Showing posts with label s152 cpc. Show all posts
Showing posts with label s152 cpc. Show all posts

Monday, 23 March 2015

Whether failure to give description of suit property by giving boundaries etc. in the plaint is fatal?

 In a decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court reported in (2003)2 SCC 330, Pratibha Singh & another vs. Shanti Devi Prasad & another, it has been held in paragraph 17 as follows :-
“17. When the suit as to immoveable property has been decreed and the property is not definitely identified, the defect in the court record caused by overlooking of provisions contained in Order 7 Rule 3 and Order 20 Rule 3 CPC is capable of being cured. After all a successful plaintiff should not be deprived of the fruits of decree. Resort can be had to Section 152 or Section 47 CPC depending on the facts and circumstances of each case – which of the two provisions would be more appropriate, just and convenient to invoke. Being an inadvertent error, not affecting the merits of the case, it may be corrected u/s 152 CPC by the Court which passed the decree by supplying the omission. Alternatively, the exact description of decreetal property may be ascertained by executing court as a question relating to execution, discharge or satisfaction of decree within the meaning of Section 47 CPC. A decree of a competent court should not, as far as practicable, be allowed to be defeated on account of an accidental slip or omission. In the facts and circumstances of the present case, we think it would be more appropriate to invoke Section 47 CPC.”

14. Relying upon the said decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court this Court has held in the case of Monoranjan Dutta vs. Narayan Dhar, reported in 2006 (4) GLT 160 that the failure to give a description of the suit property by giving boundaries etc. in the plaint is not fatal and can be cured at a later stage. It has been held that providing those descriptions are only optional to the plaintiff and not obligatory one.
15. From a plain reading of the provisions of Order VII Rule 3 CPC it is evident that the underlying object is to ensure that a decree involving immovable property can be executed with proper identification of the suit property and therefore the said provision is directory in nature. If there arises any confusion in identifying the property the court would be entitled to call for additional particulars and such lacunae, if any, would be curable in nature. It is not the case of the defendant/respondent that the plaintiff has deliberately suppresses the factual particulars to his knowledge despite directions passed to that effect by the Court to furnish the same. The suit not being one for recovery of immovable property, Order XX Rule 9 CPC will not have any application in the facts of the present case.
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(THE HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
PRINCIPAL SEAT AT GUWAHATI
(CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION)
R.S.A.No. 139 of 2001
APPELLANT :
Shri Dwaraka Prasad Agarwalla,

-Versus-

On the death of sole respondent
Sri Nil Kamal Bezbarua, his legal heirs :-
1. (a) Smti. Sarada Bezbarua (wife)
(b) Sri Prabhat Bezbarua (son)
(c) Sri Kamal Kishore Bezbarua (son)

BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUMAN SHYAM
Read original judgment here;click here
Citation;AIR 2015 Gauhati high court33
Print Page

Saturday, 14 March 2015

When correction of error in judgment/decree arising from “accidental slip or omission” is permissible?

Civil Procedure Code, 1908 — S. 152 and Or. 20 R. 18(2): Correction of error in judgment/decree arising from “accidental slip or omission” is permissible when error should be apparent on face of record and should not depend on discovery thereof by going into merits of the case. In order to determine whether court while carrying out amendment/correction acted within scope of powers under S. 152, pleading of parties, contents of decree and corrections made, have to be examined.


Supreme Court of India


Srihari (Dead) Through Lr. Smt. ... vs Syed Maqdoom Shah & Ors on 16 September, 2014
Bench: Sudhansu Jyoti Mukhopadhaya, Prafulla Chandra Pant
   Citation;(2015)1 scc607
Print Page