Showing posts with label validity of marriage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label validity of marriage. Show all posts

Wednesday, 11 March 2015

What is distinction between proof of marriage and validity of marriage?


I am unable to agree with the contention of learned counsel for the appellants. There is a distinction between proof of marriage and validity of marriage. The proof of marriage can be achieved, by direct evidence of the marriage ceremony or registration of marriage or by circumstantial evidence, one of the circumstances being long cohabitation and living together. But, a marriage which is questioned on the ground of being subsequent to and during the subsistence of an earlier marriage, could not, by any stretch of argument or imagination, be sanctified or validated by any length of cohabitation or living together. After the advent of Tamil Nadu Hindu (Bigamy Prevention and Divorce Act, 1949 and Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the second marriage during the subsistence of the first marriage is totally void, illegal and opposed to public policy. No amount of pleading or proof of custom or consent by wife can validate such a marriage.


Madras High Court


Chinnammal And 8 Others vs Elumalai And 4 Others on 14 January, 2000
Equivalent citations: 2000 (2) CTC 214, II (2000) DMC 278
Bench: K Sivasubramaniam



Print Page

Friday, 13 February 2015

Whether validity of Marriage can be challenged in proceeding for succession certificate?

 Challenging the judgment of the learned District Judge, the appellant's learned counsel argued that in the proceeding for the grant of a succession certificate consequent on the death of Tula Ram, the validity of marriage of Tula Ram with Smt. Ram Pyari could not be questioned. The submission was that a marriage on the ground of breach of Section 5(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act can be set aside only at the instance of one of the spouses and if no application for declaration of the marriage is made by either of the spouses, the marriage becomes immune from challenge. For this submission reliance had been placed on the decision of Smt. Sheelwati v. Smt. Ram Nandani (AIR 1981 All 42) (supra) in which the learned Judge held that no third person can treat the marriage to be void and as such it cannot be so adjudicated in any suit or proceeding.
 For what we have said above we do not agree with the law laid down in Sheelwati v. Smt. Ram Nandani (AIR 1981 All 42). We answer the question by saying that the validity of a void marriage being in contravention of the provisions of Section 5(i) rend with Section 11 of the Hindu Marriage Act can be gone into at the instance of a third aggrieved party even after the death of one of the spouses to the marriage.
Allahabad High Court
Smt. Ram Pyari vs Dharam Das And Ors. on 28 September, 1983
Equivalent citations: AIR 1984 All 147

Bench: K Agrawal, O Saxena
Print Page