Criminal - Criminal procedure Code - Sections 200 , 202 , 203 , 204 , 482 Recall of summons issued by Magistrate - Validity of - Complaint filed by Respondent 1 against appellant and other respondents alleging cheating and fraud - Summons issued by Magistrate by issuing process under section 204 , Cr. Pc - Challenged - Recall of summons by trial court - Challenged by filing revision petition on ground that Magistrate had no jurisdiction to recall summons issued under section 204 - Allowed by High Court holding that while trial court was justified in taking cognizance of offences punishable under section 420 r/w 120B IPC , it erred in recalling consequential summons issued as court did not have any power to review its own order - Appeal to supreme Court - Appellant challenging order of High Court relying upon ratio of decision in case of K.M. Mathew v. State of Kerala & Anr. wherein held that for recalling an order of issuance of process erroneously, no specific provision of law was required - Validity - Although it is true that if a Magistrate taking cognizance of an offence, issues process without there being any allegation against the accused or any material implicating the accused or in contravention of provision of Sections 200 & 202, the order of the Magistrate may be vitiated - However then the relief to an aggrieved accused is not by invoking Section 203 of the Code as the Criminal Procedure Code does not contemplate a review of an order - Held that in absence of any review power or inherent power with subordinate criminal courts, the remedy lied in invoking Section 482 of Code. - Observation of court in case of Mathew that for recalling an order of issuance of process erroneously , no specific provision of law is required runs counter to scheme of code which does not provide for review and prohibits interference at interlocutory stage - View of court in Mathews ease that no specific provision was required for recalling an erroneous Order held unjustified - Impugned judgment of High Court being unsustainable, set aside.
Adalat Prasad vs Rooplal Jindal & Ors on 25 August, 2004
Bench: N S Hegde, S Sinha, A Mathur
Citation;2004(2)ALD(Cri)855, 2005(1)CGLJ268, 2004(4)CTC608, 113(2004)DLT356(SC), (2005)1GLR546, JT2004(7)SC243, 2004(2)KLJ727, 2004(4)MhLj274, 2004MPLJ1(SC), 2004(4)PLJR124, 2004(7)SCALE137, (2004)7SCC338
Print Page