Showing posts with label recall of order of issue process. Show all posts
Showing posts with label recall of order of issue process. Show all posts

Wednesday, 5 August 2026

No Legal Evidence, No Process: A Session Judge's Compass for Deciding Criminal Revisions Against Orders Issuing Process

 The Core Idea in One Line

An order issuing process cannot survive revision if it rests on no admissible, relevant material connecting the accused to the offence — but a Sessions Judge examining that question in revision must look only at the record that was before the Magistrate, and must never reweigh or reappraise the evidence found there.

What Counts as "Legal Evidence"

"Legal evidence" is admissible material — recognized as such under the Evidence Act — bearing a rational, probative connection to an ingredient of the offence charged. It is not simply anything appearing in the case file. Four elements define it:

Print Page

Monday, 31 March 2014

Leading Supreme Court Judgment : Magistrate can not recall order of issue process


Criminal - Criminal procedure Code - Sections 200 , 202 , 203 , 204 , 482 –Recall of summons issued by Magistrate - Validity of - Complaint filed by Respondent 1 against appellant and other respondents alleging cheating and fraud - Summons issued by Magistrate by issuing process under section 204 , Cr. Pc - Challenged - Recall of summons by trial court - Challenged by filing revision petition on ground that Magistrate had no jurisdiction to recall summons issued under section 204 - Allowed by High Court holding that while trial court was justified in taking cognizance of offences punishable under section 420 r/w 120B IPC , it erred in recalling consequential summons issued as court did not have any power to review its own order - Appeal to supreme Court - Appellant challenging order of High Court relying upon ratio of decision in case of K.M. Mathew v. State of Kerala & Anr. wherein held that for recalling an order of issuance of process erroneously, no specific provision of law was required - Validity - Although it is true that if a Magistrate taking cognizance of an offence, issues process without there being any allegation against the accused or any material implicating the accused or in contravention of provision of Sections 200 & 202, the order of the Magistrate may be vitiated - However then the relief to an aggrieved accused is not by invoking Section 203 of the Code as the Criminal Procedure Code does not contemplate a review of an order - Held that in absence of any review power or inherent power with subordinate criminal courts, the remedy lied in invoking Section 482 of Code. - Observation of court in case of Mathew that for recalling an order of issuance of process erroneously , no specific provision of law is required runs counter to scheme of code which does not provide for review and prohibits interference at interlocutory stage - View of court in Mathew’s ease that no specific provision was required for recalling an erroneous Order held unjustified - Impugned judgment of High Court being unsustainable, set aside.


Supreme Court of India
Adalat Prasad vs Rooplal Jindal & Ors on 25 August, 2004

Bench: N S Hegde, S Sinha, A Mathur
Citation;2004(2)ALD(Cri)855, 2005(1)CGLJ268, 2004(4)CTC608, 113(2004)DLT356(SC), (2005)1GLR546, JT2004(7)SC243, 2004(2)KLJ727, 2004(4)MhLj274, 2004MPLJ1(SC), 2004(4)PLJR124, 2004(7)SCALE137, (2004)7SCC338
Print Page

Whether criminal court can review its own order?

 Having noticed the aforesaid, this Court in Adalat Prasad case (supra) held a contrary view in respect of recalling of erroneous order of issuance of process from the earlier view taken by this Court in K.M. Mathew v. State of Kerala, MANU/SC/0434/1992: (1992) 1 SCC 217 and opined that the scheme of the Code does not provide for review of order of issuance of process and prohibits interference by the accused at the interlocutory stage under Section 203. This Court, after overruling the view expressed by this Court in KM. Mathew case (supra) has stated as under:
It is true that if a Magistrate takes cognizance of an offence, issues process without there being any allegation against the accused or any material implicating the accused or in contravention of provisions of Sections 200 and 202, the order of the Magistrate may be vitiated, but then the relief an aggrieved accused can obtain at that stage is not by invoking Section 203 of the Code because the Code of Criminal Procedure does not contemplate a review of an order. Hence in the absence of any review power or inherent power with the subordinate criminal courts, the remedy lies in invoking Section 482 of the Code,
13. The aforesaid law laid down in Adalat Prasad case (supra) has been followed and reiterated by this Court in its subsequent decisions in Bholu Ram case (supra), Subramanium Sethuraman v. State of Maharashtra, MANU/SC/0770/2004 : (2004) 13 SCC 324; N.K. Sharma v. Abhimanyu,MANU/SC/1075/2005: (2005) 13 SCC 213 and Everest Advertising (P) Ltd. v. State, Govt. of NCT of Delhi MANU/SC/1767/2007: (2007) 5 SCC 54. In our view, the issue that we have raised for our consideration and decision is no more a debatable issue in view of what has been stated by a three judge bench of this Court in the case of Adalat Prasad (supra) and therefore, we are of the considered opinion that the High Court is not justified in rejecting the petition filed by the Appellant under Section 482 of the Code.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Crl.A. No. 250 of 2013 (Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 4984 of 2012)
Decided On: 06.02.2013

Appellants: IRIS Computers Ltd.
Vs.
Respondent: Askari Infotech Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:H.L. Dattu and Ranjan Gogoi, JJ.

2013(3)KCCR1777, 2014(1)RCR(Criminal)468, 2013(3)SCALE207
Print Page

Monday, 20 May 2013

Whether Magistrate can recall order of issue process against accused?

In view of the law laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of Adalat Prasad (supra) it is not open for an accused, even in a summary case, to apply for recall of the process. If at all the accused feels aggrieved by an order of issuance of the process in a summary trial, the remedy open to him is to approach the High Court under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and that of course, is without prejudice to any other remedy which the accused may have under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India. An accused aggrieved by the order of issuance of process by the Magistrate cannot approach the same Magistrate again with the prayer for recalling of the process. The application dated 30th July 1998 made by the present petitioner - accused no.4 before the Magistrate was for recalling of the process was clearly not maintainable in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in Adalat Prasad (supra).

Bombay High Court
Chandrakant B. Garware vs M/S.Jayheet Investments ... on 17 December, 2009
Print Page