It appears that the appellant herein has accepted the order and sought
for time to pay the costs. Moreover, it did not choose to approach the
appellate Court assailing the order and the same has attained finality. In
spite of the same, the appellant filed the application opposing the
execution petition filed by the respondents. The first and foremost
ground of attack against the order passed by the English Court is that
the order is not conclusive as per Section 13(b), CPC. Such argument
appears to be attractive but we are not able to appreciate the same in the
facts and circumstances of the case. Before we proceed further, it is
appropriate to have a look at Sections 13 and 14 of CPC which read as
under:
Section 13. When foreign judgment not conclusive : A
foreign judgment shall be conclusive as to any matter
thereby directly adjudicated upon between the same parties
or between parties under whom they or any of them claim
litigating under the same title except—
(a) where it has not been pronounced by a Court of
competent jurisdiction;
(b) where it has not been given on the merits of the case;
(c) where it appears on the face of the proceedings to be
founded on an incorrect view of international law or a
refusal to recognise the law of India in cases in which such
law is applicable;
(d) where the proceedings in which the judgment was
obtained are opposed to natural justice;
(e) where it has been obtained by fraud;
(f) where it sustains a claim founded on a breach of any
law in force in India.
Section 14. Presumption as to foreign judgments: The Court
shall presume upon the production of any document
purporting to be a certified copy of a foreign judgment that
such judgment was pronounced by a Court of competent
jurisdiction, unless the contrary appears on the record; but
such presumption may be displaced by proving want of
jurisdiction.
13. A plain reading of Section 13, CPC would show that to be conclusive an
order or decree must have been obtained after following the due judicial
process by giving reasonable notice and opportunity to all the proper and
necessary parties to put forth their case. When once these requirements
are fulfilled, the executing Court cannot enquire into the validity, legality
Print Page
for time to pay the costs. Moreover, it did not choose to approach the
appellate Court assailing the order and the same has attained finality. In
spite of the same, the appellant filed the application opposing the
execution petition filed by the respondents. The first and foremost
ground of attack against the order passed by the English Court is that
the order is not conclusive as per Section 13(b), CPC. Such argument
appears to be attractive but we are not able to appreciate the same in the
facts and circumstances of the case. Before we proceed further, it is
appropriate to have a look at Sections 13 and 14 of CPC which read as
under:
Section 13. When foreign judgment not conclusive : A
foreign judgment shall be conclusive as to any matter
thereby directly adjudicated upon between the same parties
or between parties under whom they or any of them claim
litigating under the same title except—
(a) where it has not been pronounced by a Court of
competent jurisdiction;
(b) where it has not been given on the merits of the case;
(c) where it appears on the face of the proceedings to be
founded on an incorrect view of international law or a
refusal to recognise the law of India in cases in which such
law is applicable;
(d) where the proceedings in which the judgment was
obtained are opposed to natural justice;
(e) where it has been obtained by fraud;
(f) where it sustains a claim founded on a breach of any
law in force in India.
Section 14. Presumption as to foreign judgments: The Court
shall presume upon the production of any document
purporting to be a certified copy of a foreign judgment that
such judgment was pronounced by a Court of competent
jurisdiction, unless the contrary appears on the record; but
such presumption may be displaced by proving want of
jurisdiction.
13. A plain reading of Section 13, CPC would show that to be conclusive an
order or decree must have been obtained after following the due judicial
process by giving reasonable notice and opportunity to all the proper and
necessary parties to put forth their case. When once these requirements
are fulfilled, the executing Court cannot enquire into the validity, legality
or otherwise of the judgment.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 10106 OF 2016
ARISING OUT OF
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 19791 OF 2013
M/S ALCON ELECTRONICS PVT. LTD
V
CELEM S.A. OF FOS 34320 ROUJAN, FRANCE & ANR.
Dated:DECEMBER 09, 2016
Citation:(2017) 2 SCC253
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 10106 OF 2016
ARISING OUT OF
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 19791 OF 2013
M/S ALCON ELECTRONICS PVT. LTD
V
CELEM S.A. OF FOS 34320 ROUJAN, FRANCE & ANR.
Dated:DECEMBER 09, 2016
Citation:(2017) 2 SCC253

