Showing posts with label removal of encroachment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label removal of encroachment. Show all posts

Sunday, 26 February 2023

Whether the court can permit demolition of some part of religious places for the purpose of road widening?

 Thus, in the above decision the Court holds that if such places of worship are taken away for the purposes of carrying out the expansion of the road, it would not mean in any manner that a religious structure is being disrespected.

18. In the present case too, this Court is of the view that the larger public interest would outweigh the concerns raised by both the places of worship i.e., the Mandir as also the Masjid. There is no gainsaying that places of worship cannot be encroaching public land and hindering developmental activities meant for the larger segment of the public. In order to make the said pedestrian pathway uniform and so as to not inconvenience the pedestrians on the said busy stretch of the road which also has access to the Delhi Metro station, this Court is of the opinion that the PWD ought to be permitted to make the pedestrian pathway uniform. For the said purpose, if some portion of the Mandir/Masjid is to be broken/demolished, the same would have to be permitted by the Court.

2023/DHC/001358

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

W.P.(C) 16609/2022.

DEVENDRA KUMAR & ORS. Vs  STATE (NCT OF DELHI) & ORS.

CORAM:JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH

Date of Decision: 23rd February, 2023

Print Page

Friday, 25 March 2022

Madras HC: Officers Can't Promote Encroachers By Allotting Alternative Lands In Absence Of Statutory Provision


 Learned Additional Advocate General could not refer to any provision of law, which mandates the State Government to allot a land to the encroachers. However, he prayed that till alternative lands are allotted, the encroachments may not be removed.

 {Para 4}

5. The encroachments are on the water-bodies. The allotment ofalternative lands to the encroachers, would only promote the tendency to encroach on the Government land and the water-bodies. For years, the Officers remained silent spectators and failed to take any action in reference to the encroachments on the water-bodies. Therefore, there is a total failure on the part of the Officers concerned to remove the encroachments on the waterbodies and even on catchment-areas. The encroachment of the water-bodies would lead to shrinkage of the water-bodies, destroying them to the maximum and creating acute water scarcity. At times, in the absence of storage facilities to store the water during rainy season, it causes floods.

6. In view of the above, learned Additional Advocate General could not clarify as to why the Officers are promoting the encroachers by allotting alternative lands else-where. It may be a Government policy or decision. However, in the absence of any statutory provision, it would lead to promoting encroachment of the lands on the water-bodies and the same cannot be endorsed.

THE  CHIEF JUSTICE and D.BHARATHA CHAKRAVARTHY, J

(The Order of the Court was made by The Honourable Chief Justice)

Dated: 23.03.2022

Print Page

Saturday, 18 February 2012

Whether court can grant Injunction to restrain municipality from removing illegal encroachment?

Protection From removal of encroachment, apart from long posssession, such person has to establish some legal right in his favour. Mere act of depositing monthly certain amount as rent cannot clothe respondent with status of lessee or tenant.
 Insistence upon observance of "due procedure" by these respondents is totally unwarranted. Even if all plaint allegations are presumed to be true, the same fall short to make out any case of legal injury in their favour. The application of mind by Appellate court is unsustainable. Appellate court ought to have noticed that an action to be binding on body corporate like petitioner or to operate to the prejudice of general public must be stated and shown to be in accordance with provisions of Municipal Act. The Appellate Court was duty bound to notice this aspect and ought not to have confused possession only as conferring any legal right upon respondents. Resolution of Municipal Council or any of its members or its chief officer cannot make their action binding unless and until it is in accordance with provisions mentioned above. Procuring of some trading licence or no objection from Municipal Council, paying some charges to it towards such occupation of land does not create any legal relationship between Municipal Council and such person. Influential traders or businessmen may try to take undue advantage of their position by getting any orders or resolutions from such bodies and therefore only, legislature has circumscribed those powers by providing for appropriate measures by way of control. It is apparent that Appellate Court has exercised jurisdiction not available to it in the matter by protecting unauthorised and apparently illegal possession of respondents to the prejudice of public at large and has hampered the development work specified by Development Plan. It is further to be noticed that respondents after receipt of notice to remove encroachment from Municipal Council, till today got sufficient time to make alternate arrangements but then as already stated above the wish to prosper at the cost of general public which cannot be tolerated at all.
Bombay High Court
Municipal Council vs Kundanlal Mohanlal Jaiswal And ... on 31 January, 2007
Equivalent citations: 2007 (3) MhLj 155
Author: B Dharmadhikari
Bench: B Dharmadhikari
Print Page