We have given our anxious consideration to the submissions made by advocate Mr. Talekar, appearing for the accused. The Doctor (PW.4) was cross examined at length on technical aspects regarding difference between signs of strangulation and hanging. We have reproduced some important portions of his admissions. But after taking over all view of the evidence of Doctor we are of the opinion that the defence has succeeded in creating doubt about the case of the prosecution that Seema died as a result of strangulation. It is basic principle of criminal law that it is for the prosecution to prove a case against accused beyond reasonable doubt and, if it is a case of murder, then the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that Seema died as a result of strangulation and strangulation alone. This test in criminal law is not satisfied by the prosecution. In any case the defence has succeeded in creating doubt about this story of strangulation particularly when the case is entirely based on circumstantial evidence, absence of motive and nobody seeing the accused in the house when Seema died on that night. {Para18}
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Criminal Appeal No. 276 of 2001
Decided On: 12.07.2006
Surendra Gyanchand Chawla Vs. The State of Maharashtra
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
D.G. Deshpande and V.M. Kanade, JJ.
Author: D.G. Deshpande, J.
Citation: 2006 All M R (Cri.)2262,
2006CRILJ3694, MANU/MH/0387/2006
Print Page