Showing posts with label resignation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label resignation. Show all posts

Sunday, 4 April 2021

Whether School tribunal has jurisdiction to decide a dispute relating to a private school teacher's resignation?

  In view of the aforesaid judgment of the Supreme Court

in the case of Shashi Gaur (supra), in my opinion, there can

be no doubt that once a teacher/employee of a school takes

up a case that she has been illegally removed, this aspect

very much falls within the jurisdiction of the Tribunal. The

mere fact that in determining this issue the Tribunal has

also to consider that whether or not the teacher or employee

has resigned or not cannot mean that Tribunal will have no

jurisdiction because it is only on arriving at a conclusion

that there is no valid resignation, would thereafter the

Tribunal arrive at a decision of illegal removal of a

teacher/employee of a school. Surely, a teacher/employee

who is illegally removed, will naturally approach the

Tribunal as per the ratio of the Supreme Court in the case

of Shashi Gaur (supra), and surely the defence which is laid

out by the school to justify the action of the school would

not mean that the issue will not remain that of removal of

the teacher/employee from the school. In fact, it is reiterated

that it is because of the assertion of the respondent no. 1

that she has been illegally removed from the school, and

which case has been accepted by the Tribunal, that the

impugned judgment has been passed in favour of

respondent no. 1 and against the petitioner.”{Para 4}

22. In fact in the case of Daya Nand (supra) the Court was confronted

with the question of maintainability of an appeal before the Tribunal

where the Petitioner had resigned and even in that context the Court held

that since resignation was one of the modes of cessation of service, it

would be within the purview of the Tribunal under Section 8(3) of the

Act to adjudicate the issue. In a recent judgment in GD Goenka Public School and Ors. vs. Vinod Handa and Ors. 262 (2019) DLT 154, a Coordinate Bench of this Court has taken a similar view and relegated the Petitioner to the remedy of an appeal before the Tribunal, as the challenge was to an order of resignation.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI


 W.P.(C) 6975/2020 and CM Nos.23831/2020 and 23832/2020

SANDHYA BINDAL  Vs  STATE OF NCT OF DELHI 

CORAM:

HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE JYOTI SINGH

Pronounced on: 24.11.2020

Print Page

Sunday, 21 February 2021

Whether the court can permit a municipal councillor to withdraw her resignation only because she was depressed due to a fight with her husband?

 The Commissioner of the Respondent No. 2 Corporation is not

empowered in law to allow the Petitioner to withdraw her resignation only because the

Petitioner was angry and depressed due to a fight with her husband. Even her being an

active social worker, or being at the forefront during the current pandemic to help the

needy would not come to her rescue in light of S. 7 quoted above, dealing with

‘resignation of ofce by councillor’. In view of her seat having fallen vacant

immediately upon receipt of her Letter of Resignation, the fact that the Commissioner

of the Respondent No.2 Corporation did not mention that the Petitioner had

withdrawn her Resignation Letter dated 26th October, 2020, by her subsequent Letter

dated 3rd November, 2020, in his Letter dated 2nd December, 2020, addressed to

Respondent No. 1 – State of Maharashtra and / or to the Respondent No. 3 – State

Election Commission, can by no means be termed as malafde, or vindictive conduct

on his part, since the subsequent withdrawal of her resignation is of no consequence as

her seat stood vacant immediately on 26th October, 2020, i.e. upon receipt of her

Resignation Letter by the Commissioner of the Respondent No. 2 Corporation in view

of Section 7 of the Act. The question therefore of any interference by this Court

under Article-226 of the Constitution of India, as sought by the Petitioner, does not

arise and the above Writ Petition is dismissed with costs.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION NO.53 OF 2021

Farzana Ismail Rangrez (Mirchi) Vs The State of Maharashtra 


CORAM : S.J. KATHAWALLA, & R.I.CHAGLA, JJ.

DATE : 7TH JANUARY, 2021

Print Page

Sunday, 18 October 2015

Whether employee can be relieved from service without paying his dues in case of his resignation?

Having regard to the respective contentions, the question that arises for consideration is: whether the respondent acquired a vested right after acceptance of the voluntary retirement by proceedings dated December 20, 1994? It is seen that the order is a conditional order in that until the dues are paid, the order does not become effective. The respondent himself admitted that the outstanding dues could be adjusted from the amount payable to him. Admittedly, no such adjustment has been made. He , therefore, rightly understood that unless he is relieved of the duties of the post, after the payment of the outstanding dues, the order accepting his voluntary retirement does not become effective.
It is now settled legal position that unless the employee is relieved of the duty, after acceptance of the offer of voluntary retirement or resignation, jural relationship of the employee and the employer does not come to an end. since the order accepting the voluntary retirement was a conditional one, the conditions ought to have been complied with. Before the conditions could be complied with, the appellant withdrew the scheme. consequently, the order accepting voluntary retirement did not become effective. Thereby no vested right has been created in favour of the respondent. The High court, therefore, was not right in holding that the respondent has acquired a vested right and, therefore, the appellant has no right to withdraw the scheme subsequently.
Supreme Court of India
Power Finance Corporation Ltd vs Pramod Kumar Bhatia on 17 March, 1997
Bench: K. Ramaswamy, G.T. Nanavati
Print Page