Section 182 of the Contract Act defines an "agent" as a person employed to do any act for another or to represent another in dealings with a third person. The authority of the agent, as Section 186 provides, may be express or implied. Section 187 defines express and implied authorities. An authority is said to be express when it is given by words spoken or written. It is implied when it is to be inferred from the circumstances of the case. Things spoken or written or the ordinary course of dealing may be considered as these circumstances. So far as the extent of the agent's authority is concerned, Section 188 provides that the agent, having an authority to do an act, has authority to do every lawful thing which is necessary in order to do such act. If the agent has done any act on behalf of his principal, without the latter's authority, under Section 196, the latter may elect to ratify or disown such act; if he ratifies the act, the same effects follow as if it had been performed by his authority. Ratification, as provided in section 197, may itself be express or may be implied by the conduct of the person on whose behalf the act is done. The ratifier must, however, have knowledge of the facts of the case, without which, as Section 198 provides, no valid ratification is possible. These provisions give rise to a whole lot of questions, particularly in the light of the facts of our case where the Petitioner's wife is claimed to have acted as his agent so as to make him responsible for her acts, which questions appear to have escaped the arbitrator's attention altogether. Was the Petitioner's wife acting for him in the particular act, namely, addressing of the two subject mails, or was she generally representing him in his dealings with the Respondent or involving the others to whom the emails were copied? Was her authority to do so express or was it to be implied from the circumstances of the case (including words spoken or written by the Petitioner)? Was calling the Respondent a "forger", which may be a criminal act involving an offence under Section 499 of IPC, a matter within or without her authority? If without her authority, did the Petitioner ratify the act? Did he do so expressly or by implication? If he might be said to have ratified it, did he have the full knowledge so as to make the ratification valid? These and other pertinent questions either appear to have escaped the arbitrator's attention altogether or to have been considered by him only in an unacceptably tentative manner, as I shall presently point out.
12. It was nobody's case that the Petitioner's wife had his express authority (i.e. by spoken or written words) to act on his behalf when she wrote the two subject emails. The only circumstance, which the arbitrator appears to have considered in this behalf, is that the Petitioner, despite knowledge of the email of 15 June 2011, did not repudiate his wife's statement or clarify that it was not his opinion. The law does not put the burden of repudiation on the principal, when the agent acts beyond his authority. The law requires a positive act of ratification on his part so as to fasten him with the consequences of that act. Once again, the arbitrator appears to have missed the plot, resulting into a complete miscarriage of justice.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Arbitration Petition No. 167 of 2015
Decided On: 19.05.2020
Jackie Kukubhai Shroff Vs. Ratnam Sudesh Iyer
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.C. Gupte, J.
Citation: MANU/MH/0633/2020,2020(5) MHLJ 524
Print Page