidavit is filed?

 On a consideration of the Report, the High Court took the view that Sciemed had given a false affidavit in this Court to the effect that the work was near completion. In this view of the matter, the High Court dismissed the appeal filed by Sciemed and imposed costs of Rs. 10 lakhs to be deposited with the Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority.

21. At this stage, it is important to mention that Sciemed through its proprietor Shailendra Prasad Singh son of Rameshwar Prasad Singh, had filed an affidavit on or about 10th July, 2008 in the High Court in which it was explained that the statement made in this Court on affidavit was because the deponent was of the view that the installation of the complete system of gas pipeline is one part of the award and installation of liquid oxygen tank is a separate work. It was stated that the affidavit filed in this Court was due to some misconception and was not with a view to mislead this Court. In other words, the deponent sought to justify his affidavit in this Court notwithstanding the Report of the learned advocate. The deponent after giving the above explanation, tendered an unconditional and unqualified apology to the High Court for the statement regarding the near completion of the project.

22. The High Court did not accept the apology given by the proprietor of Sciemed and, therefore, imposed costs of Rs. 10 lakhs on Sciemed.
Giving false evidence by filing false affidavit is an evil which must be effectively curbed with a strong hand. Prosecution should be ordered when it is considered expedient in the interest of justice to punish the delinquent, but there must be a prima facie case of "deliberate falsehood" on a matter of substance and the court should be satisfied that there is a reasonable foundation for the charge.

32. On the material before us and the material considered by the High Court, we are satisfied that the imposition of costs by the High Court was justified. We find no reason to interfere with the impugned judgment and order. The petition is dismissed.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Petition For Special Leave to Appeal (C) No. 29125 of 2008

Decided On: 11.01.2016

 Sciemed Overseas Inc. Vs. BOC India Limited and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Madan B. Lokur and R.K. Agrawal, JJ.

Citation: (2016) 3 SCC 70
Print Page

Wednesday, 15 August 2018

Whether court should impose heavy costs while granting adjournment ?

I consider that looking at the manner in which the defendant had deliberately been dragging the case and seeking adjournment after adjournment on flimsy, untenable grounds and the trial Court had been obliging defendant, it only shows that the trial was being impeded by the defendant at his whims and fancies and he wanted it to be extended to any length of time. I consider that the trial Courts while exercising discretion of giving adjournments must be careful and should not impose paltry costs of Rs. 250/- or Rs. 500/- which seem to be no costs in the present days. The costs imposed by the trial Courts must be realistic costs taking into account the time of the court wasted every time when the case is called and also taking into account the harm which is being caused to the entire judicial system by such kinds of adjournments and the sufferings of the plaintiff. When the costs are realistic, keeping in view the present day value of money then only defendant seeking adjournment may be deterred from seeking such frequent adjournments. Where the costs are so paltry as is reflected in orders such as Rs. 250, Rs. 500/- or Rs. 1,000/-, such costs encourage the party to seek adjournments because the cost of prolonging the case for few months comes out hardly Rs. 200/- p.m. and anybody would happily pay such cost and keep the case prolonging. Thus, while adjournments are given on such grounds which the trial court may consider compelling, such adjournments must be given subject to realistic cost and not paltry and unrealistic cost.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

CM(M) No. 308/2010

Decided On: 12.03.2010

Mahavir Parshad Lamboria Vs.  Joginder Kaur and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.N. Dhingra, J.

Citation: 2010 AIHC  2265 DELHI
Print Page

Friday, 2 March 2018

Supreme court Guidelines for trial court if the accused is not co-operating in the examination of witnesses

If any court finds that the day-to-day examination of witnesses mandated by the legislature cannot be complied with due to the non-cooperation of the Accused or his counsel the court can adopt any of the measures indicated in the Sub-section i.e. remanding the Accused to custody or imposing cost on the party who wants such adjournments (the cost must be commensurate with the loss suffered by the witnesses, including the expenses to attend the court). Another option is, when the Accused is absent and the witness is present to be examined, the court can cancel his bail, if he is on bail (unless an application is made on his behalf seeking permission for his counsel to proceed to examine the witnesses present even in his absence provided the Accused gives an undertaking in writing that he would not dispute his identity as the particular Accused in the case).
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal Nos. 2045-2046 of 2017 (Arising out of Special Leave Petition (Crl.) Nos. 8994-8995 of 2015) 

Decided On: 28.11.2017

Doongar Singh and Ors. Vs. The State of Rajasthan

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.K. Goel and U.U. Lalit, JJ.


Print Page

Saturday, 11 November 2017

Whether amendment of pleading can be rejected on ground of delay or negligence on part of party?

It cannot be disputed that ordinarily all amendments ought to be allowed, which are essential for to determine the real controversy in the suit. The precaution for the Court must be to see that the proposed amendment should not materially alter/vary/annul the substantive relief claimed in the plaint and in other words, it should not be a substitute for the original cause of action on which the original suit has been filed. By means of proposed amendment, a Court is to see whether any prejudice is likely to be caused to the other side which cannot be compensated by means of costs. It is to be borne in mind by the trial Court that no litigant should suffer either on account of mistake committed by a Court of Law on account of technicalities or hyper-technicalities of law. To put it in brief, an amendment sought for by a litigant either as plaintiff or defendant ought to be allowed by the Court to reduce/minimize the litigation between the parties to avoid multiplicity of proceedings. Furthermore, an error or mistake, which if not fraudulent, should not be the ground for rejecting the Application for amendment of pleadings. If the amendment/amendments sought for in the amendment application goes to the very root of the matter or it concerns with the real issues in controversy between the respective parties, the said application/amendment, in the considered opinion of this Court, ought to be allowed, notwithstanding the fact there may be a negligence, omission, on the part of a particular party applying for amendment in regard to the inordinate or long delay that has occurred relating to the proposed amendment. It is no doubt the discretion of the Court before which the application comes for hearing when it deals with an amendment application seeking amendment of plaint. Order VI, Rule 17 of Civil Procedure Code gave wide discretion to permit amendment even by condoning laches or delay, to impose costs and permit amendment for just and proper final decision in the suit. While allowing an amendment application in respect of pleadings, a Court cannot be expected to go into the merits and demerits of the amendment. It must be borne in mind that, the rules of procedure are only handmaid of Justice. A party/parties should not be denied/refused the just relief, because of some inadvertence, mistake or negligence or even the infraction of rules of procedure committed by the parties to the litigation. The substantive justice is to determine the real controversy between the parties finally by a conclusive judgment and order. It may be noted that the relief is based on the same facts previously pleaded. The relief prayed in the suit in substance appears to be based on the title claimed by the plaintiffs and for possession and injunction. The delay to prefer amendment or negligence may be penalized by imposing reasonable cost, but not by the complete or blanket refusal to amend the plaint because the real controversy in the suit is required to be decided finally by the trial Court. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 291 of 2012

Decided On: 04.07.2013

 Kamlesh and Ku. Anita Vs.Kalyan and Atul Vishnu Dharmadhikari

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.P. Bhangale, J.
Citation: 2013(6) ALLMR 537.
Print Page

Saturday, 13 August 2016

What order is to be passed by court if plaintiff is willing to withdraw his suit?

 Next it is to be noted that no act is required to be done by the Court to complete or effectuate a plaintiff's withdrawal of his suit There is no provision for any act to be done in the suit by the Court for making the withdrawal effective or even after the withdrawal it is not even required to pass any order. Withdrawal of a suit is itself its end. A plaintiff withdrawing his suit is liable for such costs as the Court may award; so the Court is empowered to pass an order only in respect of the costs. The liability for costs arises out of the plaintiff's withdrawing his suit; the suit has been withdrawn and consequently he becomes liable. The Court's order awarding costs against him is a consequence of the withdrawal, which means that the withdrawal is already complete and effective The order is not an element of the withdrawal and is not required to complete or effectuate it. In Lakshmanan Chetty v. Muthaya Chetty, (1921) 40 Mad LJ 126. Sadasiva Aiyar, J. pointed out at p. 137 that as regards unconditional withdrawal.
"It is. . . . . wholly at the option of the plaintiff and the Court has nothing to do with it except as regards providing for costs ...
and it is only where he wants some permission that he has to make an application under Clause 2.
In ILR 32 Bom 345 (supra) Sir Lawrence Jenkins, C. J, said at p. 347 that "if a party desires to withdraw from the suit with such liberty, then he must apply to the Court to permit him so to withdraw. If he does not desire to have that liberty, then he can withdraw of his own motion and no order of the Court is necessary".
Allahabad High Court
Smt. Raisa Sultana Begam And Ors. vs Abdul Qadir And Ors. on 20 September, 1965
Equivalent citations: AIR 1966 All 318

Bench: M Desai, S Manchanda
Print Page

Sunday, 29 May 2016

When court should not take hyper technical rigid view which will result in denial of justice to litigant?

 On aforesaid point, both the sides placed
reliance on the case reported as (1986) 2 SCC 424
(Konkan Trading Company v. Suresh Govind Kamat). In
this case the Apex Court has considered provisions of both
Order 23 Rule 1 and Section 148 of the Civil Procedure
Code. The Apex Court has laid down that even if the order
of payment of cost is a condition precedent for filing fresh
suit, the defect, if any, can be cured by depositing in the
Court the cost within reasonable time and the time can be
fixed by the Court before which the second suit is filed.

The Apex Court has observed that there is no warrant for
taking a hyper technical rigid view which may result in
denying to a person access to justice and deprive him of
his legal rights. It is observed that when it is possible to
take a liberal view which promotes the ends of justice,
such liberal view needs to be taken in such matters. In
view of the relevant facts of the present matter which are
already quoted, this Court holds that on this technical
point present appeal cannot be allowed and the suit filed
for relief of partition cannot be treated as not tenable. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
Second Appeal No. 1132 of 2004

 Rajaram Mahadu Dahatonde
Versus
Babu Mahadu Dahatonde,
 CORAM: T.V. NALAWADE, J.
 DATE : 29th OCTOBER 2015
Citation; 2016(2) ALLMR326
Print Page

Sunday, 17 April 2016

Whether court can extend time for deposit of costs beyond thirty days as per S 148 of CPC?

 In terms of Section 148 C.P.C. court has the discretion
to extend the time. The words “not exceeding thirty days in total”
have been inserted by the C.P.C. (Amendment) Act, 1999.
Observing that if the act could not be performed within thirty days
for the reasons beyond the control of the parties, the time beyond
maximum thirty days can be extended under Section 151 C.P.C.,
in Salem Advocates Bar Association, T.N. vs. Union of India
(2005) 6 SCC 344, this Court in para (41) held as under:
“41. The amendment made in Section 148 affects the power of the
court to enlarge time that may have been fixed or granted by the
court for the doing of any act prescribed or allowed by the Code. The
amendment provides that the period shall not exceed 30 days in
total. Before amendment, there was no such restriction of time.
Whether the court has no inherent power to extend the time beyond
30 days is the question. We have no doubt that the upper limit fixed
in Section 148 cannot take away the inherent power of the court to
pass orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice or to prevent
abuse of process of the court. The rigid operation of the section
would lead to absurdity. Section 151 has, therefore, to be allowed to
operate fully. Extension beyond maximum of 30 days, thus, can be
permitted if the act could not be performed within 30 days for
reasons beyond the control of the party. We are not dealing with a
case where time for doing an act has been prescribed under the
provisions of the Limitation Act which cannot be extended either
under Section 148 or Section 151. We are dealing with a case where
the time is fixed or granted by the court for performance of an act
prescribed or allowed by the court.”
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 1856 OF 2016

NASHIK MUNICIPAL CORPORATION  Vs  M/S. R.M. BHANDARI & ANR.

Citation;AIR 2016 SC 1090,(2016) 6 SCC245,2016(6) MHLJ 813
Print Page

Sunday, 14 September 2014

Whether court can impose minimal costs or even waive costs if cheque dishonour case is compounded?


Having regard thereto, we are of the opinion that even when a
case is decided in Lok Adalat, the requirement of following the
guidelines contained in Damodar S. Prabhu (supra) should
normally not be dispensed with.
However, if there is a
special/specific reason to deviate therefrom, the Court is not
remediless as Damodar S. Prabhu (supra) itself has given
discretion to the concerned Court to reduce the costs with regard

to specific facts and circumstances of the case, while recording
reasons in writing about such variance.
Therefore, in those
matters where the case has to be decided/settled in the Lok
Adalat, if the Court finds that it is a result of positive attitude of the
parties, in such appropriate cases, the Court can always reduce
the costs by imposing minimal costs or even waive the same. For
that, it would be for the parties, particularly the accused person, to
make out a plausible case for the waiver/reduction of costs and to
convince the concerned Court about the same. This course of
action, according to us, would strike a balance between the two
competing but equally important interests, namely, achieving the
objectives delineated in Damodar S. Prabhu (supra) on the one
hand and the public interest which is sought to be achieved by
encouraging settlements/resolution of case through Lok Adalats.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 8614 OF 2014
(arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 38519 of 2012)

MADHYA PRADESH STATE LEGAL
SERVICES AUTHORITY  V  PRATEEK JAIN & ANR.

Dated;SEPTEMBER 10, 2014.

A.K. SIKRI, J.
Print Page