Showing posts with label second complaint case. Show all posts
Showing posts with label second complaint case. Show all posts

Wednesday, 14 June 2023

Under Which circumstances the court can entertain second criminal complaint against accused after dismissal of first complaint?

 As regards the submission made by learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Luthra that the second complaint at the instance of the Respondent No. 2 on the same set of facts against the same Accused was not maintainable, it may be noted that the law in this regard is quite well settled since 1962. In case of Pramatha Nath Talukdar v. Saroj Ranjan Sarkar MANU/SC/0149/1961 : AIR 1962 SC 876, it was held with regard to filing of the second complaint that a fresh complaint could be entertained after the dismissal of previous complaint Under Section 203 of the Code of Criminal Procedure when there was manifest error or manifest miscarriage of justice or when fresh evidence was forthcoming. It was further held that an order of dismissal Under Section 203 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is no bar to the entertainment of a second complaint on the same facts, but it will be entertained only in exceptional circumstances, e.g. that the previous order was passed on an incomplete record or on a misunderstanding of nature of complaint or it was manifestly absurd, unjust or foolish or where new facts which could not, with reasonable diligence, have been brought on record in the previous proceedings have been adduced. The precise observations made in para 48 thereof may be reproduced hereunder:


48.  An order of dismissal Under Section 203 of the Criminal Procedure Code, is, however, no bar to the entertainment of a second complaint on the same facts but it will be entertained only in exceptional circumstances, e.g., where the previous order was passed on an incomplete record or on a misunderstanding of the nature of the complaint or it was manifestly absurd, unjust or foolish or where new facts which could not, with reasonable diligence, have been brought on the record in the previous proceedings, have been adduced. It cannot be said to be in the interests of justice that after a decision has been given against the complainant upon a full consideration of his case, he or any other person should be given another opportunity to have his complaint enquired into.  {Para 14}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal Nos. 836-841 of 2023.

Decided On: 17.03.2023

Cardinal Mar George Alencherry  Vs.  State of Kerala and Ors.

Author: Bela M. Trivedi, J.

Dated: MANU/SC/0260/2023.

Print Page

Sunday, 16 September 2018

When second criminal complaint on same facts is maintainable?

This Court in the case of Udai Shankar Awasthy v. The State of U.P. [MANU/SC/0018/2013 : (2013) 2 SCC 435, para 30] has observed that "the law does not prohibit filing or entertaining of the second complaint even on the same facts provided the earlier complaint has been decided on the basis of insufficient material or the order has been passed without understanding the nature of the complaint or the complete facts could not be placed before the Court, or where the complainant came to know certain facts after disposal of the first complaint which could have tilted the balance in his favour. However, the second complaint would not be maintainable wherein the earlier complaint has been disposed on full consideration of the case of the complainant on merit". In the matter on hand, the Complainant/Appellant came to know certain facts relating to the replacement of parts of the machine after the disposal of the first complaint, that too after getting a service report from "Key Pharma Limited, Delhi", and, therefore, there is no bar for the Appellant to lodge second complaint.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 857 of 2018 (Arising from SLP (Crl.) No. 387/2018)

Decided On: 11.07.2018

 Om Prakash Singh Vs. The State of Bihar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N.V. Ramana and Mohan M. Shantanagoudar, JJ.

Print Page

Tuesday, 5 September 2017

Whether Second Complaint to Consumer forum is maintainable?

These Rules do not provide that if
a complaint is dismissed in default by the
District Forum under Rule 4(8) or by the State
Commission under Rule 8(8) of the Rules, a
second complaint would not lie. Thus, there is
no provision parallel to the provision
contained in Order 9 Rule 9(1) CPC which
contains a prohibition that if a suit is
dismissed in default of the plaintiff under
Order 9 Rule 8, a second suit on the same cause
of action would not lie. That being so, the
rule of prohibition contained in Order 9 Rule
9(1) CPC cannot be extended to the proceedings
before the District Forum or the State
Commission. The fact that the case was not
decided on merits and was dismissed in default
of non-appearance of the complainant cannot be
overlooked and, therefore, it would be
permissible to file a second complaint
explaining why the earlier complaint could not
be pursued and was dismissed in default.”
We have also not been shown any rule similar to Order
IX, Rule 9(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. That
being so, and in view of the decision rendered by this
Court, with which we have no reason to disagree, we are
of the opinion that the second complaint filed by the
appellant was maintainable on the facts of this case.
Under the circumstances, we set aside the order
passed by the National Commission and remit the matter
back to the National Commission for adjudicating the
disputes on merits.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.557 OF 2016

INDIAN MACHINERY COMPANY V M/S. ANSAL HOUSING & CONSTRUCTION LTD.
Dated:JANUARY 27, 2016
Print Page

Saturday, 28 January 2017

When second complaint in respect of same incident is liable to be quashed?

While coming to this conclusion, even the recent law
laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court can also be taken
for assistance which is reported in (2015)11 SCC page
145 in the case of Kamla Kant Dubey Vs. State of
Uttar Pradesh and Others wherein it has been
specifically laid down that FIR need not contain
every single detail and every part of the prosecution
case and therefore, when main substratum is forming
part of the FIR, it is left to the investigating
authority to investigate in detail and therefore,
stray observations made in paragraph No.18 would
definitely lead to a situation that basic substratum
of the matter is already contained in the FIR. In the
present case on hand, simply because further
information are not contained as part of first FIR
thereof would not permit respondent No.2 to lodge the
second complaint with respect to very same
controversy. Consequential steps generated by
petitioner No.1 can well be examined during the
course of investigation and therefore, it seems that
this second complaint tantamount to have been used as
a lever to pressurise the petitioners which in no
circumstances can be permitted by this Court. The
Court is sufficiently empowered under section 482 of
Cr.P.C. to embark upon such an attempt if made to

misuse the process of law. Therefore, the background
of fact is sufficient enough to hold that second
complaint is required to be quashed in the interest
of justice.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
CRIMINAL MISC.APPLICATION NO. 14624 of 2007

VIJAYCHANDRA PRAKASH SHUKLA & 2.
V
STATE OF GUJARAT & 1.

CORAM: MR.JUSTICE A.J. SHASTRI
Date : 27/01/2017

Print Page

Friday, 29 January 2016

Whether second complaint under Consumer Protection Act is maintainable when first complaint was dismissed for default for non prosecution?

Our attention has been drawn to a decision of this
Court in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. R. Srinivasan
[(2000) 3 SCC 242] wherein this precise question had
arisen as mentioned in paragraph 5 of this decision. It
is mentioned in that paragraph that the only question is
that in view of the dismissal of the first complaint
filed by the respondent therein, a second complaint on
the same facts and cause of action would not lie and it
ought to have been dismissed as not maintainable.
While dealing with this issue, this Court held in
paragraph 16 as follows:
“This Rule [Rule 9(6) of the Tamil Nadu
Consumer Protection Rules, 1988] is in
identical terms with sub-rule (8) of Rule 4 and
sub-rule (8) of Rule 8. Under this sub-rule,
the appeal filed before the State Commission
against the order of the District Forum, can be
dismissed in default or the State Commission
may in its discretion dispose of it on merits.
Similar power has been given to the National
Commission under Rule 15(6) of the Rules made
by the Central Government under Section 30(1)
of the Act. These Rules do not provide that if
a complaint is dismissed in default by the
District Forum under Rule 4(8) or by the State
Commission under Rule 8(8) of the Rules, a
second complaint would not lie. Thus, there is
no provision parallel to the provision
contained in Order 9 Rule 9(1) CPC which
contains a prohibition that if a suit is
dismissed in default of the plaintiff under
Order 9 Rule 8, a second suit on the same cause
of action would not lie. That being so, the
rule of prohibition contained in Order 9 Rule
9(1) CPC cannot be extended to the proceedings
before the District Forum or the State
Commission. The fact that the case was not
decided on merits and was dismissed in default
of non-appearance of the complainant cannot be
overlooked and, therefore, it would be
permissible to file a second complaint
explaining why the earlier complaint could not
be pursued and was dismissed in default.”
We have also not been shown any rule similar to Order
IX, Rule 9(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. That
being so, and in view of the decision rendered by this
Court, with which we have no reason to disagree, we are
of the opinion that the second complaint filed by the
appellant was maintainable on the facts of this case.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.557 OF 2016
(Arising out of SLP(C) No.19618 of 2013)
INDIAN MACHINERY COMPANY APPELLANT(s)
 VERSUS
M/S. ANSAL HOUSING & CONSTRUCTION LTD.
Dated;JANUARY 27, 2016
Citation:AIR 2016 SC 2209
Print Page

Thursday, 26 November 2015

Whether second criminal complaint case for distinct offence on same facts is tenable after discharge of accused in prior proceedings?

Having perused Section 300, we are satisfied, that the
submission advanced at the hands of the learned counsel for the
respondent, namely, that Section 300 of the Criminal Procedure
Code, will be an embargo to obstruct the right of the appellant to
file a second complaint against the respondent, is not justified.
Our above determination is based on the fact, that the respondent
had not been tried, in furtherance of the previous complaint made
by the appellant, under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code. The
contention of the learned counsel for the appellant, that the
respondent had been discharged in furtherance of the complaint made
by the appellant, without any trial having been conducted against
him (the respondent), was not disputed. Based on the above factual
contention, learned counsel for the appellant had placed emphatic
reliance, on the explanation under Section 300 of the Criminal
Procedure Code. The explanation relied upon, clearly mandates that
the dismissal of a complaint, or the discharge of an accused, would
not be construed as an acquittal, for the purposes of this Section.
In this view of the matter, we are in agreement with the contention
advanced at the hands of the learned counsel for the appellant. We
are of the considered view, that proceedings in the second
complaint would not be barred, because no trial had been conducted
 REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
 CRIMINAL APPEAL No.457 OF 2008
RAVINDER KAUR V ANIL KUMAR 


Citation;(2015)8 SCC286

Print Page

Sunday, 13 September 2015

Whether complaint once dismissed by magistrate for default can be refiled?

If the dismissal of the complaint was not on merit but on default of the complainant to be present there is no bar in the complainant moving the magistrate again with a second complaint on the same facts. But if the dismissal of the complaint under Section 203 of the Code was on merits the position could be different. There appeared a difference of opinion earlier as to whether a second complaint could have been filed when the dismissal was under Section 203. The controversy was settled by this Court in Pramatha Nath Talukdar vs. Saroj Ranjan Sarkar (AIR 1962 SC 876). A majority of Judges of the three Judge Bench held thus: An order of dismissal under S.203,Criminal Procedure Code, is, however, no bar to the entertainment of a second complaint on the same facts but it will be entertained only in exceptional circumstances, e.g., where the previous order was passed on an incomplete record or on a misunderstanding of the nature of the complaint or it was manifestly absurd, unjust or foolish or where new facts which could not, with reasonable diligence, have been brought on the record in the previous proceedings, have been adduced. It cannot be said to be in the interest of justice that after a decision has been given against the complainant upon a full consideration of his case, he or any other person should be given another opportunity to have his complaint enquired into.
Supreme Court of India
Jatinder Singh & Ors vs Ranjit Kaur on 30 January, 2001

Bench: R.P.Sethi, K.T.Thomas
Print Page

Wednesday, 2 October 2013

Whether Second complaint would be maintainable when earlier one had not been dismissed on merits?


He relied upon a precedent of the Hon'ble Apex Court rendered in case of Ranvir Singh v. State of Haryana & Another reported in (2010) 1 SCC (Cri) 96, wherein a similar controversy as to whether such a second complaint would be maintainable when the earlier one had not been dismissed on merits, but for the failure of the complainant to put in the process fees for effecting service came up for adjudication before the Hon'ble Apex Court. While deciding the said controversy, the Apex Court at paragraph 26 has held as under:
"The said situation is mainly covered by the decision of this Court in Jatinder Singh case, wherein the decision in Pramatha Nath Talukdar case was also taken into consideration and it was categorically observed 3
that in the absence of any provision in the Code barring a second complaint being filed on the same allegation, there would be no bar to a second complaint being filed on the same facts if the first complaint did not result in the conviction or acquittal or even discharge of the accused, and if the dismissal was not on merit but on account of a default on the part of the complainant."1

Uttaranchal High Court
Pankaj Kumar vs State Of Uttarakhand & Another on 11 October, 2011

Print Page

Thursday, 30 August 2012

Whether second protest petition and second complaint case is maintainable?

It is evident that the law does not prohibit filing or entertaining of the second complaint even on the same facts provided the earlier complaint has been decided on the basis of insufficient 
material or the order has been passed without understanding the nature of the complaint or the complete facts could not be placed before the court or where the complainant came to know certain facts after disposal of the first complaint which could have tilted the balance in his favour. However, second complaint would not be maintainable wherein the earlier complaint has been disposed of on full consideration of the case of the complainant on merit.

14. The Protest Petition can always be treated as a complaint and proceeded with in terms of Chapter XV of Cr.P.C. Therefore, in case there is no bar to entertain a second complaint on the same facts, in exceptional circumstances, the second Protest Petition can also similarly be entertained only under exceptional circumstances. In case the first Protest Petition has been filed without furnishing the full facts/particulars necessary to decide the case, and prior to its entertainment by the court, a fresh Protest Petition is filed giving full details, we fail to understand as to why it should not be maintainable.

Supreme Court of India
Shiv Shankar Singh vs State Of Bihar & Anr. on 22 November, 2011
Bench: B.S. Chauhan, T.S. Thakur
Print Page