A plain reading of Section 92 of the Code indicates that
leave of the court is a precondition
or a condition precedent for
the institution of a suit against a public trust for the reliefs set
out in the said section; unless all the beneficiaries join in
instituting the suit, if such a suit is instituted without leave, it
would not be maintainable a all. Having in mind the objectives
underlying Section 92 and the language thereof, it appears to us
that, as a rule of caution, the court should normally, unless it is
impracticable or inconvenient to do so, give a notice to the
proposed defendants before granting leave under Section 92 to
institute a suit. …”
7. Learned counsel for the appellant urges that in view of
law laid down by this Court, it is imperative that leave must
be granted before the suit is instituted. There is no quarrel
with this proposition and we are not inclined to hold, as the
High Court did, that leave can be presumed to have been
granted. There can be no presumption of this kind in a case
of this nature. We are clearly of the view that in every suit
filed under Section 92, CPC, the grant of leave is necessary
before the suit can be said to be properly instituted.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Civil Appeal No(s). 6067/2010
BHUPINDER SINGH Vs JOGINDER SINGH
Deepak Gupta, J.
Dated:September 18, 2019.